Just as the user of an App doesn't need to provide an alternative design when they say "this App sucks", the average user of healthcare likewise has no obligation to redesign the healthcare system when they say "this healthcare system sucks."
To be honest, I'm quite surprised you're siding with the provider here. Are you personally satisfied with healthcare pricing in the United States? Do you not share my intuition that in general, healthcare is too expensive and inefficient?
https://www.cms.gov/priorities/key-initiatives/healthplan-pr...
https://www.cms.gov/priorities/key-initiatives/hospital-pric...
https://www.dolthub.com/blog/2023-03-23-illusion-of-transpar...
> Humana published their MRFs across 11,000,000 different files, then rate-limited how fast you could download them
HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35347647
Maybe. The article also asserts their data, where available, is often also wrong. See the section titled "Cross checking with hospital data".
It is apples and oranges, though. Because 1) apps are hardly a critical need for the populace and 2) software margins are even more difficult to find that "line" to than physical resources.
I'm sure that medicine needs some higher than average markup in order to make up for R&D, ingredients, and various regulations to get it approved for human patients. But very unlikely 1000%. And only 1000% because of questionable vertical integration that lets UHC charge UHC however much it wants to itself.
We don't need to find the touchdown line when we're already outside of the stadium and the parking lot anyway.
If you want to be quantitative of course you do. How hard is it? Margin of error is allowed. If you want to be qualitative, vague and wishy washy, that has its place too, but at some point someone is going to ask for a quantitative assertion, otherwise you get nowhere.