News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by sneak on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @03:52AM (#42790603)
I didn’t die of being trampled by unicorns either, but the topic is the cost-benefit ratio of the federal government.

Do you really believe that without central government that we will as a society wholly disregard the last thousand years of technological progress? How do the billion people in Europe do it?

Your argument reduces to the now-infamous “but who will build the roads?” We don’t need the military-industrial complex to put down ashphalt or produce safe food.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by 0dayz on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:00AM (#42790660)
Instead of asking what the government can do for you, ask what the idea behind government programs are and what it seeks to overcome.

Being ideologically captured "big goboment bad" is as bad as geopolitical analysis being "America bad".

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by richrichardsson on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:07AM (#42790694)
You've overestated by more than a factor of two how many people are in the EU and willfully ignored the fact there IS a central goverment of sorts here too.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by radley on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:11AM (#42790723)
> How do the billion people in Europe do it?

Last I checked, they use government. Two governments, I think.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:57AM (#42791051)
At least two. In federations like Germany it's three. Plus local administrations.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @05:05AM (#42791109)
We’ve really gone full circle when the argument for less government is pointing to Europe, and the argument against the military-industrial complex is the guy directly arguing for more military spending.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by DonHopkins on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:07AM (#42790700)
Nobody's preventing you from drinking raw milk, injecting disinfectant, and popping horse dewormer pills to own the libs. Go ahead, make my day!
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by sneak on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:08AM (#42791472)
This sort of kneejerk culture war regurgitation mischaracterizes your argument, as well the people you are talking to, and undermines your own credibility. Separately, it adds positively nothing to the discussion except noise.

The world isn’t as black and white as you seem to be convinced it is. Not everyone is neatly categorized into reasonable friend and nonsensical insane foe, unfortunately.

Do you enjoy meaningless culture brawling in the comments? Does it provide you with some sort of emotional supply? It certainly isn’t accomplishing anything else (other than breaking the social contract here). I’m truly confused, on a purely intellectual level. (I don’t expect you to change or do anything differently, I am simply thoroughly baffled.)

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:24AM (#42791569)
Claiming there is no central government for 'billion people' 'in Europe' and then lashing out when someone engages you on the same level is a very positive addition to the discussion.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by sneak on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @10:19PM (#42800328)
What lawmaking authority applies equally to people in Moscow and London? To Oslo and Cyprus?
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Thursday January 23, 2025 @12:52AM (#42801110)
What lawmaking authority applies equally to people in Mexico City and Ottawa?
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by acdha on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @09:09AM (#42793003)
Your original question was also “culture war regurgitation” by any standard which includes the post you’re replying to. If you want better discourse, you have to start that way and bring receipts that you’re participating in well-informed good faith.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by DonHopkins on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @11:50AM (#42794768)
You've characterized yourself as someone not to be taken seriously by hypocritically accusing me of doing the exact same thing you are doing, then projecting by armchair psychoanalyzing your very own problems. Not to mention that ridiculously childish selfie on your web site, and you expect people to trust you with their bitcoin holding keys via keytern? Don't dish out in the first place what you can't take back in return. Don't you have some cryptocurrency scams to pump and dump somewhere else?

https://sneak.berlin/s/img/jp.jpg

https://keytern.al/

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by fzeroracer on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @03:57AM (#42790637)
> We don’t need the military-industrial complex to put down ashphalt or produce safe food.

And whose going to check that the food being produced is safe?

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @05:07AM (#42791123)
> whose going to check that the food being produced is safe?

Honestly, we could do with less of this. It isn’t hard to tell if fresh food is safe. It’s impossible with hyper-processed nonsense. Increasing liability for producing unsafe processed food might be what we need to tip our food balance in a healthier direction.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @05:52AM (#42791390)
> It isn’t hard to tell if fresh food is safe.

You can tell if fresh salad has E. coli by the look of it? Or if fresh eggs contain Salmonella?

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @11:41AM (#42794663)
> You can tell if fresh salad has E. coli by the look of it?

You're right–I didn't think about fresh, prepared foods.

> if fresh eggs contain Salmonella?

Pasteurised eggs (washed in a factory, I'll note), no. Fresh eggs, hell yes--they smell and look weird.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @11:52AM (#42794788)
> You're right–I didn't think about fresh, prepared foods.

If only that. What about lead salts added to spices for better color (red pepper, curcuma)? What about all the other billions of ways to cut costs and make food unsafe, who is going to check for that in the absence of governments? "Increasing liability" is incredibly naive, the perpetrators don't care about that if the chance they are not caught is high enough, which it is if food chain monitoring isn't continuous.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @12:51PM (#42795505)
> What about lead salts added to spices for better color (red pepper, curcuma)?

Less of a problem with whole spices.

> What about all the other billions of ways to cut costs and make food unsafe, who is going to check for that in the absence of governments?

Local markets are good at sussing this out. We need federal regulation when supply (and thus trust) chains get longer. One of the best ways to undermine trust in the regulation we need is to over-regulate where we don't need to.

RFK going off about raw milk is Exhibit A for this. Would I drink raw milk? No, particularly not with the bird flu ruminating in dairy cows. Do I think banning raw milk makes it more likely (on the margin) that in 10 years I'll be eating leaded spices? Yes.

Note that I'm not arguing against food regulation as a whole. I'm arguing against its breadth at the federal level.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by tpm on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @01:18PM (#42795855)
> Less of a problem with whole spices.

Very few people have the ability to properly mill dried red pepper at home.

> Local markets are good at sussing this out.

Unless it's long-acting toxins. Of which there are many.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by LunaSea on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @12:35PM (#42795325)
> You're right–I didn't think

Exactly

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @12:51PM (#42795515)
You've never eaten an unregulated salad at a friend's?
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by quesera on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @02:11PM (#42796358)
> Fresh eggs, hell yes--they smell and look weird

You cannot reliably detect salmonella on a fresh egg with any human sense.

At least not prior to consumption.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by fzeroracer on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @10:46PM (#42800509)
Can you explain to me your detection process for Salmonella?
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by samastur on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:20AM (#42790794)
The whole military-industrial complex (defense industry) has about the same yearly revenues as Google.

As others have already said, we Europeans do have central governments and there's fewer of us.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by lazide on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @05:03AM (#42791096)
Direct military expenditures in the US amount to roughly $900billion to 1.2 trillion dollars/yr. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_Unite...]

Depending on how you slice things, and what you count as ‘military’.

Based on the GOA, approx. $500 billion/yr (including veterans benefits) goes into actually running the military [https://www.cbo.gov/publication/59475]. Much of that appears to be VA benefits, and it’s increasing.

So the remainder (minus war bonds!) feels like the Military Industrial Complex, which seems to add up to around $500bln/yr.

Google annual revenue appears to be up to approx. $282 billion/year now.

So unlikely any MIC component is close, but overall the MIC still seems quite a bit larger.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by samastur on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:50AM (#42791745)
Alphabet's revenue last year were about $340 billiion.

550 billion is just for compensation. You also need to pay for the upkeep of bases, fuel etc.

MI complex probably still has larger revenues as Google, but difference is much smaller than you think and that is comparing the whole industry to just one tech giant. There are others with revenues as big or bigger.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by lazide on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:58AM (#42791808)
Who provides the upkeep of bases, fuel, runs the contractors who run the equipment, provides the equipment itself, etc?

The MIC. It isn’t just artillery shells.

In general though, I agree. The tech industry is an absurdly valuable target. And thanks for the updated revenue numbers!

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by emptiestplace on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @04:58AM (#42791062)
> We don’t need the military-industrial complex

I hope you realize that part isn't going anywhere any time soon.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by lazide on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @08:04AM (#42792368)
It will stop going into at least somewhat plausibly effective weapons though. See what happened with Russia’s military for a preview.
Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by matwood on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:33AM (#42791622)
> We don’t need the military-industrial complex to put down ashphalt or produce safe food.

Obviously blatant waste and fraud should not be tolerated, but ignoring the huge value of the military is very short sighted. When you hear the phrase, 'backed by the full faith and credit of the United States government', what do you think that means? The US has been in a privileged position for so long they don't even realize why they are there. People flock to the USD because of stability, rule of law, and the ability to park a carrier strike force off any coast in the world and project that 'full faith and credit' the US speaks of. The military is not solely responsible for the US's success, but it is a large part.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by sneak on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:47AM (#42791716)
This is a meaningless phrase, much like “died for our sins”. Endless reptitions don’t make it into a meaningful logical statement.

The only inherent value of the USD is that you can pay US taxes in it. The “full faith and credit” bit meant something when you had to trust the USG to redeem it for physical gold or silver, but as you know that hasn’t been the case for a long time.

Now it’s about the same situation as the Tether fraud. Bitfinex doesnt need a carrier strike group for me to be able to trade USDT for cheeseburgers or gold coins.

People talking about the rule of law in the USA this week are especially comical. The graft and corruption are on full display for the entire world stage. They’re not even pretending any longer. It is now demonstrably clear that the value of the USD is not dependent on the rule of law in the US.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by selectodude on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @10:50AM (#42794058)
> They’re not even pretending any longer. It is now demonstrably clear that the value of the USD is not dependent on the rule of law in the US.

I assure you if people who matter start agreeing with you, we’re all in for a really, really bad time.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by scarface_74 on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @09:52AM (#42793426)
And to add on, even the military brass is not in favor of wasted spending of the military industrial complex.

The military itself has been trying to close unneeded bases, get rid of weapons it doesn’t need, etc. But Congress and the rest of the civilian leadership won’t let it because the civilian leadership is more interested in kickbacks from contractors than doing what is best for the military.

Military leadership has also been warning about the destabilizing effect of climate change and the dangers of our deficit.

Re:DHS removes all members of cyber security advisory boards... by ludwik on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:50AM (#42791739)
> I didn’t die of being trampled by unicorns either

I think this comment is incredibly telling. Many people tend to treat problems that do not currently affect them because of the momentous, coordinated efforts of many individuals and institutions the same as problems that do not affect them because they are naturally nonexistent.

There is a huge difference between these two categories of problems. The first will become very visible when the constant behind-the-scenes work is no longer maintained. The second will not. Confusing these two seems to be one of the causes of the mess we currently find ourselves in.

> How do the billion people in Europe do it?

As a European, I can help with the conundrum: we DO have central governments, and they tend to take more responsibility for taking care of people than the U.S. federal government has ever been allowed to. Governments don't have to be continent-wide to exist.