Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by itronitron on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:03AM
(#42949397)
It's a myth that the bar is lowered for DEI hires.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by djohnston on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:23AM
(#42949739)
You should RTFA before making such an obviously disprovable assertion.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by itronitron on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:20PM
(#42952849)
The parent comment was making broad generalizations about DEI hiring practices in general. So with all due respect I implore you to go fuck yourself.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by Manuel_D on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:48AM
(#42950197)
There are methods of practicing DEI that don't lower the bar. There are methods of DEI that do lower the bar. There's no single answer to that question, it depends on how DEI is implemented in that particular case.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by mistermann on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:21AM
(#42949700)
It isn't possible for you to know this.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by MisterTea on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:41AM
(#42950067)
And you are backing this claim up with what exactly?
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by kikokikokiko on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:27AM
(#42949831)
Yeah? Tell me how avoiding hiring a better qualified white/asian person, in order to hire a less qualified black one, isn't lowering the overall quality of the job being done by the company/agency in question? Logic be dammned right.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by ryandrake on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:54AM
(#42950298)
Why are you (and many others) just assuming the black candidate is less qualified?
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by d1str0 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @11:17AM
(#42950692)
That’s literally what this whole article was about. Removing a high correlation performance test, that black candidates didn’t pass as frequently, and replacing it with a very low correlation questionnaire that provided a more diverse applicant pool while weeding out highly qualified individuals.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by kalensh on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:47PM
(#42952292)
They still had to pass the performance test. It was just no longer the first step in the process. I want to be clear, that doesn't mean the questionnaire was a good thing. It just means that the questionnaire did not lower the bar.
Instead it reduced the applicant pool in a sudden and unfair manner, which is it's own issue.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by Devilspawn6666 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @06:54PM
(#42957117)
No, read the article again. They didn't need to pass the same test to the same degree - the criteria was also changed to have "qualified" and "well qualified".
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by kalensh on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @09:40PM
(#42958358)
It's worth nothing that this change happened before the questionnaire was instituted. (The paper referenced in the article was from 2006, I haven't dug enough to find a date for when this change was made, but the narrative in the article also establishes this act as happening in the '00s.) Additionally, from the Conclusions:
"Reweighting was based on data collected from incumbent ATCSs who took AT-SAT on a research basis; some of these employees achieved overall scores less than 70 (that was one of the reasons for the reweighting effort – a belief that incumbent employees should be able to pass the entry-level selection test)."
I don't think this proves that the update to the test was good or bad in overall competency, but I do think it's worth investigating if the test should be updated when existing employees are unable to pass.
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by squigz on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:52PM
(#42952366)
Was it replaced, or was the questionnaire an addition?
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by tradertef on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:33PM
(#42953023)
Exactly. From the article: "As originally scored, the test was intended to pass 60% of applicants, but predictions suggested only 3% of black applicants would pass"
Re:The Full Story of the FAA's Hiring Scandal
by reducesuffering on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:43PM
(#42952230)
You should listen to what Harj, a YC partner and former CEO of TripleByte an objective software engineer competency test for hiring, has to say about what many companies were trying to do in lowering the bar. He only admitted companies were doing this in the past week.