That doesn't matter a slightest if people can't afford housing. Income is indeed disposed, without much to show off.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TXSTHPI
It's worse in San Francisco, but it's a nation-wide problem.
Florida: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FLSTHPI
Pennsylvania: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PASTHPI
Virginia: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/VASTHPI
Vermont: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/VTSTHPI
Tennessee: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TNSTHPI
"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."
Edit: That can never change either, in aggregate, so it’s literally futile to complain about it in general terms.
The housing market in Madison, Wisconsin is crazy. I sold my house 8 years ago, and now its estimated value is 70% higher than my selling price. I know a lot of people in the area who are despondent about the prices.
Ok, but what's the empirical justification for this claim? Why is Madison, Wisconsin a rare exception?
When people talk about low cost of living in the Midwest they generally mean more depressed areas. I live in a very low cost of living rural (15k ppl) community in Illinois, with half an acre on a lake in a 3000 sq foot house where the mortgage is only 250k. Of course, if I ever lose my remote job, I'd never be able to find work. Most of the people here work at one of 2 medium-sized factories or the hospital. The median household income is only $40k.
The town I live in is a far more common case for the rural Midwest.
> most of FAANG has outposts there to draw the CS talent.
I'm aware of a small Google office in Madison, but that's it.
almost any major city these days housing is much more expensive than it used to be relative to income
not based on the data
change in median housing prices as per Zillow, since 2017
Minneapolis: +50% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/5983/minneapolis-mn/
Omaha: +80% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/40152/omaha-ne/
St Louis: +62% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/6891/saint-louis-mo/
KC: +94% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/18795/kansas-city-mo/
OKC: +68% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/33225/oklahoma-city-ok/
Des Moines: +68% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/17759/des-moines-ia/
Milwaukee: +119% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/5976/milwaukee-wi/
Indianapolis: +103% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/32149/indianapolis-in/
Little Rock: +38% https://www.zillow.com/home-values/52998/little-rock-ar/
etc.
Disposable income means income after taxes. It does not include any expenses, housing, health care, or otherwise.
from the OECD website:
> Income includes wages and salaries, mixed income (income from self-employment and unincorporated enterprises), income from pensions and other social benefits, and income from financial investments. It is less taxes on income, wealth, social security contributions paid by employees, the self-employed and the unemployed, interest on financial liabilities, and the change in net equity of households in pension funds.
A bit of a clearer explanation here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_c...
The reason why the US has such high disposable income is because Americans have to pay for so much more out of pocket than other OECD countries do. Once you factor in health care, education and other social services that are cheap or free elsewhere, Americans are generally worse off than many OECD countries.
> It may include near-cash government transfers like food stamps, and it may be adjusted to include social transfers in-kind, such as the value of publicly provided health care and education.
Additionally from the OECD website:
> Household adjusted disposable income additionally reallocates "income" from government and Non-Profit Institutions Serving Households (NPISHs) to households to reflect social transfers in kind. These transfers reflect expenditures made by government or NPISHs on individual goods and services, such as health and education, on behalf of an individual household.
Also housing is more expensive in the US (total cost, not per sqft), as is food; in fact, the cost of living in general in the US is more expensive than Europe or Japan, with the notable exception of cars and gas.
For example, I just searched cost of living in France vs USA and the first two sites I found gave similar figures of 30% more in the US. Not representative of all of Europe of course but an interesting data point.
https://www.mylifeelsewhere.com/cost-of-living/france/united...
https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_countries_resu...
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_c...
The Oxford dictionary states "income remaining after deduction of taxes and other mandatory charges, available to be spent or saved as one wishes."
Mandatory charges, to most people outside of this HN thread, are their bills and other common expenses. Mortgages, utilities, school and incomes taxes, etc are considered mandatory charges.
I'm not saying this to argue with you. Ya'll are welcome to interpret it how you like. But if you don't consider this perspective, you are going to misunderstand what other people intend to express when they use the term disposable income.
mandatory charges are "mandatory" in the sense you are "mandated" by the gov to pay them; besides taxes these include social security contributions (some countries have more such "contributions"). The are no mandates (laws, regulations) that require you to pay for housing, food, education, etc.
I think the confusion is that _colloquially_ we refer to "disposable income" as meaning the money we can spend on things we want after we've covered all the essentials.
So you have at least one other person who uses the word like that.
I suppose you can live on the street, or move in with relatives.
On that note, you can also choose not to pay your taxes, but you'll also have to deal with those consequences.
The problem with what you said is that it's a statistic lumping all households together. As such it's largely meaningless because it lumps Elon's household with some person living in a trailer park in Montana. They are unlikely to have similar disposable income.
Equally, while health care might represent 17.6% of GDP, this of course provides no limit on any one person or group. Indeed, assuming that most billionaires are not spending 17.6% one can assume the real cost to many I'd much (much) higher than that.
No to the parent's statement about "poorer". There are many things to measure here beyond just "cash in the bank". And there are terms like "middle class" and "majority" which are imprecise.
Nevertheless the point, as an anecdote stands. While America the country is rich, not all the people in it are. Indeed it seems to be increasingly split into rich and poor - the middle class is shrinking.
The good news though is two fold. Firstly most Americans seem happy with this setup (presumably because it maintains the illusion that they can obe day be rich.)
Secondly the majority of (not rich) people believe that having rich people in charge will benefit them. No doubt the incoming government of billionaires is something to look forward to.
Which is all yo say that each country gets what they want. The US _wants_ for-profit health care. They believe it is the best in the world. Other countries think its bonkers and have other approaches. That's perfectly OK.
Indeed this is democracy in action. We vote for people who will best do what we want them to do. Who guide us, not just by their words but their actions. We clearly understand the actions of the incoming guy (he's been there before). He's clearly pro-health-company (not pro health consumer) so this is (quite literally) what people want.
The future looks very bright indeed!
> The US _wants_ for-profit health care
> We vote for people who will best do what we want them to do
> The future looks very bright indeed!
What did I just read.
(Feel free to read some sarcasm / blind adherence to democracy into the earlier post, but its hard to interpret the election results in another way.)
No, because it's a median value, thus outliers are irrelevant.
But even if it's a median, the point stands. At least half the country falls below this standard.
Equally the distribution of outliers is not balanced. There are a lot lot more outliers (far from the median) on the up side than the down side.
If a sibling comment[1] is to be believed, the "Southeast Asian backwater" in question seems to be Bangladesh. Looking at GDP per capita PPP (ie. adjusted for cost of living), united states is nearly 10x as rich. Is it possible to construct a hypothetical where a country has 10x higher GDP per capita than other, but the average citizen is poorer? Yes. Is that actually occurring? Unlikely.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42630667
>Nevertheless the point, as an anecdote stands. While America the country is rich, not all the people in it are. Indeed it seems to be increasingly split into rich and poor - the middle class is shrinking.
I don't know how you can possibly interpret the parent comment as just an "anecdote". It's specifically making claims about "the majority of middle-class Americans".
Source? I find this hard to believe given the US leads the OECD in terms of household disposable income[1], never mind whatever "Southeast Asian backwater" country you're talking about. It's unlikely "US healthcare profiteering" would affect this. Healthcare spending in the US is 17.6% of GDP, which provides an upper limit on how much it can eat into income. Even if you assume all that's borne by households and subtract that from income figures, the US would still be in #2.
[1] https://www.oecd.org/en/data/indicators/household-disposable...