News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Aurornis on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:30PM (#43271905)
The original source was Louis Rossmann, a YouTuber known both for advocating for Right to Repair and for producing a lot of videos in the rant/complaint genre.

I know a lot of people are fans of his content, but this is hardly the first time he's rushed out a video with unverified claims that later turned out to be false/exaggerated. He also has a habit of moving the goalposts when manufacturers actually try to do something good, like when he continued to complain about Apple after they introduced their hardware repair program with loaner equipment.

He's very confident in his videos and presents a calm and collected demeanor, but his claims and content feel like they're scraped from the angry parts of social media. Take with a grain of salt.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by dingdingdang on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:56PM (#43272274)
Rossmann also wholesale recommends LibreWolf as a replacement for Firefox with full calm assurance despite the maintainer(s) obviously being anonymous and unvetted and there being no organisation behind the fork to serve as a legal entity.

A prior time he did this was with GrapheneOS which ended in tears when he had epic fallout with the primary maintainer and withdrew all support because.. no surprise.. all the security of that fork is in the pocket of a single individual who may or may not, as according to Rossmann, be stable any given day of the week.

We all make mistakes and I hope he will retract if needed but the attention economy is clearly an -attention- economy, not a truthful-content economy..

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by OsrsNeedsf2P on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:14PM (#43272523)
> despite the maintainer(s) obviously being anonymous and unvetted and there being no organisation behind the fork to serve as a legal entity.

Librewolf is judged by its track record of being open source, rapidly fixing security issues, and strict stance on user privacy. Why do people always attack these projects on "Hacker" News?

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:19PM (#43272602)
>Why do people always attack these projects on "Hacker" News?

It's not an attack. It's a pertinent statement of fact that some privacy-conscious people may want to consider when choosing their browser.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by drunner on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:22PM (#43272638)
Are the developers on Chrome or Safari not anonymous to you as well? Or basically every piece of software that you did not author yourself?
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:23PM (#43272658)
That's where the second half of the sentence comes into play:

"organisation behind the fork to serve as a legal entity."

There is a legal entity behind both Chrome & Safari.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Xelbair on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:51PM (#43273092)
Yeah, in both cases it is user hostile entity hellbent on tracking you, with strong legal defense.

I think this actually makes things worse.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Nextgrid on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:48PM (#43274783)
The threat model is completely different.

A big company tracking you generally does so in a fully algorithmic manner, with little to no human eyes on the actual data, and any individual's unauthorized access to such data is generally considered a Big Deal™ in these companies and grounds for instant termination.

Furthermore, these companies generally have good security controls that would be hard to subvert by a hostile attacker to release a malicious build or leak the collected data.

Finally there's also safety in numbers - you are statistically unlikely to be the "most interesting" person using a major company's software product such as Chrome, so even if someone managed to gain full unfettered access to the collected tracking data and/or is able to push a malicious update, it's very unlikely you will be the target.

A smaller project led by a lone developer or a small team of contributors lacks those various checks and balances, large security team, and the numbers of users, such that once breached you may very well be interesting enough for the attacker to actually take a personal look at.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Xelbair on Thursday March 06, 2025 @07:34AM (#43279502)
It is all also trust based, with plenty of examples showing that access was available despite all checks and balances supposedly being in place.

If it is trust based i would rather trust someone who's open source and privacy advocate than any corporation that will abuse the data as soon as it is profitable for them. but that is my choice that follows my priorities.

Even more so when company - in the cited examples - already has heavy conflict of interest when it comes to service provided(chrome tracking <-> google ads feedback loop that gives them even higher unfair advantage)

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:56PM (#43273164)
>Yeah, in both cases it is user hostile entity hellbent on tracking you, with strong legal defense.

This isn't related to the point. I'm not recommending any specific product.

I'm just saying that the anonymity (or not) of the maintainer(s) can and should play a role in the decision of which browser you use. You may decide that you don't care about that, or that it's a risk you accept, and that's completely fine. But having the information to base the decision on is important.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Xelbair on Thursday March 06, 2025 @07:05AM (#43279268)
I'm just providing a counterpoint that non-anonymity of maintainer can also be a downside. with similar caveats.
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by nickthegreek on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:18PM (#43272585)
It would be nice to have both though right? Ideally I want an active maintained fork by a group of security minded individuals that are known.
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by parl_match on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:38PM (#43272890)
Let me demonstrate the issue to you with a hypothetical situation:

An anonymous open source developer of a popular tool is identified by a bad actor. This developer is offered a million dollars to install a backdoor that allows the bad actor access to any device used by consumers or that software product.

Now, if that developer is anonymous to you, you have no legal recourse after the developer used their software product to launch a cyber attack on you.

That is the issue.

Also, not hypothetical, many such cases: https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/dozens-of-backdoore...

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by autoexec on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:58PM (#43273188)
> Now, if that developer is anonymous to you, you have no legal recourse after the developer used their software product to launch a cyber attack on you.

It looks like the source is hosted on codeberg, which a company in Germany. Presumably they would know which account was used to sign in and upload the malicious code, and that account would be tied to things like an email address and IP address which could be traced back to a person. It might not always be enough to find the person, but that's always true. Red Hat and The Debian Project being non-anonymous didn't mean they knew who backdoored the XZ Utils package.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by pseudalopex on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @11:57PM (#43276569)
> Presumably they would know which account was used to sign in and upload the malicious code, and that account would be tied to things like an email address and IP address which could be traced back to a person.

Anonymous email services and VPNs exist.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by parl_match on Friday March 07, 2025 @02:40PM (#43293640)
"It looks like" "Presumably" "might not always be enough"
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by drpossum on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:11PM (#43272476)
I don't see how the anonymity of the maintainers of Librewolf are at all relevant to this discussion. You're just doing a gish gallop argument and undermining your credibility.
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by dlahoda on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:18PM (#43273463)
may you share link to GrapheneOS? i was not able to find
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Nextgrid on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:50PM (#43274801)
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by larossmann on Thursday March 06, 2025 @03:19PM (#43284696)
A lot of the criticism of librewolf is for being "woke"

I differentiate between someone who holds political beliefs that I don't, or that are a little wild; and someone who holds the belief that I am trying to get them killed. Particularly when there is an easy way to figure out which phone is mine if one were so inclined.

The former may not like me, but the latter ? if you believed someone was trying to kill you, what lengths would you go to? i think grapheneos & librewolf are two very different cases.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by MostlyStable on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:22PM (#43272648)
That's not the original source, that's the video that made it go viral. The original source, as detailed in the article, is online reports from people (like me) who have experienced a Brother printer stop working when 3rd party toner is installed and that swapping the DRM chip fixes the issue.
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by aquariusDue on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:23PM (#43272659)
I used to enjoy Louis' videos when he started out on YouTube, his troubleshooting process for repairs was cool to watch along with his soldering technique. I might've found him through Eli the Computer Guy (another early YouTuber), but these days both of them seem kind of jaded and cynical while pandering to people who seem angry at tech in general.

Anyway, it's weird looking back at various tech YouTubers and how they've either fallen out of favor or changed and adapted to reach further heights I guess. One schism I remember was TekSyndicate, I personally went on to follow Wendell to Level1Techs.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by autoexec on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:29PM (#43272742)
Anyone informed on the current state of technology should be jaded and cynical
Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by autoexec on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:24PM (#43272680)
> The original source was Louis Rossmann

No, the original source was reddit. His video just reported on what other people had already been saying.

Ultimately social media is where we're going to hear about these issues. The companies themselves aren't going to publish an article detailing how they're screwing their customers over on their websites.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Someone1234 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:59PM (#43273221)
It was both Reddit and HN threads. You can find his sources in his Wiki on this subject:

https://wiki.rossmanngroup.com/wiki/Brother_ink_lockout_%26_...

Going after Rossmann when he is just repeating what multiple people have posted on social media feels like shooting the messenger.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:24PM (#43272682)
> He also has a habit of moving the goalposts when manufacturers actually try to do something good, like when he continued to complain about Apple after they introduced their hardware repair program with loaner equipment.

I don't think that's moving the goalposts. Apple set things up in a way that still made it extremely difficult for a repair shop to do the work. No ability to stock parts being one of the really bad features. With the rental costing enough money to cancel out any savings, it becomes a tool for a small number of people that don't want the phone leaving their sight, a toy for some others, and not much more.

Has that changed since?

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by larossmann on Thursday March 06, 2025 @03:17PM (#43284667)
This is interesting since I never had an issue with the loaner program, or apple making those tools available. The tech press had a field day laughing over that, but it wasn't anything professional repair people considered an issue. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vhCaFW5xTk

I was quite aggravated that the tech press managed to put focus on the piece of kit they were sending people to fix devices, rather than on the real issue; telling distributors they're not allowed to sell us individual components that they would otherwise make available to anyone willing to wire them money for a large enough order.

The aggravation over the tools rental, to me, was always a nothingburger.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by legitster on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:25PM (#43272698)
All do respect to Rossmann, but he definitely falls under the genre of "professional complainer". And like a lot of tech journalism he applies the same narratives to everything.

I get that everyone wants to make this a story about tech enshittification, but Brother barely bothers to keep their website updated. The idea that they are secretly and suddenly changing their sales strategy and publicly lying about it is a bold claim that requires bold evidence.

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by autoexec on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:35PM (#43272841)
> The idea that they are secretly and suddenly changing their sales strategy

I don't know about "sudden". The reddit post is kind of old. That said, I have no idea when "Brother Genuine ink" even became a thing. I saw nothing at all about it when I bought my printer from them 10-15 years ago. It certainly wasn't mentioned as a requirement for getting support.

It sounds to me like at some point they got their tech support to tell customers that they need to have "Brother Genuine ink" in order to get support (or at least techs were told to strongly imply that was true) and now it's come back to bite them in the ass

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by creatonez on Thursday March 06, 2025 @02:45AM (#43277534)
> like when he continued to complain about Apple after they introduced their hardware repair program with loaner equipment.

This program was proven to be a complete scam, beyond a shadow of a doubt

Re:Brother refutes "false claims" that it bricked printers u... by josephcsible on Thursday March 06, 2025 @09:21AM (#43280494)
> He also has a habit of moving the goalposts when manufacturers actually try to do something good, like when he continued to complain about Apple after they introduced their hardware repair program with loaner equipment.

Apple's repair program requires that you do the equivalent of replacing a car's engine when just its spark plugs go bad. He's absolutely right to continue complaining.