News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by demosthanos on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:17AM (#43231229)
> IMO there is no alternative to supporting Mozilla, and also keeping them accountable and criticizing them where criticism is due.

If there is no alternative to supporting Mozilla, how do we keep them accountable? If they know that they're the only hope for a cross-platform browser that isn't developed by Google, then they know that any outrage is a bluff that can't have teeth because they're indispensable.

> They are still roughly the good guys, even if sometimes misguided.

There aren't any good guys here, there are just people doing people things.

Mozilla is more than sometimes misguided, they've been essentially permanently distracted from Firefox as the core mission for more than ten years now. Their organization is designed in a way that makes funding Firefox directly impossible, and they haven't made any moves to fix it. Instead they set up failed side project after failed side project and repeatedly alienate their core with ads, while insisting that donations couldn't possibly work in spite of the fact that Thunderbird clearly shows that they can—as long as the project is unshackled from the mess that is Mozilla.

It might well be that the best thing that could happen for Firefox would be for it to get evicted from Mozilla like Thunderbird was.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by homebrewer on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:52AM (#43231641)
Do note that Thunderbird can afford to keep a relatively tiny team (compared to Firefox) because it stands on the shoulder of giants (Firefox) for its UI and HTML renderer. That Thunderbird is able to cover its expenses with donations really doesn't prove that Firefox will also be able to do so, but that doesn't excuse Mozilla from not even trying.

> failed side project after failed side project

Rust and MDN have been huge successes. Their mobile OS is still alive and kicking, although other people are making money from that now. They also put in a ton of resources into decreasing FF memory footprint as part of the failed mobile OS effort, which benefits all of us.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by masklinn on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:03PM (#43232449)
> Do note that Thunderbird can afford to keep a relatively tiny team (compared to Firefox) because it stands on the shoulder of giants (Firefox) for its UI and HTML renderer.

Also, and mainly, because that's a lot less of a moving target.

- there's not much that's new to email, there are some recent ideas like jmap but they're not exactly hard requirements

- UI requirements are largely fixed and a pretty minor concern

- and between web clients and completely broken ones (cough cough outlook) email HTML rendering is pretty damn far from any sort of leading edge

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by demosthanos on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:58AM (#43231715)
> Rust and MDN have been huge successes

Neither is an income stream, and Rust was evicted while it was still taking off and is no longer a Mozilla project.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by AstralStorm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:21AM (#43232000)
The big question is why anything there has to be an income stream.

If there are users, and there is a need, we should directly furnish the project with a bunch of hired employees rather than indirectly pay some manager, rely on charity or ads.

Yes, I know, how unamerican of me. ;)

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:39AM (#43232172)
> we should directly furnish the project with a bunch of hired employees

Who is “we”?

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by lyu07282 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:42PM (#43233554)
We should be able to directly donate to fund the salary of full-time engineers working on Firefox and only Firefox, completely circumventing the PMC.

It might also be possible to fork and spin off Firefox into a new non-profit, circumventing Mozilla if some of the devs organize it.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:01PM (#43233743)
> We should be able to directly donate to fund the salary of full-time engineers working on Firefox and only Firefox

Money is fungible. If you want to do this, frankly, donate to LibreWolf.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by yu3zhou4 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:25AM (#43232030)
Can you share more about their mobile OS? I thought it's discontinued
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by fabrice_d on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:20PM (#43232662)
I guess they are talking about KaiOS, which had initial success, shipping on more 100M devices in India. Unfortunately they have been struggling to expand outside of India and even in India these days since their partner (Reliance Jio) is not pushing new devices there so much.

Another major pain point is they lost support from WhatsApp, which is really the king maker in many countries when it comes to mass market adoption of a mobile platform.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by rjsw on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:39PM (#43232875)
The version of Firefox in KaiOS has lagged a long way behind the current desktop one.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by fabrice_d on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:12PM (#43233867)
Yes, it's been a struggle to ship newer version. It looks like they are preparing a new release based on gecko 123 (https://github.com/kaiostech/gecko-b2g/blob/gonk/config/mile...).
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by aquova on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:44AM (#43231558)
> If there is no alternative to supporting Mozilla, how do we keep them accountable? If they know that they're the only hope for a cross-platform browser that isn't developed by Google, then they know that any outrage is a bluff that can't have teeth because they're indispensable.

Except they're not indispensable. They're now the fourth place browser in terms of market share on a good day, and dwindling. They need all the good will they can get, and this sort of discussion amongst their most hardcore audience is exactly what keeps them accountable.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by AstralStorm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:25AM (#43232025)
Can you name other browser engines in play? I'm waiting.

While neither Mozilla nor Firefox are not indispensable, Gecko is.

We literally have three working rendering engines: Chromium/V3, Gecko/Spidermonkey and ... Long nothing ... WebKit/KHTML?

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by Philpax on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:27AM (#43232050)
Ladybird and Servo are coming up, but I suppose you're covering that with "working".
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by Laesx on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:04PM (#43232463)
Servo is still going? Thought it was pretty much on life support after being abandoned by Mozilla.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by LoganDark on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:14PM (#43232577)
Servo does indeed not seem to exist anymore but some of its components such as Webrender still do and are actively maintained.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by johnny22 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:50PM (#43234308)
servo was never a fully featured web browser and was never proposed to be iirc. It was proposed as experimental from the start. The most we got at the time was browser.html
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by LoganDark on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:30PM (#43235952)
Back in... 2018? there was a Servo binary you could download that had an address bar and could be used to browse the web. That actually started to get stripped down over time, the later binaries had less and less functionality, until now I don't even think there are any. Servo spearheaded a lot of projects, like bindings to macOS frameworks from Rust, that would have been used to create a more comprehensive browser, but then got torn down once the larger thing was canceled in favor of certain components, like webrender.

I don't know when exactly it was canceled - maybe around the time Firefox Quantum shipped.

Note that I never said it was ever not experimental. Just that it would have been more until it was canceled.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by yencabulator on Monday March 03, 2025 @01:19PM (#43244909)
servoshell exists today. Their focus has definitely been in the rendering etc and not in developing browser UI, but that's understandable.

https://book.servo.org/running-servoshell.html

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by fabrice_d on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:21PM (#43232673)
Yes, it was revived by Igalia, and has good momentum. Check https://servo.org
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:40AM (#43232186)
> Can you name other browser engines in play?

WebKit. Also, the only thing keeping Chromium a Google monopoly is Europe, China and India’s concession.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by 42lux on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:55PM (#43233026)
What’s the problem with WebKit?
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by djao on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:45PM (#43238098)
Nothing is wrong with WebKit, but it's not really a separate rendering engine, and the discussion is about separate rendering engines. Chromium's heritage derives from WebKit.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by layer8 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:39AM (#43232177)
You keep them accountable by calling them out in public, as with the recent ToS change, where it made them clarify and improve the new wording. Keep calling them out on stuff that isn’t acceptable.
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:46AM (#43232241)
> You keep them accountable by calling them out in public

This is performative. Mozilla is accountable to a small circle of donors, and they mostly see Firefox as a monetisation vector.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by sciens3_ on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:58AM (#43232383)
> and they mostly see Firefox as a monetisation vector.

They could’ve gone the Wikipedia route and heavily asked for donations, but, instead, they’ve chosen to sell user data. That’s why I must leave. At least Google was very obviously reliant on advertising. Mozilla had no excuse other than desperation and pure idiotic evil.

Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by handoflixue on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:34PM (#43232827)
What specific data is being sold?
Re:Trust in Firefox and Mozilla Is Gone – Let's Talk Alterna... by tokai on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:50AM (#43232289)
We have called them out for years, and its not getting better.