Re:All Placebos are not created equal
by BugsJustFindMe on Sunday March 23, 2025 @04:03PM
(#43455467)
> That wouldn’t be the placebo effect then
I agree! But I would argue that a lot, if not most or even all, of what gets called a placebo effect is confounded by these obviously-not-placebo-effect-as-defined effects without any distinction and to me that casts the field into myopic disrepute.
> I think what you’re describing is generally called “pain tolerance”.
No, I think that's yet another different thing.
You get that these studies aren't actually measuring pain, right? They're measuring things like "how the patient rates the pain on a scale of 1-10". The difference between a "genuine" placebo and a "psychological" placebo is not detectable in that data.
That wouldn’t be the placebo effect then, it would be more of a psychological phenomenon in the realm of how your mental outlook can influence how you experience pain. That is also heavily studied.
Edit: This video is good intro to the placebo effect: “Harnessing the power of placebos” Alia Crumb, 2017 (video) https://youtu.be/WcQnSW1wpGA?si=A2tzqvd45BLiMADW
Edit 2: I think what you’re describing is generally called “pain tolerance”.