I don't know if I can give them the benefit of the doubt on the cancer drugs because of this.
So it's at least plausible that they're abusing their position as the company that owns the pharmacy and the insurance plan to charge you a lot of money and provide very little coverage and also to gouge you at the very end of your coverage, because that's exactly what they did to my partner and I.
Is that clear enough for you?
1) I don't know what Medicaid pays.
2) I don't know that what Medicaid pays is a just price until we define what a just price is on its own merits. Maybe Medicaid pays more than they should.
3) What Medicaid pays could change at any time for any reason unless what Medicaid pays is based itself on some metrics that define otherwise, in which case let's just look at those metrics directly, yes?
4) If Medicaid decides to pay more, is that the new line?
2. If anything, it's a bit stingy. The negotiating power of government (and the predictability of it) helps keep reimbursements down here.
3. I mean, that's how they're set. They analyze how long and how much a particular procedure should take/cost.
4. Sure.
The negotiating power
And the more predictable process. Private insurers (especially UHC) are notorious for changing up the minutiae of the claims process in order to increase the proportion of claims they deny. There's a cost associated with having to maintain a huge staff just to hassle with for-profit insurance companies.I $truggle to think how $omething like thi$ wa$ allowed to happen.
Bastards.
This is the most absurd set of words I've read in a while.
I agree that more reform and enforcement is needed in the healthcare industry but let's at least get the facts and history right.
As an European, this is mind boggling.
I have no idea what the correct margin for essential cancer drugs is. I don’t think it should be a 10x markup. Intuitively, it seems that there’s something wrong with price gouging dying cancer patients. If you have an argument why my intuition is wrong, please share it.
So let's talk about it and think about it and form an idea. There's no universally right or wrong answer, but you should at least be able to decide what answer is right to you.
> I don’t think it should be a 10x markup.
What about 1x markup?
> Intuitively, it seems that there’s something wrong with price gouging
There is, but you're relying on the word "gouging", and without identifying what price you think is gouging vs reasonable profit, stopping at the point where you express that "too much is too much" doesn't get us any closer to having actionable goals.
----
But to go along with your exercise, I take a look at current market dynamics and compare it from there. Apparently, the typical wholesale markup is 20-40%, and stores will typically markup another 20-50% on top of that. So we're talking roughly a 125% markup on the higher ends from the factory into the consumer's hands as a very rough average (VERY rough, markups vary a lot per product and industry).
That's with two chains of markup, so clearly 1000% feels absurd from one part of such a chain. Outside of factors like drinks (which are easy to scale and can have markups well into the hundreds), it's pretty hard to find any part of the chain as not "overcharged" once we go past 100% markups in any given place.
on the most generous side, Costco famously has markups limited to 14% (albeit they rely on bulk purchases to mitigate that). and subsidized vehicles used to generally be a 10-15% markup price. So I'd say 15% is about the bare bottom of what to expect markups without some kind of twist. e.g. printers selling at a loss, making up for it with high markups for ink (another product that's easy to scale and marked up into the hundreds). or previously, a video game console in order to sell games (software, whose markup is hard to really determine since it's infinitely scalable and costs are more to make up for R&D).
I perceive that one of the reasons that people who want change in the devastatingly perverted system are repeatedly plowed over, cheated, and ignored when it comes to making actual policy is that as a group those with the most reason to be upset are easily swindled into engaging only vague moans about some miniscule ignorable example being bad but not being ready to articulate what should be done instead as a set of categorical rules. And it happens over and over again until the voting public are bred into helplessness, and the way out is to talk about things in actionable ways instead of in vague handwavy ways. And the path to collective dialogue shift has to start somewhere, so it can start with us. Was it painful?
I suppose so. But I have no insight of these concepts outside of the 30 minutes I spent studying various markup strategies. And I have no interest in trying to personally influence policy (especially in something I studied for 30 minutes ". I don't know how many qualified people in this community can influence such stuff (or any that will read HN specifically) , so I simply question the tactic's effectiveness.
If you want to be quantitative of course you do. How hard is it? Margin of error is allowed. If you want to be qualitative, vague and wishy washy, that has its place too, but at some point someone is going to ask for a quantitative assertion, otherwise you get nowhere.
Just as the user of an App doesn't need to provide an alternative design when they say "this App sucks", the average user of healthcare likewise has no obligation to redesign the healthcare system when they say "this healthcare system sucks."
To be honest, I'm quite surprised you're siding with the provider here. Are you personally satisfied with healthcare pricing in the United States? Do you not share my intuition that in general, healthcare is too expensive and inefficient?
https://www.cms.gov/priorities/key-initiatives/healthplan-pr...
https://www.cms.gov/priorities/key-initiatives/hospital-pric...
https://www.dolthub.com/blog/2023-03-23-illusion-of-transpar...
> Humana published their MRFs across 11,000,000 different files, then rate-limited how fast you could download them
HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35347647
Maybe. The article also asserts their data, where available, is often also wrong. See the section titled "Cross checking with hospital data".
It is apples and oranges, though. Because 1) apps are hardly a critical need for the populace and 2) software margins are even more difficult to find that "line" to than physical resources.
I'm sure that medicine needs some higher than average markup in order to make up for R&D, ingredients, and various regulations to get it approved for human patients. But very unlikely 1000%. And only 1000% because of questionable vertical integration that lets UHC charge UHC however much it wants to itself.
We don't need to find the touchdown line when we're already outside of the stadium and the parking lot anyway.
https://content.naic.org/insurance-topics/pharmacy-benefit-m...
Semicon tool builders (my industry) have margins around 50% (cost + 100%). This is considered high margin manufacturing work.
To match United Health's margins we'd need to raise prices by 5x.
One part "free market -- maximize your profits as much as you can and get rewarded by a skyrocketing share price!"
And one part, unspoken except in the PR BS put out by the insurance companies, "Try to improve the health of patients and have them not die!"
The only way the two can coexist at all is if someone draws some lines like you are suggesting. I know that there are some (probably easily manipulated) laws stating that X% of premiums have to be "spent on care" and if they get too high overall margins on your group, they have to give your employer a rebate. Of course, who knows whether you'll see that money.
If we just say "maximize your profits" (and indeed, shareholders 'should' sue them if they don't) then it's obvious that morally bankrupt scum that runs all these insurers would 100% extort people for 1000% profits on lifesaving drugs. It's the most logical course of action! People will pay infinity dollars to save their own lives/their loved ones, so let's soak them!
If it's not obvious, I believe that overall the "free market" part of this system is a failed experiment that should be abolished immediately, and not just because I want all of these companies' sickening, greedy executives to go straight to hell (where Brian Thompson is burning today).
A better approach would be to mandate that everyone purchase individual or family policies directly from insurers on open exchanges using pre-tax dollars, with subsidies for low-income consumers.
after WW2, there was very obviously inflation. It was crazy in the EU and Japan, but the US still experienced some too. To fight this, the government made a then-common tactic of wage controls: basically cap off the maximum amount an employer can compensate workers, in order to fight the inflation spiral.
But there was an imporant exemption. This was only on wages and not any benefits given to employees in order to try and quell the inevitably angry employees. So when companies couldn't attract talent with more money, they offered more benefits. including employer sponsored healthcare. Perfect since these contributions were free from income tax.
And the modeled spiraled from there. a tax code passed in 1954 to let these contributions be business expenses, Medicaid came in the 60's, etc. It was great back then, but it was getting more expensive to navigate and companies started compromising to manage it. up to our favorite healthcare starting its vertical integration 20 years ago to come into what we know them for today.
Some loaves of bread are worth a dollar. Some are worth ten dollars. The exact line is hard to pin down... but a $1,000 loaf of bread is probably excessive.
Oh it does!
Perhaps we need antitrust action in healthcare.
Of course it's all subjective, but I cannot think of a single other industry that can get away with a 1000% markup on anything and expect to get away with it. In proper capitalism, that just means any competitor worth a dime can massively cut you with a 300% markup that is insane but a steal in comparison. Then it just stabilizes to some point between where competitors need more saavy to compete and more than some minimum markup to function.
I'd say overcharge is correct given the monopolistic structure of healthcare. You don't have too many choices to begin with and it's very hard to switch.
I do not like UnitedHealth, I do not like our existing crop of health insurance executives, and I might even be viscerally glad at some level that the UnitedHealth CEO was killed in a world where justice clearly takes a back seat to greed, but I wish the headline didn't say "overcharged", because there's no established amount of markup that is the correct amount of markup other than what people end up paying. Is that shitty? Yes. Does it violate a social contract? I think so. But tell me how much the right amount to charge is first. Is that cost? Cost+percentage? They've chosen their percentage. What's the correct one instead?
The article body presents the story in a more meaningful way, "UnitedHealth Group is charging patients a markup for key life-saving drugs that could easily exceed their cost by a factor of ten or more".