News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by nirvana on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:07PM (#4313004)
Please explain to me why a bot would click on ads? (if anyone knows)

Is it crawlers crawling Facebook? Are they alleging that facebook is doing it to boost revenues?

Their hypothesis seems secure, given that you can't really use the facebook site at all without javascript enabled.

More alarming is Facebook holding their name for ransom for the sum of $24,000 a year!

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by jiggy2011 on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:13PM (#4313041)
Possibly other advertisers trying to push competitors away from facebook so BigDickPillz Inc can have it all to themselves?
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by pathdependent on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:24PM (#4313110)
Yes. This used to happen a lot on ad networks, although I personally don't know how pervasive it is now.

The game is as jiggy said. Force competing ad buyers to pay for what appears to be non-productive traffic by forcing ad clicks. Since the real views are dominated by false views, the conversion rate on whatever is being sold appears to be horrible. The competitor goes elsewhere, and the scammer maintains access to artificially cheap ad inventory, since there are fewer bidders.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by dclowd9901 on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:56PM (#4313291)
How does Google prevent this? Is it simply inherently not-problematic, due to their spread of advertising?
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by pathdependent on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:12PM (#4313401)
It's a cat and mouse game. Google gets good at it; scammers get more sophisticated; google catches up again; ad infinitum. Also, in addition to the scam mentioned above -- in Google's case, targeting AdWords -- they have to deal with scammers hitting their own AdSense properties.

It's a well known problem. Considering AdWords is Google's primary source of revenue, they work hard at it. For a tiny bit more directly from Google, see: http://support.google.com/adwords/bin/answer.py?hl=en&an...

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by veyron on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:01PM (#4313316)
Overall it's hard to say whether google wins or loses overall by this. In absence of a real competitor in the search ad space, people generally will swallow google's fee hikes ...
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by freshhawk on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:46PM (#4313231)
As pathdependant said, this is a very common shady tactic in the ad business. You drive up your competitors costs with bots in order to drive them away from your keywords or make them think their conversions on those keywords are awful and then abandon them.

By far the most likely explanation in my opinion. Even if it's not the correct one, some of the traffic is almost certainly these kinds of bots.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by TomGullen on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:15PM (#4313056)
The biggest conspiracy theory would say that a bot clicking ads would help earn FB money.

I don't really suspect this to be true, Facebook CTR are incredibly low so if they are faking it they are doing it badly.

I suspect the most likely reason is some sort of spam scraper thing that visits every url or something. I would have assumed Facebook would be well protected against this sort of thing in regards to charging advertisers.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by phenom on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:26PM (#4313480)
FB does not need do that shady stuff. Here some facts.

[1] Bot registration on FB is really easy. If you try register 100 fake users in direct way you need to deal with javascript and web forms with strange ids, cookies and so on in your script. But if you enter fb.com without enabled javascript, they ask you change browser or use mobile version, which is not require* js at all.

[2] You can register number of accounts from one ip without CAPTCHA

[3] Only one "difficulty" is to find batch of emails, it is not that big issue since we have services like mailinator.com.

So 15 -25 loc script on python do all your job. It is not required use any tools like selenium or special skills , only basic understanding how http get/post works.

Why fb doing all this super easy bot registration stuff? I think we all know why.

Edit: spelling. Sorry non native English speaker here

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by woodchuck64 on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:32PM (#4313878)
You seem knowledgeable. What is the main purpose of bots on facebook?

The article implies they could be used by facebook or competitors to burn up ad revenue, but this approach would just kill the golden pay-per-click goose.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by phenom on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:43PM (#4313944)
I think reasons is pretty strait forward:

[1] You can win a bunch of contests, competitions like those who have lot of likes can win iphone or other tech.

[2] You can sell likes.. just google and you will see, there are alot of places where you can buy it.

[3] Manipulation of public opinion.

Edit:

From FB side:

[1] they still have growth of users

[2] more bots == more clicks, more likes more FB value "on paper", more revenue

[3] and when they stabilize their market value they can easily kill those bots, just require them activation by phone.

vk.com Russian social network, had same issues, but they enabled phone activation for averybody and its not that easy to buy a lot of phone numbers in Russia, but some hackers just pay to vk.com admins...

Edit2: spelling

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by woodchuck64 on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:54PM (#4314008)
Thank you for that. This is the real story here, IMO.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by vaksel on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:49PM (#4313242)
Facebook does analytics...they aren't some tiny startup...surely they track the quality of their traffic...so they know that 70-80% of their ad traffic comes from bots.

So Facebook is knowingly profiting from this, and they have the resources to fix this...but they don't since this is making so much money for them.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by rkaplan on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:31PM (#4313145)
Bots might be operated by competitors to increase the cost of advertising for Limited Pressing. This is the most likely scenario, in my opinion. However, though rather unlikely, the bots could be affiliated with Facebook itself, as all of those extra clicks translate into lots of extra Facebook revenue.

That doesn't seem like a very sustainable strategy though.

Does anyone know what kind (if any) of anti-bot measures Facebook already has in place for paid advertising?

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by vegashacker on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:16PM (#4313063)
The OP says that they are not accusing FB of using bots to drive up revenue.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by huggyface on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:20PM (#4313088)
They refused to overtly accuse them, but the subtext seem to argue exactly that.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by thezilch on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:05PM (#4313353)
I don't think so; if anything, the subtext is merely arguing that Facebook isn't doing anything to stop the problem. Whether that is just as bad as running the botnet itself, that is another thing.

Assuming the problem is as bad as many are saying, I personally think it's fair to draw the same conclusion you have -- running and letting run a botnet is one and the same. It's costing other businesses money; it's too big for Facebook to be able to play dumb on the issue.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by spaghetti on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:58PM (#4313302)
While I doubt malicious intent on FB's part there's certainly a financial incentive to ignore this problem. How would their earnings reports change if they stopped charging at least some advertisers for 80% of clicks?
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by klawed on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:52PM (#4314000)
I think Hanlon's Razor is appropriate here: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by huggyface on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:17PM (#4313429)
It would be a very, very short term financial incentive.

Advertisers monitor to see performance on the other end, and when the campaigns don't yield actual success they move on.

The only real exception to this are mega-brands that advertise just to build namespace. Everyone else expects direct action from some hefty percentage of their ads.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by spaghetti on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:36PM (#4313542)
Are you saying it's short term because advertisers would notice? Sure some advertisers would notice. However I doubt the majority are capable of performing the OP's analysis (which could use some scrutiny).

Imagine a 100 person company with 5 people dedicated to advertising. Leadership says to increase on-line presence. Some recent college grad on the advertising team buys FB ads. Next month leadership is pleased that they're advertising on Facebook. Also leadership is pleased that sales increased x%. The FB ads could be completely worthless. Some non-trivial percentage of clicks could be from bots and no one would notice.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by JPKab on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:04PM (#4313722)
You act as if "everyone else" sees results from FB ads. They don't. This is a well known problem. They have a high rate of adoption from new sign-ons, and also a high level of departure. While the first number is greater than the second number, they are ok. Either they will manage to improve value and keep more of the advertisers, or one day the Ponzi scheme implodes.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by huggyface on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:14PM (#4313772)
You act as if "everyone else" sees results from FB ads. They don't.

Most ads target a specific outcome: You buy a product, create an account, joining a mailing list, etc. Even the most technically incompetent advertisers establishes these fundamental metrics such that they can say "I spent $1,000,000 on Facebook ads and only got ten signups. I spent $1,000,000 on iAds ads and got ten million signups." That sort of thing.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by pandog on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:30PM (#4313140)
Which is really taking things too far - if Facebook wanted to generate some revenue with bots then it wouldn't be very difficult for them to write ones that supported JavaScript.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by adharmad on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:21PM (#4313450)
That is true, but Facebook's reputation would suffer seriously if they were ever caught.

What they (Facebook) are doing now seems to be some version of DADT (Don't Ask, Don't Tell).

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by Cushman on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:42PM (#4313201)
I don't think so, there's lots of reasons that would be a stupid idea for Facebook. But there's clearly something shady going on, and Facebook is being dicks to them in other ways, so they're out. That's the subtext.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by huggyface on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:47PM (#4313235)
They end the bot section with "But let's move on, because who the bots belong to isn't provable." after saying that they weren't accusing Facebook of running the bots. The subtext is screaming out.

Does me pointing out the barely shrouded subtext mean that I believe what they are saying? Of course not. It's just as likely, it seems, that their test is simply flawed (as others said, let's see the technical honey trap), that it's some other technical fault, etc. I highly doubt, just on intuition, that Facebook is running such broken bots: Come on, they'd do a better job than make something so easily detected.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by rapind on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:14PM (#4313407)
I actually think they were trying to say something strange is going on, which I think is pretty obvious given their stats, and that they have no idea who's doing it or why, partially because Facebook can't be bothered to look into it or at least get back to them about it.

That to me sounds like FB is aware of the issue and isn't interested in discussing it. That's the subtext imo.

My own suspicion would be because someone is gaming their ads and they haven't been able to prevent it as of yet, and not because they themselves are gaming the numbers. No doubt they believe that discussing it is tacit admission that they haven't been able to prevent it, which is bad for business.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by Cushman on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:17PM (#4313435)
I see what you're saying, it just isn't very hard for me to take them at their word: They're not claiming that it's Facebook, not out of some sense of propriety, but because they don't have any evidence that it is. It could be anyone.

And it doesn't matter who it is, because they're leaving for a different reason: Facebook never returns their calls unless it's with an offer of extortion.

Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by spaghetti on Monday July 30, 2012 @01:04PM (#4313348)
It would be outrageous for FB to run the bots themselves. There's two other issues that are more realistic and unfortunately not so great for FB: they're aware of the bots and ignoring them in favor of the ad revenue or they're just becoming aware of the bots and will implement some fix which could result in a substantial decrease in ad revenue. Good to keep in mind that OP's 80% is just one data point and may not be accurate.
Re:Company withdrawing from Facebook as analytics show 80% o... by dchuk on Monday July 30, 2012 @02:52PM (#4313998)
could be ad spy tools...they crawl around clicking ads and following them to the landing pages and then follow the landing pages to the offer being promoted. Allows affiliates and other advertisers to reverse engineer the competition