I agree that there's potential here, though, and do genuinely hope that we find ways to make human intelligence better as we're going about AI research. Even pessimistically, I think we'll at least surface approaches that people use without thinking about, which is on its own a good thing, because once you know you're doing something, it becomes a lot easier to train yourself to do it better.
There's that quote from Socrates, recorded by Plato:
> For this invention will produce forgetfulness in the minds of those who learn to use it, because they will not practice their memory. Their trust in writing, produced by external characters which are no part of themselves, will discourage the use of their own memory within them.
I don't think anyone today could recite Beowulf from heart. But 1500 years ago that's exactly how it was enjoyed.
Look at these people that will declaim Pi digits, just because.
Also there are difference in education over different cultural era, not only through time but also space. I heard that India for example value more repetition, where western culture is more in love with innovation. These are of course nothing like exclusive tendencies.
Now if you look at antic Greece, it's certainly not like everyone would be able to restitute Homer word for word. Actually it's easy to forget how divided in term of linguistic and social classes this societies where, and focus solely on the most renowned figures as if they where all part of a tight social group full of solidarity and genius. Actually even a guy like Hippias of Elis can be both depicted by plato as exhibiting all the tremendous admirable feats of the time, including mastering the art of mnemonics, and yet turned into a clueless bragger that isn't even able to recognize that he just doesn't know how to define beauty.
Is this the case? I was under the impression they memorized the plot beats and filled in details on the fly. Also using set phrases or epithets like "Gray-eyed Athena" to slow down the narration and let them plan further.
[0] "A Record of Learning about Government" [政學錄] Magistrates handbooks, Author Zheng Duan [鄭端] (compilation), Early Qing Dynasty (1644-1796)
But there are other factors, like, is the amount of outcomes done also changing, thus affecting the absolute number of errors?
Also, does the side effect of disengage the person in most cases means it has side effects like not paying the same attention to what would stand out as a big issue that needs more attention and consideration than business as usual?
And so on
However, research[1] suggests that relying on AI tools degrades reasoning and cognitive ability regardless of your cognitive ability, and may even cause users to stop making their own choices[2].
1. https://www.404media.co/microsoft-study-finds-ai-makes-human...
The Buddha (from the Pali Canon, Vinaya Pitaka, Cullavagga 10:4):
“Writing is like a drug that weakens memory.”
and: “Do not go upon what has been acquired by repeated hearing; nor upon tradition; nor upon rumor... But when you yourselves know: 'These things are good; these things are not blameable; undertaken and observed, these things lead to benefit and happiness,' enter on and abide in them.”
Confucius (Analects 2:15):
“Learning without thought is labor lost; thought without learning is perilous.”
Lao Tzu (Tao Te Ching, Chapter 48):
“In the pursuit of learning, every day something is acquired. In the pursuit of Tao, every day something is dropped.”
Jesus (Matthew 16:26):
“For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?”
Muhammad (Hadith, Sahih Muslim):
“The worst vessel to fill is the stomach; sufficient for the child of Adam are a few morsels to keep his back straight. If he must fill it, then one-third food, one-third drink, and one-third air.”
(This Hadith symbolically warns against excessive reliance on external consumption diminishing spiritual clarity and internal balance.)
Rumi (Masnavi):
“These outward forms are but dust and air; Seek the reality beyond appearance and form.”
Krishna (Bhagavad Gita, 2:42-43):
“Those who are attached to pleasure and power, whose minds are drawn away by such things, have no capacity for absorption into higher states of awareness.”
Even things like confession, or therapy, leverage this - people letting go of bad things that are hanging around in their memory.
Also remember, your conclusion itself is "the devil" - the trap of the analytical mind. :) You will likely do everything you can do avoid the fact that you may be disagreeing directly with the word of the creator as given via various prophets, if you go back to the sources, the command is quite clear, however humans will interpret it: because the command is too simple and terrifying to adhere to. It seems impossible to us that we should indeed, be doing nothing but living in nature in a state of oral tradition and anything outside of that is an unintended state, trusting that energy cannot be destroyed and we are nothing but energy. I don't particularly like it either tbh, hence I'm writing a book about it.
What would he say if the collective IQ drops by 30 points in case of a power outage?
What would he say if people need a subscription in order to "think"?
As someone who comes from a long ancestral line of people who talk to themselves while reasoning through problems - it would occasionally prove to be a minor handicap during proctored exams, as internal monologue isn't really the same thing.
So you may have to use the SLI bridge again just to make sense of what the other side is hearing.
Girlfriend, coming in from outside: "Who are you talking to?"
Me: "I talk to myself. You know that."
Gf: "Oh right. You also whisper to yourself, which is scary."
Me: "Scary?"
Gf: "It sounds demonic."
Which, to be fair... Evidently, my internal monologuing gets quite a bit vocal even with other people around.
He told me later he too does a lot of internal monologue for stuff as well and was told by some super successful businessman that this is a good thing and a hallmark of successful people so don't be discouraged by it.
Research is extrapolation.
Neural networks are interpolators, they are notoriously bad at extrapolation. For simple example, look at pendigits data set [1]. The test part of pendigits is taken from different "writers" than train part and neural networks aren't that good at it.
[1] https://archive.ics.uci.edu/dataset/81/pen+based+recognition...
Humans do extrapolation all the time.
Actually writing out all thinking steps helps with ironing out some wrong steps in my reasoning or going in circles due to having limited working memory.
I started doing this more rigorously after seeing how reasoning based AI does reasoning, because it seemed like a useful thinking technique.
These reasoning AI models help me think on a meta level about my own thinking and shows me tools I can use to improve it.
Great to see that I’m not alone in this!
At the very least, someone at Copilot must have pitched a rubber duck avatar as the new Clippy by now...
In general, this is very helpful for when your executive function feels taxed, as it has the effect of coaching yourself.
You are not “emulating R1”, you are talking to yourself to make sure you understand the concept.
Which is fine but don’t act like AI is making this part of life better in any way with this example. Nonsense
There are good ways and bad ways to think aloud, R1 just gave me a large set of examples of doing it the "good" way.
It's uncommon to read hundreds of paragraphs of a smart person's internal reasoning process. Usually we're only able to read the final results of their thoughts.
> As I read over practice questions, I spoke aloud
This is also something that’s expected of the applicant in technical interviews
The interviewers want to hear the applicants thought process and how they develop a strategy to solve the problems presented to them as they work them out
It’s equivalent to the LLMs reasoning in the output and not in the latent space before the final output, which gave the rise to the reasoning models we see today. So speaking out loud might not be the best reasoning method ;)
As we make AI better, perhaps we'll inadvertently find ways to make HI (human intelligence) better too.
I had a personal experience with this when I was studying for an exam recently. As I read over practice questions, I spoke aloud, replicating the reasoning methods/personality of Deepseek R1. By spending a lot of time reading long verbose R1 outputs, I've essentially fine-tuned my brain for reasoning tasks. I believe this method contributed to my excellent score on that exam.