News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bluefirebrand on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:38PM (#43141136)
> For any normal CRUD app, it should take milliseconds to do whatever task. Even with network delays, 150 milliseconds is a reasonable upper bound for end-to-end processing

This is only really true with stable, high speed internet connections. We still cannot take for granted that everyone has that, especially not in rural areas and double especially not on mobile devices

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:00PM (#43141954)
So many places in apps just wait for no reason. Let's take a hypothetical situation:

Suppose you're doing gig delivery. You're delivering to two customers in the same neighborhood on the same run. You drop the first order, take your photo of the drop, and the app spins. It's waiting for the photo to be delivered before it moves on. You can't get directions to the next customer until the app moves along. Why can't it just take the photo, take the text description, and hold that until service is better? Just give the driver the map, and upload the other stuff when you can.

I have similar issues with every app. It seems like every user interaction, every button press requires a round-trip to the server before the app moves to the next step. There's no reason for this. I wager that every app can keep its UI and the user's data locally, and send and receive teensy data updates.

But all "the best" software development employees (that they claim their hiring process hires) in these companies can't seem to work that out.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bee_rider on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:11PM (#43142085)
That’s bizarre. The whole point of having an app instead of a website is to have more processing occur locally, right?
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by roughly on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:32PM (#43142298)
The whole point of having an app is to collect data, show ads, and “engage the customer with the brand.” Any additional capabilities beyond that are incidental.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by thwarted on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:26PM (#43142849)
The delivery driver is not the customer, but I wouldn't be surprised if some MBA bonehead thought showing ads to workers was a win. "They have to use the app to schedule and do the work, so it's a captive audience!"
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by roughly on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:23PM (#43143884)
Hell, I got shown an ad after I paid for a ride on Lyft the other day. Even if you’re the customer, you’re still the product. If there’s not already ads in the drivers’ views, I’m shocked it’s taken them this long.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by listenallyall on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:41PM (#43145380)
Why do you think only MBAs have the idea to insert ads? It's not exactly specialized thinking. Plenty of startup founders with technical chops decide to insert ads because they desperately need the revenue.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by graemep on Sunday February 23, 2025 @05:01AM (#43148182)
Because "MBA" has become a generic derogatory term for greedy and short termist management, because its easy to blame a group of people than face the fact that the problem is a wider one of incentives and ethics that pervades the whole of western society.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by CyberDildonics on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:18PM (#43142776)
Don't forget bait and switching with updates so you can do all that later, possibly after you sell your quality app to someone else and cash out.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by edwinjm on Sunday February 23, 2025 @06:24AM (#43148529)
And send push notifications
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:18PM (#43142143)
> The whole point of having an app instead of a website is to have more processing occur locally, right?

One would think this is the case. I agree it should be.

> That’s bizarre.

Unfortunately, it's not. It's normal operation.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by ponector on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:32PM (#43142285)
Why is it so?

The whole point of app is to gather your info from the phone and to send you tons of notifications.

And don't forget mandatory updates, when you open an app and cannot use it without updating to the latest crappy version.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by TylerE on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:37PM (#43143512)
History has shown over and over again that you cannot trust the client.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by dartos on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:42PM (#43144974)
No, the whole point of apps is data collection, background tasks (when the device is closed) and push notifications.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by simonmales on Sunday February 23, 2025 @01:41AM (#43147227)
Many apps are shortcuts. They live rent free on people's home screens/launchers.

Plenty could exist as a web app.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bluefirebrand on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:23PM (#43143385)
> Why can't it just take the photo, take the text description, and hold that until service is better? Just give the driver the map, and upload the other stuff when you can.

The obvious answer is because asynchronous workflows are brittle, and require intervention from the end user to correct if they break

Then most end users aren't going to care to fix it when it breaks, or be able to fix it when it breaks for a variety of reasons

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:43PM (#43143558)
And what should one do if the network is down? Stand there indefinitely hoping it comes back up?

Recall the driver can’t continue without an address.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:04PM (#43144667)
Better they can't continue than they do the last order wrong, amirite?

There's some strong "Seeing Like a State" vibes here. I'm pretty sure these apps are intentionally designed as tools to force the users (here, drivers) into a specific flow, a flow that minimizes complexity for the vendor, reality be damned.

Another way to look at it: the job of the driver side of a delivery (or taxi) app isn't to be useful to the driver; the job is to be a remote control with which the business can control the driver like they were an automaton.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:39PM (#43144954)
So the automaton can’t deliver to the next customer because the app can’t phone home.

I don’t see how this benefits anyone.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by lmm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:42PM (#43145399)
For the control system, no delivery is better than a delivery that they can't track.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by avidiax on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:26AM (#43147748)
Lots of delivery jobs are effectively paid by the piece or paid by the route. The driver is not paid hourly.

This is one reason that package delivery drivers often will say that they've attempted delivery when they at best drove past the delivery point. Marking the delivery as attempted gets them off the hook for that delivery, and they can finish their shift that much faster.

Having a broken app that forces the driver to 100% complete every delivery before moving to the next one thus costs the company relatively little, but saves some complexity, missing proof of delivery, etc.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by ndriscoll on Sunday February 23, 2025 @11:53AM (#43150811)
You can still queue the upload client side and let the worker move on. Don't consider the delivery complete until the upload happens, but allow the next leg of the job to start. The client workflow can require taking the picture and clicking submit, but it can accept queueing the actual upload.

In any case, if the network is down, a spinner is a lie. It's pretending to be working on something when it's not. It should show an error at least.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by AStonesThrow on Sunday February 23, 2025 @01:32AM (#43147192)
It's dispute resolution in a low-trust environment.

When a customer shows up saying something went wrong with the delivery, the CSRs will need evidence and if the driver did their job then they can be exonerated.

The logistics are a bit more complex than a restaurant where customers are eating at tables in the same building.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bluefirebrand on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:20PM (#43145232)
If the network is down it really doesn't matter if your app does synchronous or asynchronous operations because both will fail?

I'm not entirely sure what your point is at all

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:13AM (#43149008)
Asynchronous operations can be retried until the network returns without blocking the UI.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bluefirebrand on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:53AM (#43149647)
Not when they require user validation like making sure a photo updated correctly

If you drive away from the delivery before that photo is uploaded, then you risk not having the proof that you delivered the package successfully

That is actually worse for the driver than having to wait for the upload so they can retry immediately

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:46PM (#43155353)
The proof is still on the phone. The photo doesn’t magically vanish because the driver moved on while the network was disconnected.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by TylerE on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:36PM (#43143505)
Relevantly, in this specified case, the picture of their delivered food is shown to the customer immediately. This is more than a nice to have (imagine a large apartment building, where your food could be dropped in any number of locations).
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by genewitch on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:11PM (#43143790)
it's shown when the driver gets a network connection again, was the way I read that.

Because "[driver] doesn't know where to go till it confirms the upload"

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by joquarky on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:06PM (#43144683)
I'm proficient in optimizing these UX flaws, and have been unable to land a full time job in two years, even after hundreds of applications.

Nobody cares about quality anymore.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by jagged-chisel on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:47PM (#43155357)
Don’t I know it …
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by wwalexander on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:05PM (#43145591)
While doing Instacart deliveries here in Maine, I dropped off a leave-at-the-door order which requires uploading a picture of the shopping bags at the entrance. However, there wasn’t any service in the rural area I was delivering to, and the app required a connection to even open the camera interface. So I had to drive away down the road until I had service, open the camera, drive back to the delivery point, take the picture, then drive away again to upload the picture and complete the order.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by bbarnett on Sunday February 23, 2025 @06:12AM (#43148472)
Same thing with paypal.

They require a mobile phone number now. If I give them one, they'll enforce SMS as a login path.

I live in an area with excellent cell service, except for a few miles around my house. I'm not going to try to log in, while buying something, then drive down the road and wait for the SMS.

Sheer stupid.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by ndriscoll on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:43PM (#43141757)
At least on my mobile, I get ~100 ms ping to most things. Admittedly I don't use it very often so it's hard to have a real world feel for how frequent things like dropouts are, but that's mostly because data costs a lot. That kind of also ties into developers doing a bad job though (e.g. sending me 10 MB of who knows what when the task (like paying for parking) fundamentally should be doable with a few kB, most of which are the TLS handshake). If they didn't do that, their thing would be instant with 3g speeds. Most CRUD generally just doesn't need a lot of data to actually accomplish the desired task.

Satellite Internet will be slow, but should still be well under a second? I'd still expect that even extreme cases, you wouldn't expect a spinner to complete a single revolution. So it still seems unnecessary.

Anyway, I'm generally on a reliable 300 Mbit/s connection where my pings are more like 20-70 ms, so I suppose you could alter my statement to "if I see a spinner, I interpret it as incompetence".

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by anigbrowl on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:23PM (#43142818)
Then it should give explicit status information like

  uploading to server (xx%)...OK
  waiting for response...delayed. Check again in 3 minutes.
Not as cool, but at least somewhat informative. Engineers have a responsibility to push back on this kind of thing, because marketing people frequently do not think about failure modes or actually put themselves in the customer's shoes.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by kristianc on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:34PM (#43142930)
> marketing people frequently do not think about failure modes or actually put themselves in the customer's shoes

It’s literally the job of marketing people to put themselves in the customer’s shoes. If engineering isn’t looping in marketing on UX challenges, or if marketing is too focused on top-of-funnel vanity metrics to engage deeply with product usability, things fall through the cracks.

But that’s a company culture issue, not a marketing deficiency.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by anigbrowl on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:34PM (#43143491)
It should be, but it isn't in my experience. Marketing people care about onboarding and engagement numbers, and are a major driver of dark patterns - everything from popups to moving the 'close dialog' icon to unintuitive places like the bottom left of unasked-for video embeds.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by brookst on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:46PM (#43143590)
Massive over-generalization.

I’m sorry you only worked with terrible, unethical, incompetent marketing people. There are good ones, just like there are bad programmers who do all sorts of terrible and dumb things without creating universal truths about programmers.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by anigbrowl on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:14PM (#43144286)
I don't think so; I said marketing people frequently do bad stuff, which is not the same as saying they're all bad. I stand by 'frequently', because just look at how much terrible adware, clickbait, spam etc there is on the web. It's a Gresham's law-type situation.

Of course marketing people do a valuable job in terms of figuring out how to sell things and minimize the gap between producers and customers. But - just like engineers - there are lots of cynical and amoral people who work in that industry who make things worse for everyone else. By contrast, I can't think of any society that is suffering because they don't have enough advertising.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by kristianc on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:48PM (#43144555)
Effective marketing (not just comms, but real positioning and messaging) is why people can find the right products and services, why small businesses can compete, and why entire industries grow. It's unequivocally a good.

If anything, societies suffer when good marketing is absent—because that’s when bad actors fill the void with misinformation, hype, and scammy tactics.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:07PM (#43144692)
> If anything, societies suffer when good marketing is absent—because that’s when bad actors fill the void with misinformation, hype, and scammy tactics.

Except, marketing too is a market for lemons. Scammy marketing outcompetes good marketing. Simple as that.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by kristianc on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:31PM (#43145309)
Scammy marketing can sometimes be effective in the short term, but the problem with it it’s inherently self-limiting.

Deceptive brands burn their audiences, lose customer trust, and either get regulated out of existence or collapse under their own churn rates. Meanwhile, companies that invest in clear, honest positioning, strong customer relationships, and long-term brand value consistently outperform in the long run. Apple, Patagonia, and Tesla aren’t winning because they spam pop-ups.

If marketing were purely a race to the bottom, all successful brands would look like clickbait farms. They don’t.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by int_19h on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:12PM (#43154531)
Did you seriously just mention Tesla as an example of "honest positioning" and "strong customer relationships"??
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by tremon on Monday February 24, 2025 @08:00AM (#43159027)
Effective marketing (not just comms, but real positioning and messaging) is why people can find the right products and services

If that's your metric, I can confirm the GP's statement, at least when it comes to online marketing people. Increasingly, I can not find the right products and services online.

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by maximilianthe1 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:02PM (#43141405)
Also, inside buildings in very urban areas
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by rapind on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:32PM (#43141661)
Also in my house in the first world because our telcos are an order of magnitude worse than third world telcos.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by nayuki on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:10PM (#43142071)
> my house in the first world because our telcos are an order of magnitude worse than third world telcos

Hello fellow Canadian

Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by RHSeeger on Sunday February 23, 2025 @12:33AM (#43146900)
Where I used to live, in NY (not NYC, but close to _a_ major city), I had to go out onto my front porch to use my cell phone. It wasn't a great signal out there, but it was better than the _no_ signal inside my apartment.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by n_plus_1_acc on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:39PM (#43141732)
Hello fellow german
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by mihaaly on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:39PM (#43142977)
It sucks to live with a dial in nowadays.
Re:'The tyranny of apps': those without smartphones are unfa... by akdor1154 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:11AM (#43147649)
And when your users are in the same continent as your backend.