News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by jazzyjackson on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:18PM (#42776117)
New norm just dropped: President says one thing, law says another, companies must choose their allegiance to which reality they adhere to but end up in a lose lose situation. Pour one out for Apple's lawyers working late tonight.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by forgotoldacc on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:29PM (#42776210)
How's it lose-lose?

Companies can now get away with anything so long as they pay the president a bribe and publicly say "thank you for saving the world." The only way to lose is to not transparently do some easy butt-kissing. And most Americans love watching the corruption. It makes you a good team player.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by jazzyjackson on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:49PM (#42776407)
I guess as long as the President is competent at directing the executive branch to not enforce a law then you're right, you win by making yourself a sycophant. But if you don't trust the President to write an EO that actually prevents you from being fined millions of dollars a day then you're just stuck with ambiguity of what you're allowed to do. Bad for business.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by 1oooqooq on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:52PM (#42776438)
right. it's a forum for start ups and small entrepreneurs, but everyone comment like they are already bigger than meta and as above the law as musk.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by hobs on Monday January 20, 2025 @11:29PM (#42776632)
This is what companies working with fascist governments have thought, and historically that works well up until things change overnight and they come for you.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by forgotoldacc on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:19AM (#42776891)
The difference between then and now is that the rich are richer than ever before and they can just buy an island thousands of miles away and continue to live a first world lifestyle, completely unaffected.

Lower level workers aren't the ones paying bribes and nobody will care what happens to them.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by hobs on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:54PM (#42783867)
Fair, but then they nationalize all your assets that you have in the country.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by bufferoverflow on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:45PM (#42776372)
You're really misrepresenting what's happening. It's not "president says". President issues an executive order. Which is a very specific constitutional legal procedure with its own rules. It cannot contradict the Constitution. The Supreme Court can overturn it.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by ggm on Monday January 20, 2025 @11:40PM (#42776695)
This is important, and needs to be understood contextually. They CAN overturn but they don't randomly overturn things: Somebody has to bring action and they have to accept a need to do something, and set it's priority against other work. They can put a stay on things or reverse, but it doesn't happen on a whim. And you need standing to bring things to their attention.

Also the volume of executive orders over time is down net, the last 150 years. With a spike during WW2. Trump is exceeding local norms. But not historical highs.

I happen to think the orders are shit. That's not the point.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by threeseed on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:35PM (#42776276)
Tim Cook already donated $1m to Trump's inauguration.

And Apple has promised to invest heavily in US manufacturing.

In fact almost all of the Tech CEOs have dutifully kissed the ring and avoided his wrath.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by davidw on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:37PM (#42776303)
For now. But once you show you're willing, there's often a next ask and then one after that.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by SpicyLemonZest on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:43PM (#42776360)
I keep seeing this characterization of inauguration donations as "kissing the ring", and I don't understand it. This is a routine practice for presidential inaugurations. Don't get me wrong, I agree it's bad, but the phrase implies a level of fealty that I really don't think is present. Nobody argued that Pfizer or Boeing or J.Lo were kissing Biden's ring in 2020.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by tantalor on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:21PM (#42776145)
From NPR:

The law does allow one exception: TikTok can continue to operate if Trump certifies to Congress that "significant progress" has been made toward TikTok breaking away from ByteDance's ownership. The law requires that Trump show Congress there are legally binding agreements in motion over ownership changes at TikTok.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by jsiegz on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:29PM (#42776212)
That only applies if it happened before January 19th. That's why his 75 day EO just says they won't go after companies who violate the law, rather than say he's using the 90 day extension provided in the law (because it's too late to use that).

Some of the media isn't picking up on this nuance, but it's clear that's why it's a 75 day lack of enforcement, not a 90 day extension.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by llamaimperative on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:33PM (#42776254)
Which obviously doesn’t prevent them from accruing massive fines for the next administration to enforce.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by jsiegz on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:37PM (#42776305)
Yes, and if you read the EO, Section 3(c) states:

"This order is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person."

In practical terms, this means:

1. Private parties (like TikTok or its users) cannot sue to enforce this EO

2. If the government doesn't follow the EO, you can't take them to court over it

3. Companies can't use this EO as a legal defense if they're sued

For example, if app stores keep hosting TikTok and get sued, they can't point to this EO as legal protection

This is important because while the EO tells app stores and other companies they won't be prosecuted, this disclaimer means they can't legally rely on that promise. If the EO is later found invalid or a new administration changes course, they could still face liability for actions taken during this period.

This creates a risky situation for companies trying to decide whether to comply with the law or follow the EO's guidance. A $5,000 fine per user of a 170M user platform means financial ruin for even Google and Apple if enforced. Larry Ellison (Oracle) might be willing to take that risk, and as a controlling founder he can do so without risk of being fired, but I don't think Tim Cook or Sundar Pichai are going to stick out their neck on this one.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by ivewonyoung on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:43PM (#42776359)
> For example, if app stores keep hosting TikTok and get sued, they can't point to this EO as legal protection

Sued by who? Private parties can't sue other private parties over lack of enforcement, for example you cannot sue your neighbor for violating the federal ban on using pot.

Only the govt can prosecute or sue over certain laws. And judges would be certainly sympathetic because of this EO.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by bdangubic on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:48PM (#42776402)
by the government… in 2026/28…
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by ivewonyoung on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:51PM (#42776424)
As I stated in my other comment, Biden refused to enforce the ban[1], so I really doubt democrats would enforce it 4 years later. It's not exactly a partisan issue, democrats don't hate Tiktok much more than republicans or something.

The real answer is that both sides don't want to take the blame from Tiktok users that rely on it for income, news or entertainment.

That's why the best outcome for them would be the sale of Tiktok to an American, and that's what the law was about. The issue was that Supreme Court ruled at the last minute if it was enforceable.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/01/17/tikt...

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by llamaimperative on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @09:25AM (#42780400)
Biden refused to enforce the ban for his last day in office. I don’t think that says anything about anyone’s general appetite to follow through.

Obviously the political calculations you mention are real, but also POTUS is legally obligated to faithfully enforce the laws. Many laws they can wriggle out of enforcing under prioritization, but given that this is just a matter of fining companies for unambiguously doing an illegal thing, I suspect that’s going to be a harder argument to make in court (and an especially hard one for Apple/Google et al to bet on them making successfully).

SCOTUS didn’t rule “at the last minute” it was enforceable. Last minute of what clock?

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by polotics on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @05:41AM (#42778581)
this creates the perfect incentive to ensure that in four years any way to keep the existential risk at bay is worth stopping for
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by hoten on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:27PM (#42776203)
Isn't that clearly not the case here? How has TikTok shown any movement towards selling.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by nickthegreek on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:30PM (#42776229)
That is 1 of 3 certifications that had to happen in the past.
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by doctorpangloss on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:29PM (#42776211)
What is their hangup with selling 50%, really? They’ll be rich!
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by foogazi on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:32PM (#42776246)
They don’t want to give it up - CCP doesn’t need the money
Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by dns_snek on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:27AM (#42778026)
Or they don't want US social media companies to buy TikTok US and use their IP to outcompete them across the world?

On that note, many US-based TikTok users have reported that the app and the algorithm are substantially worse since the ban was lifted, with speculation that TikTok might sell a watered down version of the TikTok experience to an American buyer.

Re:President signs order refusing to enforce TikTok ban for ... by keepamovin on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:47PM (#42776392)
I like how your comment and the Verge's title found the weakest way to frame something and ran with it. I guess if that's what you need to cope - go for it!