We're kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place here. Which do you prefer, entrenched incumbents or affordable/open hosting?
Anonymous browsing and potentially-malicious bots look identical. This was sort of OK up until now.
If you thought browser fingerprinting for ad tracking was creepy, just wait until they're using your actual fingerprint.
Granted, I'm not looking forward to some LLM condensing all the garbage and handing me a Definitive Answer (TM) based on the information it deems relevant for inclusion.
AI companies with best anti-captcha mechanics will win and will inject ads to LLM output in more sophisticated way.
OpenAI goes through initial cycle of enshittification. Google is too big right now. Once they establish dominance you will have to see 5 unskippable ads between prompts, even for paid plan.
I solved user problems for myself. Most of my web projects use client side processing. I moved to github pages. So clients can use my projects with no down time. Pages use SQLite as source of data. First browser downloads the SQLite model, then it uses it to display data on client side.
Example 'search' project: https://rumca-js.github.io/search
> I solved user problems for myself. Most of my web projects use client side processing. I moved to github pages. So clients can use my projects with no down time. Pages use SQLite as source of data. First browser downloads the SQLite model, then it uses it to display data on client side.
> Example 'search' project: https://rumca-js.github.io/search
That is not really solution. Since typical indexing still works for masses, your approach is currently unique. But in the end, bots will be capable of reading on web page context if human is capable on reading them. And we get back to the original problem where we try to detect bots from humans. It's the only way.
Only if you operate on the scale of Cloudflare, etc. you can see which IP addresses are hitting a large number of servers in a short time span.
(I am pretty sure next they will hand out N free LLM requests per month in exchange of user machines doing the scraping if blocking gets more succesful.)
I fear the only solution in the end are CDNs, making visits expensive using challenges, or requiring users to log in.
I don't really know about this proposal; the majority of bots are going to be coming from residential IPs the minute you do this.[1]
[1] The AI SaaS will simply run a background worker on the client to do their search indexing.
Is it going to become another race like the adblocker -> detect adblocker -> bypass adblocker detector and so on...?
This is because the only way to stop the bots is with a captcha, and this also stops search indexers from indexing your site. This will result in search engines not indexing sites, and hence providing no value anymore.
There's probably going to be a small lag as the current knowledge in the current LLMs dry up because no one can scrape the web in an automated fashion anymore.
It'll all burn down.