News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:02AM (#43422592)
Dump Office and Teams. Easy to do and a great start to move outside of Windows OS.

LibreOffice is perfect, and government officials wont govern better or worst, if their PowerPoint presentations don't have the latest MS fonts....

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by mstipetic on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:05AM (#43422647)
I’m all for open source but suggesting libre office is perfect is a bit too much for me
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by eitland on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:51AM (#43423428)
It is not perfect, but in a number of areas it is significantly better than MS Office, and this has been the case since it was still OpenOffice back in 2005: I'd import collaborative schoolwork into Open Office to fix the mismatch of styles that other students had used[1] and then (to be fair) I'd export it back to Word format and do final formatting in Word to get the exact layouts and page numering options that was demanded from us.

Today MS Office is still broken in a number of crazy ways. One of the most annoying ones is that if whoever packages and deploys Office to our computers use localization for the user interface, suddenly all formulas are in some broken local language variant making it next to impossible to search for it.

If I know the solution with standard Excel language it is doable to translate it to this broken "Norwegian BASIC" language, it is just really really annoying.

A quick and easy solution then is to write it in Libre Office Calc, export it to xls and import it and done.

With Libre Office I can also choose if I want cute "Ribbon" menus or easy-to-use menus.

List probably goes on, this was just the things from the top of my head.

[1]because it felt almost impossible to do in an efficient way in MS Office even if I had significantly more experience with it)

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by consp on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:09AM (#43422698)
Good enough for the vast majority. Just not the ones making the decisions. And when it is changed, you have to fight all m$ because it keeps breaking formats and compatibility let alone standardisation with others.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bayindirh on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:16AM (#43422826)
LibreOffice works for 99.99% of the cases where Microsoft Office is being used. Moreover, NextCloud offers a free "LibreOffice on the web" capability if you prefer.

Oh, BTW. Nextcloud is also nice. Very nice.

Edit: Looks like Owncloud guys have arrived (just joking, I like them equally).

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bloopernova on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:28AM (#43423031)
I got access to a NextCloud instance as part of my Hetzner storage.

Setting up access for my wife was easy. Adding "apps" to my nextcloud instance was easy. Sharing storage, playing with a Kanban board, editing documents, it all just works.

I'm very impressed with nextcloud, I had no idea it was so good!

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bayindirh on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:32AM (#43423090)
Installing it on a bare metal server is equally easy. Not a walk in the park, but half a day at most, with server optimizations and polish.

It updates nicely too. I'm managing one for ~4 years now, and it's painless.

Nobody calls for me for support either. I think this is, good?

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:08AM (#43422688)
Perfect for 98% of the things government officials are using Word, Excel and PowerPoint for...
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by kristiandupont on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:35AM (#43424081)
If you have a spreadsheet with macros that are anything more than the most basic, you can't run it in Calc. It's not that trivial.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:07PM (#43429551)
The 2% ...And your company logic should not be in the Macros.

"The Wall of Shame for the Worst Excel Errors" - https://www.solving-finance.com/post/the-wall-of-shame-for-t...

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by kristiandupont on Friday March 21, 2025 @02:11AM (#43432310)
Right, so your argument is that this is easy, and if it turns out that it's not, we'll just be smug and tell them that they were holding it wrong all along?

It sounds like you are picturing in your head that all spreadsheet work is greenfield. Do you have any idea how much Excel code is embedded everywhere? Very often made by people who are no longer around. You can lecture all you want, but this is the situation. I don't like it either.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Friday March 21, 2025 @09:43AM (#43435609)
Relax...the weekend almost here... :-)

Did not intend to be smug...honestly..not really. :-) In my defense, I have more than 20 years corporate experience in tech AND finance domains, in more than 25 countries. And in the cultural domains of the five different languages I am familiar and whose grammar I regularly brutalize. Can't recognize the problem you are describing, as the mountain that would stop any company from start using LibreOffice.

All that logic in Excel sheets is just a serious governance problem...

"How an Excel error cost JP Morgan $6 billion" - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/eriklidman_how-an-excel-error...

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by whywhywhywhy on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:49AM (#43424900)
Suggesting LibreOffice 19 years after Google Docs is so weird to me.

Are you expecting people to shuffle around single files to each other every time something is changed? Is that what we consider perfect?

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:13PM (#43425183)
Except for emailing Linux kernel patches...:-) Do people for example do that with Code in 2025? Or do they use Version Management and Shared Portals with document locking?

Are most companies having three or four employees working in the SAME document at the SAME time? Maybe while singing Kumbaya over Teams? That would not be very efficient...

Or just use: https://www.collaboraonline.com/

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by kennysoona on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:34PM (#43428597)
It's about not putting your data in the hands of a US company.

Collaboration can be managed by offline servers that facilitate that. Not everything needs to be in a web page.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by grimblee on Friday March 21, 2025 @03:05AM (#43432587)
The files can be on a shared filesystem with open file locking, the word processing suite is irrelevant.

Samba existed long before google docs and already did this.

We only use google because of the convenience of having everything in one interface. I think this is the real issue, we are all so lazy we would rather give away our freedom for a little bit of convenience.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:13PM (#43425173)
A suggestion to dump Office and Teams and move out of Windows, selectively down voted out of a whole thread...Fascinating....
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by baq on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:15AM (#43422796)
LibreOffice calc is barely usable for the smallest spreadsheets. Google sheets is better, but comes with its own set of issues and dumb limitations. Excel is at this point in time irreplaceable.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by eitland on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:54AM (#43423481)
> LibreOffice calc is barely usable for the smallest spreadsheets.

Citation very much needed :-)

Excel on the other hand is barely usable for anything that involves formulas for us who are forced to used the localized version.

In fact if one is stuck with a localized Excel the easiest way is often to write in LibreOffice Calc and then export it to xls format.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bayindirh on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:17AM (#43422840)
Genuinely curious. Can you elaborate?
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by hylaride on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:24AM (#43422971)
I don't think people realize how much of the world runs off of excel, especially the financial world. Excel still "supports" buggy issues from versions in the 1990s as to not break financial models.

IBM mainframes do the same thing with COBOL because modernizing core code means having to notify and test all the downstream users that have their own code to deal with the legacy issues in the current stack. I was once explained by a retired COBOL programmer (who spends his summers contracting for maintenance) how this tangled mess of thousands of banks feeds in all the way to the US central bank to determine interest rates - in some extreme cases, IBM still has to emulate hardware bugs as to not change expected behaviour. This is not something you just migrate away from or fuck around with. There's a reason IBM still sells mainframes that runs code from the 1960s.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bayindirh on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:28AM (#43423023)
I know what you mean, but now you're talking about a very niche market. Finance, which uses Excel or spreadsheets since 90s. You can't replace these, I agree.

But for other uses of Excel, I can say it can be easily exchanged. This is why I used 99.99% percent, but not more nines. The remaining "three nines" are the niches you're talking about.

It's like how we say "Nah, it's a small set of matrices. just 2, 3000x3000, double precision floating point matrices, and a couple of vectors and some multiplication (i.e. in a range of a couple of billions)".

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by hylaride on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:53AM (#43423456)
It sounds like a niche market, but every company in the world has a finance department that plugs everything from sales forecasts, various inputs (goods, employment, supply chain components, etc), to things we don't even think of that flow through it. At some point these companies are talking with other companies and a shocking amount of data interchange is done by emailing excel spreadsheets around (or CSVs exported from excel).

I forget about it myself as I've worked for modern tech companies since 2008, but outside of that world is a very different place where old ways of doing things stick around. Anecdotally, about 2 years ago I got a cold email from a co-op job that I had in 2002 for a manufacturing company that I wrote a perl script for asking for help modernizing it. The perl script consolidated raw EDI(1) files coming into some ancient HP-UX machine, then exported it...to an excel file, MS Access DB, and a SAP DB so that the accountants and the manufacturers could simultaneously get work processing the order. When I started people were inputting these all manually.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_data_interchange

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:38AM (#43423178)
I recently switched from Excel. I'm not a FOSS ideologue, but I found that Calc does more of the things I need with less of the distraction, more customisability, and less irritation with bugs and breaking updates.

It's true I'm not a spreadsheet power user - but not many people are.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @03:33PM (#43427853)
The trouble is that excel really does have a disproportionate share of all the tiny applications that keep the world running, so it's very very hard to move.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by Lanolderen on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:36AM (#43423160)
I remember back in the 00s Excel could support millions of rows on an office PC used in a bank department to check approvals for loans. I don't want to know what perversions they're doing now but at some point all that needs to get in normal DBs.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by bayindirh on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:40AM (#43423218)
Excel has native DB connectivity for quite some time. Maybe they were using that, actually?

Libreoffice Calc also supports the same thing over ODBC AFAIK.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by Lanolderen on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:50AM (#43423408)
Damn, you might be right. I even made a tutorial on Excel ODBC for our sales department recently and completely forgot it's ancient tech. But even then, why in the hell would you query that much shit outside of management diagrams...
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by sodapopcan on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:41AM (#43423243)
> I don't think people realize how much of the world runs off of excel, especially the financial world.

Most people working in software understand this as a huge chunk of software projects are "let's get these people off of their spreadsheets!"

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by throwaway798214 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:54AM (#43423468)
Client company of mine likes to document server rack layouts with Excel sheets (not a bad idea really). I used LibreOffice for years to _read_ those Excels, but any time I would write the smallest change the whole Excel sheet broke... In the end I just bought Office (one-time payment still exists) and while that company is using Macs and I'm using Windows we never have any problems sharing and modifying those xls files.
Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:54AM (#43423469)
Feature Comparison: LibreOffice - Microsoft Office

https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Feature_Comparison:_Libr...

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by piokoch on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:46AM (#43423333)
Nah, it is not gonna be that simple. Office is not just editing software, that would be fairly easy to replace, Office is a collaboration suite, provides documents storage, provides authorization and authentication that can be integrated with practically anything companies, governments, universities are using.

Can we go back to '90 and relay on sending documents by email?

Building an alternative, even on the level of Google Docs, which has editing capabilities on the MS Word 2.0 level, is not gonna be simple, although I am surprised that European Union is ready to spend a lot of money on adjusting caps to bottles (this costed billions), but is not able to invest into its own capabilities in terms of IT infrastructure.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:46AM (#43424208)
Easier than it looks.The EU is currently still sending 200 Billion EUR a year in oil and gas imports to Russia per year.

A peanuts project of 100 million EUR ( basically one Microsoft Global Customer Contract...) could get something like this or similar going within 24 months:

https://www.collaboraonline.com/

As long as it would not be managed by EU bureaucrats. Otherwise the tenders would take 18 months....

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by sabjut on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:28AM (#43423025)
I would much rather see a viable alternative to Google Docs with at least an attempt at feature parity.

I have yet to see a solution that has a chance at comparison, especially considering performance and features.

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:55AM (#43424305)
It seems the Microsoft influencer team [1] is again all over this thread. They must have some alerts...

Reminder LibreOffice for most things is better than Office - Feature Comparison: LibreOffice - Microsoft Office: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Feature_Comparison:_Libr...

[1] "In fact, this morning, I was reading a news article in Hacker News, which is a community where we have been working hard to make sure that Azure is growing in popularity and I was pleasantly surprised to see that we have made a lot of progress in some sense that at least basically said that we are neck to neck with Amazon when it comes to even lead developers as represented in that community..."

[1] https://www.kickscondor.com/satya-nadella-'reads''games'-hac...

Re:Dutch Parliament: Time to ditch US tech for homegrown opt... by belter on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:55PM (#43425699)
A proof Microsoft has sock puppet accounts here, from the words of their own CEO, selectively down voted out of a whole thread...Fascinating....