News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:12PM (#43062387)
> The only reason people are still using Windows is gaming

Also, almost every corporation and similar large-scale deployment, for management and compatibility purposes.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by impossiblefork on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:14PM (#43062401)
I suppose, but it should mostly be a quick matter to switch away from it.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mjr00 on Saturday February 15, 2025 @04:20PM (#43062458)
I work with energy systems that are still running Windows Server 2003. Even upgrading to a new version of Windows would be a multi-year project; rewriting all of the customized, Windows-specific software to work on Linux would be incomprehensibly expensive.
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Saturday February 15, 2025 @05:03PM (#43062830)
People who don't know often imagine that, understandably. Recreating years of accumulated deployment and management in a new system is so expensive, it's usually impossible. In a real sense, you have to redo many years of work, all at once. And on top of that, you have to deploy it all at once - an immensely complex project that is almost certain to be a disaster.

Also, in many ways, Windows management components (Active Directory, Group Policy, etc.) have no competition:

First, you must have management systems: imagine you are deploying, configuring and managing a new application on 10,000 desktops, or just 1,000. You can't manually go to each desktop (just add up the time spent walking between desks!); you must automate it.

Second, most user applications provide management components for Windows and for no other platform. If they have something else, it's often an afterthought (and goodness forbid they stop developing it and you are left 'to your own devices').

Finally, there's usually no reason not to use Windows. Why create these risks and costs? The users care only about the applications - these aren't their home computers; the IT department handles the OS, etc. The network effect of the Windows standard is hard to beat.

There are exceptions: Some deployments are very simple and can be done on Linux, for example POS cash registers. Many applications now depend on web browsers, though even then you can have DRM and other issues, and you don't know what new application a user may need tomorrow. Macs are a standard in some places.

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Sunday February 16, 2025 @12:08AM (#43065519)
I forgot another aspect of migrating: After all that time and money and energy (including opportunity cost of taking people from other productive work), what do you have to show for it?

Another directory services / management system that does the same thing as - or likely worse then - the original. All that work and at best you haven't moved an inch forward, you haven't helped the business' bottom line ... what did you do? How do you explain that to the CEO?

Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by 15charlimitdumb on Saturday February 15, 2025 @07:02PM (#43063800)
You could probably count the number of successful corporate migrations away from MS active directory on one hand
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by mmooss on Sunday February 16, 2025 @12:04AM (#43065499)
What major corporation doesn't use AD, excluding special cases (e.g., Apple might use their own, or do they use their Macs under AD)? What do they use?
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by belter on Sunday February 16, 2025 @06:27AM (#43067259)
Re:Is the ArXiv safe from the current US Government attacks? by curt15 on Sunday February 16, 2025 @08:22AM (#43067761)
The Linux MDM space is still pretty barren.