News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by jesterson on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @10:45PM (#42861280)
As opposed to sentiment the article was likely written with - I warmly welcome the initiative.

The organization that digests humongous amount of taxpayers money, consistently fails audits for years in row, participates and encourages global wars - should be dismantled or severely reformed at bare minimum.

Whether Trump administration be able to achieve that remains to be seen, but hopefully it's a start.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by ianhawes on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:08PM (#42861402)
A severely weakened or dismantled US Military would encourage aggression by China against Taiwan, by North Korea against South Korea, (continued) aggression by Russia against their former Soviet states, and Iran against Israel and Saudi Arabia, leading the planet into a 3rd World War.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:13PM (#42861430)
Or, the US could stay out of conflicts that don’t involve us?

I find it interesting how the left has gone from anti-war to pro-war in the span of a 2-3 decades.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by auntienomen on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:29PM (#42861547)
Wars with our trading partners and military allies involved us, duh.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:55PM (#42861707)
How'd that attitude work out when your grandpa believed the same thing in the 1930s?
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:05AM (#42861761)
In the 1930’s? Pretty well?

How has it worked out since then? I count a 100% failure rate.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by YZF on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:28PM (#42861543)
It's an interconnected world. All conflicts involve you. Pretty much all the current crop of wars are a direct result of the US getting "less involved". Putin's goals in Europe and the middle east. China's goals in Taiwan. All of these are a direct opposite of the "western world order". The thinking that the US can just withdraw from the world and it would become a peaceful free place is obviously failed. It's not restricted to one side in US politics either.

I think the US left is still generally anti-war. They hesitated to support Ukraine. They're locked into "why can't we all just get along" thinking. The right doesn't think we can get along but also doesn't want the US involved.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by vkou on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:03AM (#42861749)
> Pretty much all the current crop of wars are a direct result of the US getting "less involved"

Whereas the previous crop of wars was a direct result of the US getting "more involved". Afghanistan, Iraq II, ISIS in Syria, Libyan civil war...

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by sympil on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:17PM (#42861451)
No rational, reasonable person is always pro war or always anti-war. You ought to understand that nuance is involved. Lots of liberals were opposed to the Iraq war that started in 2003 and now support fighting against Russian aggression in Ukraine. Your view is simplistic.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by threeseed on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:20PM (#42861471)
There is a difference between being pro-war and anti-invasion.

Most people including the left don't want another repeat of Iraq or Afghanistan where the US chose to regime change a country.

But are happy with supporting a democratic country to defend itself against unwanted aggression.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by YZF on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:36PM (#42861584)
You're basically saying the US should have let Iraq take Kuwait. Or let China take Taiwan?

Any weaker democratic country can be taken by a stronger non-democratic country?

"Invasion" is part of war. If you go to war against a country this may often involve invading. Wars are hard to win if you're not there. If there is no threat of going to war you are essentially yielding the world to Russia and China and the likes.

This is not to say the US hasn't made a lot of mistakes but I'll take a US world order with mistakes over a Chinese or Russian world order.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by skellington on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:03AM (#42861747)
There is no conventional war with China the US can win. Therefore, it's a big fucking waste of money to pretend we can with aircraft carriers and tanks. Nuclear weapons are relatively cheap. What the US military is good at is dropping bombs that cost the equivalent of houses onto primitive people living in tents.

The US invaded at least 2 countries and killed 2 million plus people in the last 25 years. Where were you then to stop the "invasion?"

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by palmfacehn on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:36PM (#42861582)
I agree there are distinctions worth making. The above poster's comment was concise. I'm not sure they intended to conflate the two ideas.

It is easy to observe how under Obama, the allegedly anti-war candidate pivoted to supporting invasions. He forgive his predecessor's use of torture. He said incoming administrations shouldn't prosecute the previous. The only gift he didn't grant was the wish to invade Iran.

There is a sense that the defense, foreign policy and intelligence establishment will have their way regardless of electoral outcomes. Trump's first term was unique in that he did not start any new wars. Permanent Washington sought to actively sabotage his administration. Many infer a correlation between the two observations.

As for the assertion that, "If we don't spend x amount of dollars or intervene, the world will devolve into WWIII", I'm not sold on this doom. We might equally ask, If the US continues to misallocate resources via uncontrolled spending, will we have a functional economy capable of fielding a meaningful military response?

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by YZF on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:42PM (#42861619)
Obama let Syria devolve into a civil war with something like half a million dead and many millions of refugees because he was afraid to use the power of the USA to stabilize it. The consequences of which still impact us today. In general he messed up the Arab Spring completely.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2016/12/29/obama-never-understood-...

He's super smart, had great intentions, and messed things up completely.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by skellington on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:14AM (#42861808)
He didn't "let it devolve into a civil war." He authorized the CIA to fund rebel groups which maintained and expanded the civil war.

What exactly do you suggest Obama should have done with "the power of the USA to stabilize it?" Invade? How would trying to 'fix' Syria be any different than trying to fix Iraq or Afghanistan?

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by YZF on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @09:10PM (#42873972)
I think he should have supported the more secular democratic elements against the regime. The regime was on the brink of falling and the outcome was probably going to have been not different than where we ended up. Instead Obama stood aside and let Assad and the Russians crush the opposition.

But that's just my opinion. My point being that "let's not intervene and let it play out" ended up with an amazingly bad outcome because the fear of a bad outcome from an intervention. Clearly a bad decision. A good decision, whatever that might have been, would have a better outcome. If the argument is that no better outcome was possible then that seems pretty wrong on the face of it.

Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan (e.g.) are fairly different places.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by skellington on Thursday January 30, 2025 @08:55PM (#42884066)
So the US has the moral right to install a western style gov into other countries?

How many times do we have to go down this road, tear apart countries, fuck them up more, and leave with everything in worse shape than before?

The US does not have the right to interfere and has proven over and over again that it will do all of the wrong things while trying to force other people with different ways of living and thinking to behave in a western way.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by kennysoona on Thursday January 30, 2025 @08:56PM (#42884073)
> So the US has the moral right to install a western style gov into other countries?

Sometimes, yes. A more powerful entity has a moral right to act to stop cruelty and abuse if they can.

I think acting to dismantle the Taliban, for example, is completely justifiable morally.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by skellington on Saturday February 01, 2025 @02:03PM (#42901127)
I didn't realize I was talking to George Bush.

I guess the US gets to unilaterally decide what's right and wrong for the world, and kill however many people it takes to demonstrate the shining hope that is Western democracy!

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by kennysoona on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:38AM (#42930259)
Anyone with the power to stop injustice should do so. That's not a controversial position at all.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by YZF on Saturday February 01, 2025 @12:21AM (#42895892)
I disagree with this logic and morality. There is a moral obligation to intervene when failing to intervene results in more harm. Naturally the type of intervention needs to be reasonable for the circumstances. But standing by and letting Assad and Putin drop barrel bombs on the population of Syria is clearly not the moral path.

By your logic if Japan hadn't attacked the US then the US should have just stood aside and let the Germans take Europe in WW-II.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by skellington on Saturday February 01, 2025 @01:53PM (#42901032)
WWII was an invasion into Europe, not a civil war.

Every time we've intervened in civil wars, the outcome has been bad, with one exception -- Korea.

The problems with your thinking are:

#1 It's how the neo-cons think and is the justification for all of the US terrorism in the past 40+ years.

#2 Who are you to say what the best outcome for another people are? Which people? What group in Syria will have this great outcome now that it's controlled by Isis?

#3 How many people did you get to kill to experiment with nation building? Do you really understand the internal power dynamics of countries like Syria, Iraq? Or are you practicing a form of Imperialism?

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by vkou on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:05AM (#42861759)
> the power of the USA to stabilize it.

The power of the USA is what destabilized it, by creating a breeding ground for all sorts of fun militias in Iraq.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by palmfacehn on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:25AM (#42861862)
Here's an interesting take. Not my favorite source ideologically, nor are some of the citations. However, citing the WaPo (again, strong dislike) which has been favorable to the Neocons is something.

https://www.globalresearch.ca/how-the-us-supports-the-islami...

>Ultimately, whether one pallet drifted into ISIS hands by accident in a recent airdrop is a moot point. Billions in cash, weapons, equipment, and vehicles have already been intentionally supplied to the many groups that ISIS represents, as planned as early as 2007. ISIS is the purposeful creation of the United States in its pursuit of regional hegemony in the Middle East, and ISIS’ atrocities were predicted long before the first shots were fired in 2011 in the Syrian conflict, long before the term “Islamic State” went mainstream.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by quickslowdown on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @04:07PM (#42871157)
No you don't find it interesting. You view your complete lack of understanding of reality as a cudgel you can use to move the goalposts again. The nebulous "left" isn't for war. Anyone with a shred of morality wants to keep bigger nations from invading & occupying their smaller neighbors, especially when they're trade partners.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by TaurenHunter on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:30PM (#42861555)
A severely senile and incompetent leadership would encourage aggression even more. When did you think the Russian aggression was initiated?
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by hackyhacky on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:45PM (#42861643)
Russia invaded Crimea in 2014. Are you saying Obama was senile?

Russia invaded Georgia in 2008. Are you saying GWB was senile?

Fact is, Russian aggression towards its neighbors has never really stopped. I'm not sure it matters to them who is president in the US.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by TaurenHunter on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:49PM (#42861666)
Don't be disingenuous. I said "senile and incompetent".
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by hackyhacky on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:57PM (#42861718)
> Don't be disingenuous.

I am completely sincere.

> I said "senile and incompetent".

Okay, so answer the question: are all us presidents in the last 20 years, in your opinion, senile and incompetent? If so, what is the point of your comment in saying "When did you think the Russian aggression was initiated?"

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by ianhawes on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:47PM (#42861653)
Russian aggression technically started with the Annexation of Crimea in 2014 during President Obama's 2nd term.

While I do think Biden was fairly incompetent as a leader, the strategy adopted was probably the best option given the poor circumstances: wait and see if Ukraine could repel the initial invasion, then fund the resistance to draw Russia into a stalemate.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by saagarjha on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:40PM (#42861611)
As someone who thinks we spend too much on the military: coming in and immediately pausing everything is an insane way to go about doing things. Unless your goal is to cause a bunch of worry and confusion until you restore the things you like, there are far better ways to cut spending.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by jesterson on Thursday January 30, 2025 @02:25AM (#42875701)
I tend to agree with you, but had I been in Trump position I would do same - just freeze the bloody everything for 90 days and figure out in those 90 days whats actually important and whats not.

If I understand correctly, noone freezes things indefinitely

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by IAmGraydon on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:56PM (#42861711)
Your post history makes it clear that you are sympathetic with Russia and China. I'm curious since you have such an interest in American politics - what country are you from?

Edit - stylometric analysis confirmed what I suspected: your first language is Russian. Makes sense that you would be here making inflammatory posts about the US.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by jesterson on Thursday January 30, 2025 @02:34AM (#42875748)
I should be flattered you wasted some time looking into my history, but let me disappoint you here - I am sympathetic to truth alone. Russian, China or the US do not matter much to me. Visiting/living in those countries is absolutely horrible experience, which I am lucky to have very little of (with exception of some regions in China perhaps).

My interest in US politics is based on pure curiosity. And on top of that, it's very unfortunate that US spreads it's "interests" everywhere in the world, starting wars, overthrowing governments and sorts. So no matter where one lives or planning to, it's going to be interesting and relatable.

If we take this particular case, my welcome to the measure is partially based on hope it will help to deescalate and eventually stop the Ukraine war - useless meat grinder and money laundering machine for corrupted politicians.

And if it makes my posts "inflammatory" - I will humbly welcome that as well.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by smcin on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:28PM (#42861545)
Realistically, the programs that are likely to be trimmed are hugely expensive things like the F35 program, which the newly-promoted tech class would to a large extent replace with drones (land- or carrier-based) [0].

We might expect to see a civil war within the admin between the factions who favor traditional defense hardware programs vs newer tech (drones, AI, autonomous). There's a lot of $ at stake so there will be heavy lobbying. Also, the traditional revolving door.

Also the opportunity for insiders to enrich themselves. Perhaps 2025 will be to defense and AI stocks what 2020/1 was to pharma and vaccine stocks.

One political self-preservation mechanism that traditional defense has done that tech hasn't yet much is to spread the federal spending around across states and congressional districts (think B-1 bomber). So, don't expect these battles to be fought on the merits, let alone net benefit to the taxpayer.

[0]: "The F-35 Program is Costing More and Doing Less, GAO Says" https://dsm.forecastinternational.com/2024/04/19/the-f-35-pr...

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by nradov on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:04AM (#42861755)
There are no drones available today or even on the drawing board which can perform even a fraction of the F-35 mission set.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-A_aF7lpm4

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by smcin on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @04:34AM (#42863153)
Irrelevant. Noone said "cancel the F35 program", and noone said it can be totally replaced. The F35 program is running over-budget, so it's entirely reasonable to look at some cost reductions on the $2 trillion. (The current admin said they were looking for trillion-dollar cost savings by this April, and laying off the entire federal workforce wouldn't going to do that.) The choice is not a binary "100% of all the F35s currently budgeted, or no F35 program at all".

You can get thousands of suicide drones for the equivalent price of one F-35A ($80m). Both Ukraine and Russia are using these daily. (Obviously they don't have a fraction of the capabilities of an F35.)

The Houthis interdicted the Red Sea to commercial shipping in 2024. This is asymmetric: the US Navy couldn't afford to keep shooting down cheap Houthi drones with $2m missiles ("cost exchange ratio"). This is costing billions in economic damage. [0][1]

Another obstacle to where the F35 can't be deployed is the US blocks deploying leading-edge technology to some allies, for multiple reasons (espionage, lack of training, geopolitical), so such conflicts will determine which mix of drones or missile systems or F16s (yes, generations older) are more cost-effective.

[0]: https://www.politico.com/news/2024/08/07/houthi-yemen-defens...

[1]: https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/dp-wor...

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by nradov on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @08:59AM (#42864937)
Irrelevant. The military is retooling to fight China. Cheap suicide drones like what are being used in Ukraine lack the range and sensors necessary to be relevant in the Pacific theater. Funding for the F-35 program will not be cut; if anything it will increase.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by smcin on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:34AM (#42959412)
Still irrelevant to my comment that you replied to; it belongs in a separate thread.

Noone suggested cheap suicide drones can replace the F-35 in general. I did point out that the military has a weak spot in economic asymmetric warfare using drones against it. This has been manifesting for over a year now, with commercial shipping in the Red Sea/Suez. You're quite aware of that. The military has more than one mission, and air(/sea/satellite) superiority with China in a hypothetical Taiwan war is not the only scenario.

> Funding for the F-35 program will not be cut; if anything it will increase.

Clearly the tech lobby's interests compete with traditional defense contractors. Supposedly they are now competing for the same (possibly shrinking) overall defense appropriations. If that is not the case, then defense spending will continue to bloat.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by mcphage on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @10:53PM (#42861325)
> Whether Trump administration be able to achieve that remains to be seen

Does it? Do we truly need to be born anew every day, unable to look into the past to see how Trump has run his businesses, or how he conducted his first term, or how he has promised to run his second?

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by mullingitover on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @10:59PM (#42861359)
So far, culture war aside, everything's proceeding according to plan if the plan was written by a hostile foreign power.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by mcphage on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @07:43PM (#42873404)
“Hostile domestic power” seems like an odd concept, but that’s what we’re dealing with here. Maybe boosted by hostile foreign powers as well, but even without that support, this administration would be doing its best to take this country down from the inside.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:24PM (#42861498)
Trump has run several successful businesses, and with a 50+ year career several failures as well, which I’d imagine a entrepreneurial board like HN wouldn’t hold against him.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by sympil on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:35PM (#42861575)
He’s been found by a jury to be a sexual abuser. He can’t run a charity in New York. Stiffs employees and hires illegal workers. He lies constantly and makes shit up. Like using a sharpie to change a NOAA map because he is incapable of admitting he’s wrong. Anyone doing business with him deserves what happens to them. Like all the lawyers, advisors, and sycophants that ended up in prison during his first term in office.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:02AM (#42861745)
This doesn’t address my point or the topic at hand at all.

He has had severe successful business enterprises.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by sympil on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:14AM (#42861807)
You don’t think character counts in terms of whether or not he’d fit in Ycombinator? That says much about either Ycombinator or you. Stiffing employees and not being able to run a charity very much counts in this discussion. As does the tendency of his business partners and confidants to end up in prison.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @02:41AM (#42862559)
The question wasn’t whether he’d “fit in” with YCombinator.

But it makes sense that you’re answering every question with another and the one that accused him of being a grapist.

You're grasping at straws to avoid admitting he's a successful businessman.

ABC News has agreed to pay $15m (£12m) to US President-elect Donald Trump to settle a defamation lawsuit after its star anchor falsely said he had been found "liable for rape".

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cgrw57q4y9do

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by sympil on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @11:17AM (#42866885)
Here’s the post you originally responded to:

Does it? Do we truly need to be born anew every day, unable to look into the past to see how Trump has run his businesses, or how he conducted his first term, or how he has promised to run his second?

His character is relevant to the discussion. He cheats. He lies. He steals. He rapes. He shirks responsibility. But he has made a lot of money. Like the $30 billion in bribes he took 2 weeks ago. He is a great buinessman but that is not relevant to the discussion. Reread what the origanal poster wrote to see this. It was about his character and how we can judge the future by his past deeds.

My responses included rhetorical questions.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @10:58PM (#42874678)
My original comment was "Trump has run several successful businesses, and with a 50+ year career several failures as well".

I'm not interested in arguing about the comments someone else made.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by sympil on Thursday January 30, 2025 @09:13AM (#42877828)
Your comment was in response to someone and that provides the context for the discussion.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2025 @08:23PM (#42883910)
It wasn’t very relevant.

First comment asked “we’ll need to wait and see if the admin can deliver”, then next “do we? Or do we have data to go on?” and my comment “he has run several successful businesses” followed by “his character is bad”.

The logic doesn’t follow, just an attempt to bad mouth.

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by auntienomen on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:36PM (#42861586)
He's been convicted of accounting fraud and he's nowhere near delivering the kind of returns that YCombinator seeks. Plenty of things to hold against him.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @12:04AM (#42861756)
You’re really reaching, LOL.

No, he wasn’t convicted of accounting fraud. What else do you believe that’s wrong? Not to mention it’s a misdemeanor unless politics demands a felony.

And “delivering the kinds of returns YC does”? Is that the bar now? How’s Obama stack up? LOL

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by cemerick on Tuesday January 28, 2025 @11:54PM (#42861704)
A bag of leveraged real estate and casino holdings, plus a smattering of dollar store swindles is what denotes entrepreneurialism in the modern HN world? Wild times.
Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by refurb on Thursday January 30, 2025 @07:55AM (#42877284)
Funny how you call it "leveraged" when it's just fund raising.

He's built numerous building from scratch. He gathered investors, built, then operated or sold.

Sound familiar?

Re:Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seem... by mcphage on Wednesday January 29, 2025 @08:35AM (#42864739)
HN has a pretty low tolerance for fraud.