News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by HeatrayEnjoyer on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:36AM (#42338036)
Advertising is fundamentally corrosive to society and should be outlawed with few and carefully tailored exceptions. Any business models that consequently fail, fail because their externalities to collective society are now priced in.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Aerroon on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:40AM (#42338056)
You will just get other kinds of advertisement. Ads that are technically not ads. Things like product placements, free promotions, word of mouth campaigns etc.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by tossandthrow on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:48AM (#42338101)
These are ads and in many jurisdictions Also treated like ads.

Weird that This is not the case in the US?

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by arrowsmith on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:15AM (#42338280)
If you grew up in Europe, I promise that when you visit the US for the first time, you will be SHOCKED by America's advertising standards (or lack of them.)

Advertising is everywhere, everywhere, everywhere, everywhere, to an extent far beyond what you're used to from home. Posters, billboards, fliers, TV commercials, product placement, celebrity endorsements - you can barely step outside without being bombarded by yet another obnoxious advertisement. And "obnoxious" is an understatement: American adverts are noticeably more loud, garish, cheesy, repetitive and attention-grabbing.

It's really quite something. And it's exhausting.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ratherbefuddled on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:30AM (#42338381)
Sometimes I end up watching US TV with US ads on some stream. They are horrifying and amusing all at once.

The idea that prescription medication is marketed to the general public on TV is entirely foreign to me, the descriptions of conditions that 99% of people wouldn't have heard of make me wonder just who they are connecting with.

Then you get to the "side affects may include headaches, vomiting, diarrhoea, haemorrhaging, spontaneous combustion, exploding eyeballs, bubonic plague and instant death - do not take this drug if you are a living breathing human being" bit and you can't help but laugh. Who goes to their doctor after watching one of these?

And "Dude Wipes" - I mean is that a spoof?

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by zmgsabst on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:35AM (#42338821)
The pharma ads are bribes to news stations not to report on them (via being a major funding source for their parent conglomerate).
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by blueflow on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:16AM (#42338691)
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by arrowsmith on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:32AM (#42338803)
Amazing. Reminds me of a joke from an old South Park episode. The boys are watching something tragic and awful on the news, then it cuts to a ridiculous commercial that completely trivialises the tragedy. I can't remember the details (does anyone know what episode I'm talking about? Got the clip?) but it's a hilarious satire of how the news media operates.

That CNN clip is basically South Park in real life.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by mgraczyk on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:35AM (#42338410)
You get used to it in a few days, and it's part of the reason why businesses grow so much faster in the US (especially online). People who want your product find out about it much faster.

For example I buy SaaS, and the way I hear about most tools are ads. I choose what to buy via references and evaluation, but ads are often how to get things on my radar. Without Ads, I would have bought worse software in the past

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by BLKNSLVR on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:01AM (#42338593)
> You get used to it in a few days

I don't even know how to reply to that, but I feel the need to call it out as, potentially, the most creepy-as-fuck quote-unquote justification of literally anything.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by tolciho on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:12PM (#42343128)
You got used to blocking all ads back in the "punch the monkey" days, while also wondering about the externalities of flyers put under car windshield wipers, many of such flyers ending up in the drains and gutters as you walked around the unwalkable America. Perhaps America would be less a miserable place with fewer ads?

You remarked to a coworker that it would be a great justice if a Porta Potty truck overturned onto a spammer, and you respond to your coworker —good, hit them with another. Alas that karma does not work that way.

You forgot when the modern web got so bad—indeed, has only continued to, well, you have a term for it now, "enshittification"—as you do not recall the moment of souring. Was it a decade ago, or more like two?

You is here used in the Hindu sense of you being divided from you, as that is a good way to explain you being both a great fan of ads and you holding them in extremely low regard. You may also recall that you sometimes make "you're either with us, or against us" pronouncements.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by mgraczyk on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:08PM (#42352479)
I don't understand what you're trying to say here
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by int_19h on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:05PM (#42352463)
Why do you need ads for that? Why doesn't your research for things that you buy not start with looking up the list of all prominent contenders in that niche?
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by mgraczyk on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:07PM (#42352477)
Where is the list? And what if I don't know the category exists?
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by int_19h on Saturday December 07, 2024 @04:05PM (#42352856)
You search online. You ask people on Reddit etc.

If you have a specific problem you're trying to solve, then you will find out about the relevant categories.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by arrowsmith on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:44AM (#42356593)
If your "problem" is so insignificant that you're not even aware that there exists a category of products that might "solve" it, it sounds to me like you don't actually need the product.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by sofixa on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:10AM (#42338654)
And also, all of their ads are THE BEST something. Even if it's showing some greasy microwaved slop billed as food.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ChrisMarshallNY on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:30AM (#42340128)
> American adverts are noticeably more loud, garish, cheesy, repetitive and attention-grabbing.

I take it that you have not been to Tokyo or Seoul, then?

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by xandrius on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:34PM (#42341975)
I have unlocked understanding Japanese and it blew my mind how pervasive advertisements are.

Most foreign people would just gloss over them but even most temples (say in Kyoto) have the names of companies which donated money plastered all over the place.

Even the famous tori gates at inari have cool looking Japanese text which basically says "Applebees", "Yamato Metal Industries", and so on.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by arrowsmith on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:57PM (#42342244)
Nope!
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ChrisMarshallNY on Friday December 06, 2024 @01:42PM (#42342765)
Their ads make the American advertisers look like teetotalers.

Some of my faves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRLe826lyao

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by arrowsmith on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:42AM (#42356585)
So you're saying the fake advert in Friends wasn't far off: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOy2lrJqKGY
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by tossandthrow on Saturday December 07, 2024 @06:46AM (#42349130)
I have been to the US on numerous occasions - and do like it!

My main curiosity was about the legal classification of product placement etc.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Aerroon on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:54AM (#42338132)
They aren't all ads, because the situation gets really muddy. If a website talks about an upcoming movie is that an ad? What if they were shown the movie before its release?
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by AdamN on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:13AM (#42338270)
It's not all that muddy under normal circumstances - if there are payments to the producers then it's an ad. There is the problem in extremis though - a person gets a cameo on a show and then uses that to sell other products and in return helps out the producer in some non-obvious way.

It's an issue but I'd be happy with a 90% solution over a 0% solution.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by quietbritishjim on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:10AM (#42339055)
Ok but what if you're allowed to watch the movie/game/etc. for free before general release? That might not seem like payment, after all it's just necessary to allow the review to happen. But what if review sites that give a few bad reviews are denied this access? And no one wants to read reviews after release?

In the end, on paper, the studio has no editorial oversight, but in practice you need to give them good reviews (essentially, adverts) if your business is to survive.

This is exactly how it works, by the way.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by kassner on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:00AM (#42340406)
Would they get to watch it for free if they release their review months after the movie is released? If no, then it’s an ad, with just a very low price.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Timwi on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:07AM (#42338222)
It's an ad if and only if it is mixed into an article that is not about the movie. If I click a link that says that the article behind it is about the movie, it's not an ad. If I click on a link to a comparison of PC networking equipment, then it's an ad because a movie is not PC networking equipment.

This doesn't mean the movie article (or indeed the hardware comparison) can't be sponsored. It just means the ad shouldn't be able to be shoved in your face unsolicited.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by querez on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:02AM (#42338599)
Ok, so you have a review article about PC networking equipment, sponsored by Cisco. That's an ad for you. Now you go to the homepage of the site that wrote that review. They link to that review from their home page. Is that an ad? Probably, because it could contain an ad-like image as its banner (showing Cisco equipment) and maybe even a slightly ad-ish title ("Cisco outperforms other networking equipment in our recent review of x articles").

So, is another page, that links to that page also an ad? Because maybe the homepage that runs Cisco-sponsored reviews might also have a cisco-sponsored banner. And even if not, maybe over time they become associated as "the thing that reviews things were cisco always wins"...

Oh, and what if it wasn't a sponsorship. What if instead Cisco just gave them the hardware to test at a discount? Or for free? Would you not write a slightly more favourable review for nvidia if they gifted you their top-tier GPU? What if instead of gifting you the GPU, they just give it to you at a discount? Or earlier than normal customers? Or they just have nvidia-stickers for your kids in the box?

Ads are an extremly slipperly slope, they're part of human nature; everyone I ever met is trying to tell me about (=market) themselves, their beliefs, their current hobbies, that new burger place down the road, ....

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by blitzar on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:02AM (#42338182)
Reviews are ads. Thats why these people call themselves "influencers".
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by oneeyedpigeon on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:06AM (#42338626)
Roger Ebert will be turning in his grave.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by prmoustache on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:09AM (#42338652)
Well most hollywood movie productions are just 1h30 ads nowadays. You can usually see ton of product placement with closeup on logos and products that do not make any sense for the storytelling.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by account42 on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:55AM (#42338550)
We get those already so removing all the others is still an improvement. But we can outlaw paid product placements too.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by 93po on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:54AM (#42339813)
we already have laws that make it illegal to accept money for certain circumstances, e.g. sex, bribery, extortion. Just make it illegal to accept money to promote products. I say this not because I think it's illegal but rather to challenge the status quo - i don't think there's a reason we couldn't do this other than humans being fragile and inflexible
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by wat10000 on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:35AM (#42340187)
Good.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by refulgentis on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:57AM (#42338150)
> Advertising is fundamentally corrosive to society

Interesting, why?

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Sammi on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:37AM (#42338833)
Because they want to make you do stuff that is not in your best interest. They want to create a need that you don't actually have, and they do so by applying psychological pressure. They are a festival of fomo. They're pollution for your mind and distort your sense of reality.

In a knowledge economy your attention is your highest commodity, and ads want to take all of it.

One of the strongest rules I have for my household is that my children don't see any ads. I pay for Netflix, Youtube, and Spotify and use adblockers on all devices. And my tv is not connected to anything that can deliver flow tv - the biggest mindrot of all.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by XCSme on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:53AM (#42338936)
How else do you find out about new stuff, or recommendations, or things you never considered before?

How do you find out about new movies, concerts, etc.?

Most customers don't know themselves that a solution to their problem (which they might not even notice) exists.

Manipulative ads are bad, yes. But ads that expand your knowledge of what's available in the world are good in my opinion.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Sammi on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:18AM (#42339105)
I wanted to know about headphones that have high sound quality yesterday and you know what I did to find out? I googled it.

I found out about ChatGPT and became a paying subscriber in january 2023, because it was all over hckrnews, youtube, twitter and tech media in general.

New stuff and recommendations are everywhere. They are even a form of entertainment themselves. I watch several tech channels on youtube just to see what cool new stuff there is. There are channels and websites for movies, books, home renovation, hobbies and anything really if you want to know more.

No ads needed.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by XCSme on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:37AM (#42339236)
I think that's a good point, and it does make me doubt my initial comment.

One issue now, on a world without ads, is what incentive would also those actors have to provide you with that information? Search engine, review websites, YouTube channels, etc. Of course, we could pay them for this information. They could also have affiliate links, but doesn't then it become an ad?

I think we hate ads now simply because they are implemented poorly and there's a lot of low quality, deceiving ads for useless products.

I play table-tennis a lot, and my shoes are always wet after a session, I usually left them outside to dry, but it doesn't work in bad weather (which is common here). I then saw an ad for shoe-fresh (a dry rack/sanitizer for your shoes), I got one, and it has completely solved this problem. Maybe I could have found about it in a different way, but this is how I found it.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by XCSme on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:40AM (#42339252)
Another example is computer games. I got No Man's Sky recently because it was discounted on Steam, and I always wanted to try it. I would consider the pop-up you get when you launch steam, and the discounts showed in the store to also be "ads". I am enjoying the (still buggy) game so far.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by int_19h on Saturday December 07, 2024 @03:13PM (#42352525)
If you want to buy a specific Steam game on discount, you can just add it to watchlist and get a notification when it has one.

If you want to buy some random games because they are discounted, you can just go to the corresponding section in the Steam store.

The point of the popup is to distract you from whatever you're doing right now to get you to make an impulse purchase, as opposed to a well-researched one. That's exactly how people end up with Steam accounts that have literally hundreds of never-played games in them.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by magicalhippo on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:41AM (#42339264)
You're talking about placed ads. The OP was talking about all advertising.

Viewing a review on a site where the reviewer got sent a set of headphones to review is also advertisement. It's just not a placed ad.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Workaccount2 on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:16AM (#42340542)
No ads needed for you.

Just like you can visit hacker news and see all the stories right there, do they just manifest through out the day? Or is there a group of people trudging through the new stories to pick which ones to elevate?

Having worked on the product side, I can tell you that when you google a product looking for organic reviews, what you are seeing is the sprouts of seeds planted by advertising.

Trust me, try and launch an amazing product with no advertising.

Then do it with a standard set of web ads, wait a few months, and go see the people on reddit talking about your product despite you never doing more than buying standard website/social media ads (not sponsored posts, just regular ads)

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Sammi on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:30PM (#42346117)
I am right now launching a sass product that I develop using advertisement. I have launched many products in the past. I used to be a concert organizer and band manager in my youth. All the times I have driven around town to hang up posters... I went to business school. I know advertisement.

Advertisement is 99.999% bad people doing bad things to you.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by sotix on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:32AM (#42340155)
> How else do you find out about new stuff, or recommendations, or things you never considered before?

Personally, I chat with friends over a beer and talk about new things. More often than not, my friends have great recommendations on things to try — both old and new.

> How do you find out about new movies, concerts, etc.?

I go check the movie listings / concert venues’ schedules. Or look up the schedule for a band I like. I don’t constantly browse the lineup; only when I get the itch to go to a show.

Normally I’m the one engaging research into new experiences, and it seems to be going fine. The other month I was reading Troy by Stephen Fry. When I finished, I thought it would be nice if he covered the Odyssey, so I looked it up and saw he is releasing an ebook for it in the Spring. In the meantime, I decided to read the Iliad. I wasn’t sure which translation would be good, so I searched online and found that Emily Wilson has a great translation. And now hopefully a reader has benefited from m y suggestion here.

Most ads related to these fields seem to me that they are designed to sell me something I don’t necessarily want or need. I feel capable of taking action and looking up things that do interest me. It may be different for areas outside of entertainment, but I’d have to think on that more.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by wat10000 on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:37AM (#42340208)
True, that one time in 1996 where I actually found out about a useful, high quality product from an advertisement was pretty nice.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ulrikrasmussen on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:03AM (#42338189)
They incentivize collecting sensitive data about people.

They incentivize businesses to maximize for engagement which generally promotes harmful content over informational content. Empty informational calories.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by rpastuszak on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:59AM (#42338582)
I'll add: in practice its goal is not to solve a problem, but to create a need.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ulrikrasmussen on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:50AM (#42339331)
Good point. I suppose the theoretical utility of advertisement is to supply information to consumers about what the market offers so consumers can seek out suppliers that fulfill their demands. Supplying that kind of information to consumers provides utility for both the supplier and the consumer. This goal can also be accomplished without unsolicited advertisement but using directories where consumers can look up suppliers based on their needs.

Unsolicited advertisement tries to induce a sense of demand in consumers which they didn't have to begin with. This is done using many different tactics, e.g. by disguising the true cost, exaggerating the benefits or simply misinforming. This tips the utility in favor of the supplier while making it harder for the consumer to navigate the market.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by left-struck on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:28AM (#42338788)
To be fair advertising without collecting sensitive data does exist. I think the collection of sensitive data is a more serious issue so let’s not say all ads are abusive in that way.

However, I agree with the position that all ads with some small exceptions are a negative thing. I think the incentives behind advertising are inherently perverse because of what they are at their core, an attempt to manipulate (if they work then a successful attempt!). They are dishonest and inauthentic by design. It’s possible to create an ad that is like “hey this thing exists and this is strictly what it does without any exaggeration” but that basically never happens because the people who make ads have no external incentive to do that.

I think a much more ideal situation is where a user searches for something on a search engine, or an LLM or whatever, and they are shown as unbiased as possible results. This way the people making good products get their exposure and the people looking stuff get the stuff they want. Of course there’s a lot of problems in practice with that as well.

I don’t claim to have a solution, and I don’t think making an add is like super immoral, but I think ads are a scourge on our society and culture.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by ulrikrasmussen on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:12AM (#42339068)
Yes, I agree, and I also don't think that ads in printed newspapers and magazines are a problem, for example.

If I were to propose a general law to regulate advertisements, then it would be that if you serve content that qualifies as being an advertisement to a user, then the choice of advertisement must be independent of any data about that user. This includes the username and any details the user has entered or which has been collected as the user has been using the service, and also any ephemeral data associated with the session such as IP address. That is, the choice of ad is completely parametric in the user; if two users request the content from different locations, then they should in principle be served the same ad (ignoring other state such as ad impression counters which would still be allowed).

This would probably not be good for the ad-tech industry but I think it could remove many of the perverse incentives leading to excessive data collection.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by oneeyedpigeon on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:08AM (#42338641)
You just need to ask yourself: would/do advertisers lie if they could/can get away with it? And the answer is "faster than you can blink".
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Timwi on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:12AM (#42338267)
For me, it's because it's carefully crafted to be as manipulative as possible. It uses modern psychological tricks to influence our thought and behavior in ways we are unaware of and largely powerless against. The intention behind an ad is not to inform but to influence, in a way that benefits somebody's wallet at the expense of societal well-being. It's a reprehensible, psychopathic motivation to be pursuing.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by pythonguython on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:03AM (#42339888)
Noam Chomksy’s critique is that the advertising industry’s main goal is to ensure that uninformed consumers make irrational choices. Essentially it undermines the market, due to the fact that in theory markets are efficient when people make rational decisions. Subject to advertising, people may pay more for a lesser quality product.
Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by Timwi on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:01AM (#42338172)
There's only one “carefully tailored” exception that I approve of, and that's when it's solicited.

Ads should show if and only if the user asked for them. There are plenty of people who intentionally opt out of ad blockers to support their favorite websites, or who enjoy browsing ads and shopping. There's a reason ad-only TV channels (24-hour infomercial stuff) are viable despite being able to be turned off at will, and plenty of people subscribe to product-promotion magazines (catalogues). I'm sure there are websites for those interests, too.

What should be outlawed is mixing unsolicited content into solicited. If I solicit a video on black holes, or a blog article on Python, it should not be allowed to interrupt it with a dishonest, manipulative appraisal of some VPN service. That's immoral and disgusting.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by bogwog on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:54AM (#42339806)
I hate the modern advertising ecosystem, but ads themselves are not evil. We're just in a place where there is no limit to the what/when/where/how many. Without advertising, it would be really difficult to run a business.

Back when Google was great, they kind of acted as an advertising police on the entire internet, keeping ads unobtrusive and negatively ranking sites with bad user experiences. That system worked pretty well back in the day (although definitely not perfect), and I think it gives a good model to start from if we as a society ever decide to try and fix this hellscape we're living in.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by godshatter on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:03PM (#42341619)
In my view, the ads themselves are only slightly evil since they are designed to influence you subtly (well, sometimes subtly) into paying for something you probably don't want. Not a big deal, I have shields in place for that mentally. I wouldn't hate them so much if they didn't try to track you around the web and didn't sell your info to anyone with some loose change in their pockets.

I never hated ads when we had full-page ads in magazines and you had to skip multiple pages of ads to get to the actual articles. But selling my data makes them too much money, so I do my best to never have them load on the internet.

Re:The correct amount of ads is zero by account42 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @07:16AM (#42376140)
> Without advertising, it would be really difficult to run a business.

It's difficult to run a business without advertising in a world full of advertising. If others can get to your customers before they find you then yes that's a problem. But all you get from paying to advertise is to get back to where you would have been without ads (assuming your competitors spend a similar amount).