News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by osigurdson on Saturday March 01, 2025 @12:53PM (#43221684)
I used to work in this industry. One thing that might be interesting for people is the metals do not actually withstand the temperatures directly. Instead cooling vanes are needed throughout various parts of the engine. This is why shutting a gas turbine (aka jet engine) down from full power will destroy it. It is necessary to take the engine down to a lower power setting first and then continue to spin the engine (calling motoring the engine) for quite a while even after it is turned off.

Another interesting thing is some engines cannot withstand certain RPM ranges as the compressor and power turbine can get into a catastrophic resonance. A good example is the T700 (used in the Blackhawk).

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by gameshot911 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:27PM (#43222063)
Your comment is really interesting, but I didn't fully understand.

What do you mean by "metals don't actually withstand temperature"? As in the raw metal would melt were it not for the cooling vanes?

'If powered down, the engine would destroy itself' - from what? Overheating?

The lower power setting on shutdown does what? Spin it at a low RPM so it doesn't decrease in temp too quickly?

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by neuralRiot on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:12PM (#43223727)
>What do you mean by "metals don't actually withstand temperature"? As in the raw metal would melt were it not for the cooling vanes?

This is similar to the rocket engines where the thrust nozzle and its extension are cooled by the fuel otherwise they would melt or fail structurally.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by aunty_helen on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:27PM (#43223317)
The blades are hollow and have air injected from where they attach to the outside edge and fin of the blade, so when it’s spinning the blade doesn’t contact the exhaust stream because it’s coated with a layer of relatively cold air. Same thing happens with your car pistons but using an inertial layer.

Image search for a turbine blade and you’ll understand as soon as you see it.

The reason you can’t shut the engine down or power off suddenly is because the blades and housing cool at different speeds, the clearance between the blade tips and housing is as close as possible.

To help with this, hot air from the turbine is sprayed onto the outside of the casing via a hot bleed air bypass when the ecm determines its necessary.

If you shut down suddenly the tips of the blades can contact the housing and best case rub, worst case break.

There’s another problem along these lines which really exemplifies how tight these tolerances are, on the a320, you need to do a bowed rotor procedure if you’ve been sitting with the engines off for 45 minutes before you restart. This involves turning the engine over with the apu to equalize the cooling throughout the engine because the core of the engine cools slower but there’s two shafts running through the middle. These shafts “bend” because the outside is cold but the middle is hot, they can then rub against each other ruining bearings etc.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by neuralRiot on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:15PM (#43223741)
This also applies to high performance car turbo engines, a “turbo timer” is used so the ignition can’t be shut off until the turbo cools down.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by potato3732842 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:24PM (#43226115)
Your china charger doesn't have clearances that tight.

Turbo timers are a legacy from the days when turbos were primarily oil cooled and synthetic oil wasn't common and shutting down a glowing hot turbo would tend to create sludge if done habitually.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by SkyPuncher on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:06AM (#43231806)
This doesn’t seem to be true on modern turbos.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by gosub100 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:33PM (#43226164)
This is amazing yet again that they can ingest rain and snow so the inside can be, what, close to 3000F yet you can come into land in Minneapolis when it's -30F and everything Just Works. Imagine how different aviation would be if in an alternate universe we had modern jet engines but under no circumstances could they ingest water?
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by osigurdson on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:31PM (#43226568)
Note that at cruising altitude it would be more like -80F. The engine would be more efficient at sea level at -30F as the mass flow rate would be higher. Ingesting water vapour actually improves things for the same reason. The downside is it can cause corrosion over time.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by motorest on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:43PM (#43222251)
> What do you mean by "metals don't actually withstand temperature"? As in the raw metal would melt were it not for the cooling vanes?

Metals don't need to melt to fail. Increasing the temperature leads to gradual reduction of yields limits. For example, the yield stress of steel drops to 50% if it reaches around 500 degrees.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by xeonmc on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:34PM (#43226593)
> Metals don't need to melt to fail.

Another example: “jet fuel can’t melt steel.”

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by thereisnospork on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:36PM (#43226599)
but also yes, the metal would melt if it somehow managed to not fail. Often the turbine blades are operating in an environment above their melting point and only don't melt because of the internal cooling.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by yodelshady on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:28AM (#43229362)
> What do you mean by "metals don't actually withstand temperature"? As in the raw metal would melt were it not for the cooling vanes?

They creep. Have you seen, for instance, Blu-tac or glue fail? It doesn't go at once, but slowly, over a period of time. At high temperatures most metals (others on this thread have mentioned single-crystal blades) behave a bit like that.

Although steel is also weaker at temperatures far below its melting point, yes. A simple observation of a blacksmith at work should tell you that. And a think some new jets may be running hotter than Tm for steel now?

> The lower power setting on shutdown does what? Spin it at a low RPM so it doesn't decrease in temp too quickly?

Yup, or more relevantly evenly, although those tend to be related. Given almost all materials expand as they get hotter and contract as they cool, different cooling rates between parts -> different contraction rates -> different relative shape -> Very Bad in precision machinery.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by kamaal on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:00AM (#43229567)
So basically metal gets rubbery when hot, and stopping something all off a sudden could have inertial forces(moving blades, gears etc) wreck the structure?

You have to shut things down step by step, so that rigidity is supplied to the metals as the inertial forces are reduced.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by mppm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:06AM (#43230614)
> What do you mean by "metals don't actually withstand temperature"? As in the raw metal would melt were it not for the cooling vanes?

A small addition to the sibling comments: Combustion temperatures in modern turbines are around 1400C, if I recall correctly, but the best nickel superalloys go up to 1050C or thereabouts (for long-term operation). To close this gap, the use of high-temperature alloys is supplemented with active cooling and ceramic coatings, as stated by GP.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by TrainedMonkey on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:13PM (#43225652)
Many rocket engines, especially the reusable sort, require active cooling of the throttle and combustion chamber. A portion of the fuel is split into channels which run through the combustion chamber, throat, and the nozzle. Generally it is a close loop system, so the fuel makes back to be injected into the combustion chamber.

To get max performance modern engines run hot, aka ox rich, and the regen cooling is generally not enough. So in addition to that, critical surfaces such as nozzle also get protected by injecting a thin layer of fuel. This biases combustion to be fuel heavy in localized areas which is less hot. Of course all of this happens in an extremely dynamic environment where gasses are moving at 2km/s+.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by araes on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:07PM (#43226796)
Was actually going to post a similar comment re: NASA and the SSME engines for the Space Shuttle. This graphic shows the coolant system circulation that pumps cold fuel through the outer casing to warm it up to proper temperatures before use. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-25#/media/File:Ssme_schemat...

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by anovikov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:46AM (#43229950)
Not just the reusable ones. Almost all of them do. Exception are monoprop ones where the temperatures are just not high enough.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 03, 2025 @01:13AM (#43238827)
> To get max performance modern engines run hot, aka ox rich

Oxygen-rich means you have extra oxygen which doesn’t combust. That necessarily reduces performance. Most rocket engines run fuel rich because hot oxygen is a chemical terrorist.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by chris_va on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:51PM (#43225912)
I've always wanted to ask...

Why do turbines have a static duct and micron tolerances for the blades (and creep requirements) instead of a rotating (attached to the blades) duct that can be tensioned separately, and (presumably) no creep/micron tolerances?

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by jiggawatts on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:38PM (#43227006)
Look up "blisks". These are used for ceramic turbines, because those are stronger in compression than tension.
Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by HALtheWise on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:13AM (#43228125)
Not an expert here, but afaik a turbine section consists of alternating spinning blades attached to the shaft and stationary vanes attached to the duct, which de-spin the air coming off the blades and prepare it for the next set. I'm not sure why the vanes are often hidden in cutaway views.

If you had a spinning duct, you'd presumably need a stationary shaft in the middle for mounting the vanes, and would have similar tolerance issues between the tips of the stationary vanes and the rotating duct. There's reasons that it might be easier to solve (the duct can be lower temperature) and reasons it's harder (bearings for a giant spinning duct). Not sure if anyone has tried such a design.

Re:Why it's so hard to build a jet engine by rnrn on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:12PM (#43234523)
a full duct spinning at 10k rpm seems like it would massively increase stress on the blades