News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by belter on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:49PM (#43062182)
Within 4 years, Europe from top to bottom, will be running on Linux.

Massive layoffs will hit the US Defense industry as no sane nation ever will buy again a US weapon.

Cloud vendors will have to split hard their operations or see revenue cut in half.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by sampo on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:51PM (#43062200)
2029, the year of Linux on the desktop.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by impossiblefork on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:10PM (#43062358)
For my mother, the year of Linux on the desktop was this year.

Basically, she got enough of Windows, mostly due to subscriptions, that there was news being shown in the browser, and some other related issues and she was incredibly happy with Ubuntu (which is of course American, but since it's free and gratis, it doesn't really matter, and there's always SUSE).

She liked the cleanness, the absence of distractors, how it was clearer what was in the cloud and what was on the local machine, that she wasn't paying any continuous fee for LibreOffice and the happiness this switch brought was huge.

The only reason people are still using Windows is gaming and that it's a default on the machines at computer- and electronics stores. They'd be happy with Linux, they'd be more productive with Linux and they'd be calmer with Linux.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:12PM (#43062387)
> The only reason people are still using Windows is gaming

Also, almost every corporation and similar large-scale deployment, for management and compatibility purposes.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by impossiblefork on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:14PM (#43062401)
I suppose, but it should mostly be a quick matter to switch away from it.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mjr00 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:20PM (#43062458)
I work with energy systems that are still running Windows Server 2003. Even upgrading to a new version of Windows would be a multi-year project; rewriting all of the customized, Windows-specific software to work on Linux would be incomprehensibly expensive.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Saturday February 15, 2025 @05:03PM (#43062830)
People who don't know often imagine that, understandably. Recreating years of accumulated deployment and management in a new system is so expensive, it's usually impossible. In a real sense, you have to redo many years of work, all at once. And on top of that, you have to deploy it all at once - an immensely complex project that is almost certain to be a disaster.

Also, in many ways, Windows management components (Active Directory, Group Policy, etc.) have no competition:

First, you must have management systems: imagine you are deploying, configuring and managing a new application on 10,000 desktops, or just 1,000. You can't manually go to each desktop (just add up the time spent walking between desks!); you must automate it.

Second, most user applications provide management components for Windows and for no other platform. If they have something else, it's often an afterthought (and goodness forbid they stop developing it and you are left 'to your own devices').

Finally, there's usually no reason not to use Windows. Why create these risks and costs? The users care only about the applications - these aren't their home computers; the IT department handles the OS, etc. The network effect of the Windows standard is hard to beat.

There are exceptions: Some deployments are very simple and can be done on Linux, for example POS cash registers. Many applications now depend on web browsers, though even then you can have DRM and other issues, and you don't know what new application a user may need tomorrow. Macs are a standard in some places.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Sunday February 16, 2025 @12:08AM (#43065519)
I forgot another aspect of migrating: After all that time and money and energy (including opportunity cost of taking people from other productive work), what do you have to show for it?

Another directory services / management system that does the same thing as - or likely worse then - the original. All that work and at best you haven't moved an inch forward, you haven't helped the business' bottom line ... what did you do? How do you explain that to the CEO?

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by 15charlimitdumb on Saturday February 15, 2025 @07:02PM (#43063800)
You could probably count the number of successful corporate migrations away from MS active directory on one hand
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Sunday February 16, 2025 @12:04AM (#43065499)
What major corporation doesn't use AD, excluding special cases (e.g., Apple might use their own, or do they use their Macs under AD)? What do they use?
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by belter on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:27AM (#43067259)
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by curt15 on Sunday February 16, 2025 @08:22AM (#43067761)
The Linux MDM space is still pretty barren.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by tbrownaw on Saturday February 15, 2025 @05:05PM (#43062840)
> 2029, the year of Linux on the desktop.

Heh.

I ran Linux as my desktop since... approximately the turn off the millennium, with a brief downgrade to Windows from when the Rift S came out until I finally got around to switching back last year.

I should probably see about finding time to upgrade my laptop away from the os it came with as well as some point...

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by landryraccoon on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:52PM (#43062212)
> no sane nation ever will buy a US weapon

I don’t think the US defense industry is worried. Do you know any sane nations around here?

In general it’s not like war is about who’s right or moral. It’s more about who can bring more and better weapons to the fight.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by sandworm101 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:09PM (#43062346)
>> In general it’s not like war is about who’s right or moral. It’s more about who can bring more and better weapons to the fight.

"You have the watches. We have the time." There are many ways to win a war.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by JadeNB on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:05PM (#43062320)
> In general it’s not like war is about who’s right or moral. It’s more about who can bring more and better weapons to the fight.

I suspect, though I'm not sure, that the point was more that a nation that rejects science in favor of a different kind of ideological purity (lack of virtue signaling as its own kind of virtue signaling) is a nation whose weapons are no longer likely to be the better ones.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by jtbayly on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:09PM (#43062349)
Given the rejection of science and extreme virtue signaling the US has had for the last 20 years, I’m a bit skeptical that a slight turning back from that would make any difference to our allies.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by foldr on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:09PM (#43062347)
I think the point is that the US is no longer a reliable ally, so people will no longer want to buy weapons systems for which the US might withdraw support at any moment.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by aerostable_slug on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:13PM (#43062395)
That seems to be a premature assessment. Trump paused a weapons shipment to Ukraine, then allowed to it to continue. No other shipments have been held up at all. Our allies continue to receive the output of the American arms industry just like they did six months ago.

In fact, the latest news is that Trump is expanding our circle of friends when it comes to advanced weapons, offering India the opportunity to purchase F-35s.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by foldr on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:45PM (#43062667)
It's a long-term shift. European militaries are built on the assumption of US support via NATO in the event of an attack on a member state. That assumption is looking very shaky now, and it will affect future planning.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by milesrout on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:50AM (#43067333)
They are built on the assumption will subsidise their defence almost entirely. They are rapidly realising that the US defending them will be conditional on them defending themselves. This is not a serious threat, it is just pressure. But it has resulted in increased investment in defence in Europe which is really important for global security.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by foldr on Sunday February 16, 2025 @07:42AM (#43067562)
>They are built on the assumption will subsidise their defence almost entirely.

This is an exaggeration. The larger European military powers spent enough on defence to be able to operate without US assistance in a range of circumstances (e.g. the Falklands war). But Europe did not anticipate having to defend itself against Soviet aggression without US assistance.

In fairness, it would have seemed crazy, not so long ago, to think that the POTUS would be on friendlier terms with the leader of a Russian dictatorship than with the democratically elected leaders of France and Germany. But here we are.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by jafo1989 on Sunday February 16, 2025 @12:49PM (#43069980)
Key word - "spent".

The Falklands conflict was almost half a century ago. It is doubtful that the UK could respond today like they did in 1982.

The video "The Navy With More Admirals Than Warships"[1] addresses that exact scenario, and talks about the current woeful state of the British Navy today.

You are right to question who your allies are.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=po9duwvipB0

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by foldr on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:06PM (#43072718)
I think that’s somewhat unclear. In principle, the new carriers with F-35s should have a much bigger advantage over the Argentinian navy and air force than the tiny carriers we sent to the Falkland’s with Harrier jump jets. But of course it is impossible to know until such a thing actually happens. (Even in the case of a far more antecedently plausible conflict such as Russia/Ukraine, expert predictions were all over the place, and mostly wrong.)
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by belter on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:32AM (#43067282)
Canada would not buy anymore F-35. Their replacement parts can be shutdown any moment as the current US President stated publicly at least six times, they should become a US state.

A change of administration in the next few years, will not mitigate the taboo that has been broken.

The US sells 120 billion dollars a year of weapons: https://www.state.gov/fiscal-year-2024-u-s-arms-transfers-an...

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by milesrout on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:48AM (#43067326)
Baseless catastrophising. Turn off the news a bit.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by kordlessagain on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:56PM (#43062251)
Initiated by POLICY and evidenced by your REACTION, it’s pretty clear polarized views will hamper healthy discourse.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mjr00 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:56PM (#43062252)
Is this based on anything other than wishful thinking?

European nations switching entirely to domestic military production within 4 years is as realistic as Trump's plan to make the US auto industry fully domestic within a few months, which is not very.

Cloud vendors already offer ways to ensure your data never leaves the EU, for larger enterprises.

Which Linux distro is Europe going to be on, top-to-bottom? The one controlled by Google?

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by patmorgan23 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:10PM (#43062356)
SUSE, it's a German company.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mjr00 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:12PM (#43062381)
Have any EU governments indicated they are moving away from Windows/MacOS to SUSE?
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by verzali on Sunday February 16, 2025 @02:43AM (#43066172)
Canonical is British as well.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by verzali on Sunday February 16, 2025 @02:44AM (#43066177)
France has a significant military industry. It will take time to switch.

The real shift may be to move closer to China.