News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by jbyers on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:15PM (#4252351)
I'm not talking about money or reputation. The risk I see is time and opportunity. She could spend a maddening four years not moving the needle at Yahoo rather than another company or a startup of her own. Four years of punishing travel, endless meetings, unending Wall Street scrutiny. That risk.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by TylerE on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:26PM (#4252438)
Did you seriously just compare the CEO position at Yahoo to a _start-up_? To think the two are even in the same zip code, much less the same ballpark, is just, well it reflects a rather isolated viewpoint, put it that way. Yahoo is a $19B corporation.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by jbyers on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:31PM (#4252481)
Corrected. Poor phrasing on my part. I was suggesting a likely alternative for her would be starting a company, not that Yahoo is anything like a startup.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by TylerE on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:41PM (#4252532)
No, that's exactly how I took it.

Oblig car metaphor: That's like saying hey, as an alternative to a free Lamborghini Aventador, you can have an old Pontiac Fiero chassis, and a Chevy 350 with a blown head gasket. If you're really lucky and amazing you might make something worth 1/10th what the Lamborghini is.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by falicon on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:54PM (#4252608)
Well in this case it's an original Lamborghini, but it was in a horrible wreck and has been sitting at the bottom of the sea for about ten years...

So you can dredge it up, and perhaps restore it to it's original glory...or you can go out and build your own, new dream car from scratch.

Either way it's going to be a TON of work to get to a truly valuable (and fun to drive) vehicle...

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by lukeschlather on Monday July 16, 2012 @08:38PM (#4253504)
Car metaphors are tempting, but Yahoo vs. a startup is more like the difference between fixing up a rusty EOL aircraft carrier and building a sailboat.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by chrischen on Monday July 16, 2012 @05:24PM (#4252768)
Also even if you restore the Lamborghini you will own way less than 30% of it.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by jarek on Monday July 16, 2012 @05:57PM (#4252901)
I'm not sure the analogy stretches quite that far. Do you really care how many percent you own if you can drive it whenever you like and modify it however you please?
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by temphn on Monday July 16, 2012 @06:45PM (#4253079)
Not really a good metaphor. Steve Jobs, Tony Fadell, Elon Musk, Max Levchin, and many more entrepreneurs chose to start a second company rather than take a C level job somewhere else. A better analogy is whether to adapt an off the shelf piece of code to scratch your itch (often a reasonable choice) or to write your own from scratch, clean slate. The latter is much more risky, but that fits a certain personality.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by FrojoS on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:18PM (#4253626)
Exactly. With her connections, knowledge and wealth she might be able to build an amazing company from scratch.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by kamaal on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:26AM (#4254783)
Not exactly,

Building a successful company is not a joke even if you have knowledge and connections. Users don't value what and whom you know.

At her level and for all she has done, getting to be the CEO of a billion dollar firm is actually a great deal.

Looking at it from other way around, Her career at Google might have probably come to a halt given the fact that Larry and Sergey are going to be there around for a long time to come. On the other hand, she could not be the CEO of a successful firm- Because such stints demand prior experience.

In short the change she got now is because, the company is currently a underdog. No big CEO who is already on a wave of success will take up that kind of a job. She needs the company because she gets to be the CEO and nobody else would offer her the same position.

In many ways this is a no brainer.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by debacle on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:47PM (#4252569)
No one I've talked to who works at Yahoo would compare it favorably to a Lamborghini.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by Retric on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @06:20AM (#4255064)
Except as CEO she would probably make enough to buy a new Lamborghini every week. People rarely talk about opportunity costs but if you can make more than 10 million a year spending 5 years building a company from scratch to see a 30 million exit is a Failure. And doing better than that is ridiculously rare.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by Aramgutang on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:13AM (#4254361)
You would think that at Hacker News, car analogies would not be necessary, since I imagine there is a large proportion of users like myself who have no interest in cars, and have never owned nor intend to own one.

I have no idea how a Pontiac Fiero or a Chevy 350 compares to a Lamborghini Aventator without looking it up. All I know is that all three are probably luxury automobiles. I have even less of clue about what a head gasket might be.

On the other hand, if you tried to explain something to me by using a job at Google, Yahoo, and a start-up as analogies, it would definitely help make things more understandable.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by entropy_ on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:22AM (#4254774)
Well, only the Lamborghini is a luxury car(unless you consider all cars a luxury but that would be a different discussion).

Otherwise, I fully agree with your point. I like cars and had no clue what, exactly, the Pontiac Fiero or the Chevy 350 were as I'm not American and those are American cars. Around here German(Mercedes, BMW, Audi, VW) and Japanese(Mazda, Subary, Toyota, ...) cars are much much more common.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by TylerE on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @09:27AM (#4255551)
Fiero: Pontiac's great experiment at making a European style sports car. A real _proper_ sports car: Mid-engined, rear wheel drive. Except, because most most of the parts were from other GM vehicles, it was mostly shite. Still - very popular with kit car/replicar builders because they made quite a few of them (~350,000) and they're cheap as donor cars.

Chevy 350: Basically a commodity engine. 5.7L pushrod V-8. Used in lots of GM vehicles from the late 60s through the early 90s. Camaros, Corvettes, Cadiallacs etc. Built tough, cheap, and there are a gazillion aftermarket parts available.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by entropy_ on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @11:58AM (#4256289)
I've always found it weird how different engine sizes are in American cars as opposed to everything else.

Unless you were going for a race car or something it's quite uncommon to have a 5.7L engine in anything but an American car.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by TylerE on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @01:57PM (#4256886)
It's fairly unusual these days. Only thing you'll find with an engine that big is either a full-size SUV, a large truck, or a Corvette.

Plus, if you weren't here, you might not appreciate just how horrible the "EPA era" engines were. Much stricter emission controls + not having the technology to really meet it led to some really de-tuned engines. Wouldn't be unusual for a 5-6L engine in those days to only make 140-160HP stock.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by mjwalshe on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:56AM (#4254846)
I thought HN had a large preponderence of "engineers" (or at least they claim to be) I would have expected almost 100% of us sould have enough knowledge to understand the analogy.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @05:47AM (#4254962)
Pontiac's and Chevy's are very American cars. Speaking as a European I can guess they're not as good as a Lamborghini but not with enough detail to make it a particularly useful comparison.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by kfury on Monday July 16, 2012 @06:19PM (#4252981)
The flaw with this analogy isn't likening Yahoo! to a Lamborghini. It's saying that startups are all the same, regardless of who's starting them.

If Elon Musk and a new Stanford grad started brand new companies on the same day, would both companies be old busted cars with blown head gaskets?

Also, the metaphor is a bit flawed by likening the 17-year-old floundering company to a new sports car and a hypothetical new company as something that's already worthless because of wear and tear.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by gfosco on Monday July 16, 2012 @05:33PM (#4252813)
The appropriate analogy would not be a free Lamborghini, but the chance to drive one (with 2 bad tires) for a while. Or, go buy/build your own car and own it.

I think it's a great move, and Google is probably in favor of it.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by benatkin on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:10PM (#4253596)
> Oblig

Please spare us the silly abbreviations.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by ttran4 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:25AM (#4254607)
Yahoo = Major Leagues , Starting your own start up = Minors
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by TheSOB88 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:37PM (#4257744)
Wow, has HN been taken over by business types already?

Don't you think Mayer has enough capital, connections, reputation, experience, etc. that if she started a company to do what she wanted, how she wanted, it would be completely different from your average college-grad startup?

I mean, come on now. There's no comparing the two.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by coreygoodie on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @09:20AM (#4255528)
Agreed. I understand there's a hacker mentality here, but who would really pass up the CEO at an established behemoth like Yahoo to take the reigns of an unproven (or found) startup?
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @07:39PM (#4258525)
Me. I'm not qualified to be the CEO of Yahoo, so I would only be setting myself up for failure if I took the job. But running a smaller company limits the amount of harm I can do to myself and others while I learn the ropes.

The only reason to expect Mayer to do well as the CEO of Yahoo would be if her work at Google were similar to that job in some respect. I'm not sure it is.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by mmakunas on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:32PM (#4252487)
True, but Yahoo! has made so many mistakes that she would have to really to screw up (like lie on your resume) for it to hurt her reputation. So that time and opportunity cost is unlikely to ever be a waste. If she fails, well Yahoo! was already a failure, if she succeeds, she's a perceived as savior. Either way, she's a contenter for ceo of any other major internet company going forward.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by dredmorbius on Monday July 16, 2012 @05:39PM (#4252837)
I see it as the wrestling with a pig problem.

If you wrestle with a pig, both of you get dirty, and the pig enjoys it.

Meyer's a superstar right now. Yahoo's had an anti-Midas touch on several people who've attempted to steer it right.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by PakG1 on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:43PM (#4253970)
I really don't understand why people are saying she won't get a reputation hit from this if she fails. Every other CEO trying to steer Yahoo right so far in recent history has a black eye and had to leave in relative disgrace. None of them had the superstar status that she has right now, but the fact is, none of them were allowed the conclusion "well, Yahoo was just too screwed up anyway". I'm not convinced that she'll be able to escape getting a black eye if she also fails. People are harsh on Yahoo CEOs. The deck is stacked against them in so many ways.
Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by curiouscats on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:44AM (#4254471)
I think because people believe at this point it is taken that failing at Yahoo would hardly be surprising. For 2 reasons: 1) the company is in much worse shape (especially in reputation) than it was when previous CEOs failed to turned things around and 2) after a bunch of people try and fail the stigma of failing is likely to be reduced. Also here reputation is so positive that failing at a task many think is going to be hard not to fail at, won't likely turn those thinking well of her around.

Now she could fail in ways that are so bad that it does harm her reputation, certainly. I tend to agree with those that think as long as she doesn't fail for reasons that make her look really bad, her reputation won't suffer too much.

Also if Yahoo is marginally successful she may get an outsized boost - due to others failing to do even that.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by technoslut on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @09:42AM (#4255606)
Yahoo is one of those companies who has so many great properties that it will be easier than it seems to resurrect that company. They just needed a competent CEO.

I think Mayer is the right choice.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by stcredzero on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:36PM (#4253953)
Actually, your metaphor and the pattern of ruining hopefuls fits a pattern from Greek Mythology. (Other tough guys try to capture/defeat/kill a fearsome monster, but Hercules shows he's an uber-stud by finally doing it)

So Yahoo's now the Erymanthian boar?

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:00AM (#4254519)
I see it more as an Augean stables.

Time to divert Los Gatos Creek and the Guadalupe River. But I think the stench is stronger than them.

Re:Google’s Marissa Mayer Tapped as Yahoo’s Chief by gbog on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @11:06AM (#4255957)
The law of statistics and its regression to the mean tell me she will likely succeed, but should not be credited for this success.