There is more, much more, regarding our humanity and the mind body link which science does not have qualitative ways of exploring.
The placebo is mentally administered, has a 100% success rate at provably halting the condition for a indeterminate amount of time. It also works in reverse, and is quite dangerous when used this way.
It's one of my LLM tests to have the LLM come to the conclusion based on available data on the condition (as it was my only source). Today, no LLM has passed the test.
I hope this helps.
It's also obnoxious for you to play obfuscatory gatekeeper with grown ass adults, and it makes your word less valuable not more.
> It also works in reverse, and is quite dangerous when used this way.
We're adults. We get to make our own mistakes if we want to. Thank you for the warning, but please provide the information so we can decide what to do with it for ourselves instead of patronizing your audience. Otherwise it really does make you sound like a crank, unfortunate as that may be.
I have no desire or need to prove anything on the internet. I provided enough information for a motivated person to determine what was said and apply it themselves.
Feel free to submit detailed results to peer review. 100% success rates have been too rare, these days.
There's some questions in the person's post that I was providing some reflection on. The truth of my comment, or any peer reviewed study for that matter, is up to the reader.
It's funny because the idea of a mental placebo requires the user to place their trust in the very same.
Have a good day.
That wouldn’t be the placebo effect then, it would be more of a psychological phenomenon in the realm of how your mental outlook can influence how you experience pain. That is also heavily studied.
Edit: This video is good intro to the placebo effect: “Harnessing the power of placebos” Alia Crumb, 2017 (video) https://youtu.be/WcQnSW1wpGA?si=A2tzqvd45BLiMADW
Edit 2: I think what you’re describing is generally called “pain tolerance”.
I agree! But I would argue that a lot, if not most or even all, of what gets called a placebo effect is confounded by these obviously-not-placebo-effect-as-defined effects without any distinction and to me that casts the field into myopic disrepute.
> I think what you’re describing is generally called “pain tolerance”.
No, I think that's yet another different thing.
I've been a lot more attentive to this kind of stuff lately due to some chronic health stuff that came up in the family. I think there's probably some framework in modern medicine that makes it less prone to adopting these kinds of methods. Maybe it's just historical baggage, who knows...
I.e. you mentioned "sticking a needle next to the right nerve" - that's a valid research question...and it was studied. Turns out sticking needles where an acupuncture specialist thinks they should go, versus just randomly has the same reported effect in trials.
I'm not sure that invalidates my broader point in any case, but good to know!
When I feel like my symptoms have improved, that is factually distinct from my symptoms having improved. Ok, so far so obvious. But it is also factually distinct from me really feeling like my symptoms have improved. It may very well be that I'm just not sure and that I subconsciously lean toward giving the benefit of the doubt as a tie-breaker for my own uncertainty. And then I can feel better about that without the underlying symptom improving, and that is definitely factually distinct from the symptom improving.
The impact would obviously be age-related, since age equals exposure to factors like social influence, introspective knowledge of the limits of self evaluation, and so on.
And it is not the same thing as a placebo effect improving the symptom itself. I can be experiencing the exact same amount of pain but wishy-washy on the evaluation, but people report on the placebo effect as though it means I experience less pain. But maybe I'm just less frustrated by the pain, or less inclined to admit the pain to myself or to others, or less inclined to trust myself. Maybe believing feels good, so I want to do it.