News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by HDThoreaun on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:38AM (#42318485)
The US spends over 17% of GDP on healthcare, double comparable countries. The main reason for that is because Americans consume too much health care. We need insurance to reject worthless procedures more, not less. Unfortunately the incentives are terribly misaligned, everyone will say "just trust your doctor" but doctors get paid for their services so they often recomend things that are not helpful. The obvious solution is moving from a fee for service system to a capitated fee per patient on your panel system but congress is broken so we're stuck in our shitty local minima.

The onus on keeping patients safe needs to be with healthcare providers not insurance, and the providers should be paid for keeping people healthy, not maximizing the number of procedures they can do.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by schmidtleonard on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:40AM (#42318512)
It's wild that we let insurance companies label government triage as "death panels" while for-profit denial innovation got a free pass.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:46AM (#42318588)
Source?
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by SteveNuts on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:55AM (#42318695)
The "Death panel" thing was the primary boogeyman when the ACA was being discussed. But like the comment says, that already exists, just in private form instead of government.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by criddell on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:51AM (#42318647)
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:00AM (#42318756)
> Sarah Palin coined the phrase "death panel" in a widely shared Facebook post.

Does not support the claim

> we let insurance companies label government triage as "death panels"

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by nameless912 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:46PM (#42319917)
I would be fascinated to see to who was donating to Sarah Palin's campaigns at the time.

In the US, all political speech is bought and sold on the open market. Especially statements made by (most) politicians.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by Arainach on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @02:42PM (#42321238)
Insurance companies funded the vast majority of advertising using that term to attack the ACA, and their lobbyists meet with politicians often enough that it's entirely plausible they coined the initial term as well (though harder to prove)
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @04:17PM (#42322134)
So there is no evidence.

The simpler explanation is that political Party A proposed legislation, and political Party B attacks it because a win for Party A is a loss for Party B.

And digging into just slightly further makes the claim make even less sense:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_panel

> Palin's spokesperson pointed to Section 1233 of bill HR 3200 which would have paid physicians for providing voluntary counseling to Medicare patients about living wills, advance directives, and end-of-life care options. Palin's claim was reported as false and criticized by the press, fact-checkers, academics, physicians, Democrats, and some Republicans.

Why would managed care organizations (aka health insurance companies) oppose the government paying for more healthcare services?

MCOs earn 2% to 3% of the premiums that flow through them. The higher the healthcare spend, the higher the premiums, the higher the profit for MCOs.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by Arainach on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:29PM (#42322759)
"No evidence" - if you can't avoid misinterpreting every sentence to go off on a rant, this thread is not worth continuing.

Insurance companies spent billions of dollars on advertisements against the ACA. This is public record. They did it because they opposed all of the good things the act required - such as prohibiting discrimination base on pre-existing conditions or demographics (other than age), requiring many basic procedures to be covered, bans on lifetime/annual coverage maximums, bans on dropping policy holders when they get sick, prohibiting copays on various services such as vaccines, requiring that insurers spend at least 80% of their premiums on health costs, a wide array of reforms to constrain costs, and so on.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:49PM (#42322917)
Someone claimed health insurance companies came up with “death panels”, I provided evidence and logic to the contrary.

No one is ranting, but there does seem to be a lot of “I feel like this could have happened, so I am going to choose to believe this happened because it confirms my priors”.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by Arainach on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @05:57PM (#42322976)
That's not correct. The OP said that

>we let insurance companies label government triage as "death panels"

Who said the term first doesn't matter. Who popularized it does. Insurance lobbyists and the conservative politicians they funded did.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @06:29PM (#42323199)
And I see no sources that insurance companies had anything to do with it, just assertions.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by HDThoreaun on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:43AM (#42318546)
Indeed, the insurance companies deserve a ton of blame too. They rightly have death panels but use scare tactics to keep people away from gov health insurance that does the same. Still, theyre playing by the rules the gov came up with. Fee for service is a horrible healthcare strategy and insurance is forced into it.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by maxerickson on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:54AM (#42319375)
Do HMOs charge themselves fees?
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by baggy_trough on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:47AM (#42318599)
You can switch insurance companies much more easily than you can switch government policies.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by SteveNuts on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:03AM (#42318787)
By switching jobs? That's not always feasible for many reasons.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by baggy_trough on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:43AM (#42319242)
That in no way contradicts my point.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by behringer on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:14PM (#42319567)
Why do we need a government program. Continue with the medicare/medicaid and child healthcare programs as always. Outlaw regular health insurance. The problem will solve itself. "Free market".
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by mossTechnician on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:01AM (#42318760)
"Americans consume too much healthcare"? I'm afraid to guess the logical conclusion to this, but I will counter with "Americans are offered two little preventative healthcare", because in more advanced countries where that is an option, the costs are lower.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by behringer on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:14PM (#42319571)
Also americans are fed horrifying food products that are outlawed in civilized countries.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by HDThoreaun on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @03:23PM (#42321653)
The conclusion is that we need to get rid of fee for service so that doctors stop prescribing things that dont work. Getting rid of fee for service also increases the amount of preventative healthcare people receive as providers realize its cheaper to do preventative than massive surgery down the line.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by mossTechnician on Thursday December 05, 2024 @08:40AM (#42328138)
Thank you for clarifying; I had a very different read on your previous comment that was probably the opposite of your intent.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by benterix on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:54AM (#42319381)
> The US spends over 17% of GDP on healthcare

It doesn't have to be 17%, it can be an arbitrary number because the ones who decide on the nominal pricing are the ones who make money on them being extremely high. These same procedures can in some cases cost even 2-3 orders of magnitude less - and not in another country but in the same hospital but with a patient willing to pay in cash.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by slt2021 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @02:18PM (#42320965)
list prices are high to scare Americans into buying [more expensive] insurance plan.

they want Americans be scared of going bankrupt from medical bills.

on the backend, between insurance and hospital, these giant list prices are automatically lowered by factor of 10 to the actual cost of procedure

the business model is: 1. insurance scares people with huge prices 2. healthy americans buy a lot of expensive insurance 3. money is injected into healthcare system from healthy patients 4. money is split among insurance/pbm/providers/pharma

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by criddell on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:48AM (#42318609)
And insurance companies want us to need more or pay more for health care, not less. Insurance is regulated and the companies can only hold on to a certain percentage of the premiums.

They would rather hold on to 20% of a huge number than 20% of a big number.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by HDThoreaun on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:53AM (#42318680)
Agreed, the incentives are horribly misaligned throughout the entire healthcare market. We desperately need legislative overhaul but again congress is completely broken.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by wing-_-nuts on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:02AM (#42318784)
>The main reason for that is because Americans consume too much health care.

No, come on man, this is easily googleable. Americans go to the doctor less than other countries, they stay in the hospital less than other countries, they have lower life expectancy, infant and mother mortality than other countries. If you want to know why we spend so damned much, it's because we're billed 2-3x as much for the same care as other countries.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by LargeWu on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:24AM (#42319049)
A more apt statement might be that we spend more, even if our quality of care is not better. And the reason we spend more is because of profit-maximizing companies in the middle.
Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by snakeyjake on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:56AM (#42318714)
The primary reason for the cost difference is the massive network of middlemen injected into the system, and rampant profiteering by for-profit healthcare companies.

Average cost of 1 vial of insulin in France: $9.08

Average cost of 1 vial of insulin in the US: $98.70

HDThoreaun: huffing some libertarian shit "The people are using too much insulin."

https://www.rand.org/pubs/articles/2021/the-astronomical-pri...

https://www.visualcapitalist.com/cost-of-insulin-by-country/

https://aspe.hhs.gov/reports/comparing-insulin-prices-us-oth...

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by Mainsail on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:06AM (#42318827)
> the massive network of middlemen injected into the system

Does anyone have a good reference for this? It's something that I inherently assume exists but would love to see a flowchart of how rampant it is and where different layers are siphoning their penny.

Would that even be possible?

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by slt2021 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @02:14PM (#42320911)
just look up increase in headcount of administrative staff at hospitals, providers, insurance companies, pharmacy benefit managers, etc.

all their salaries and profits are coming from patient's pocket

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @11:02AM (#42318783)
It’s not middlemen. The middlemen (managed care organizations, aka health insurance companies) earn low single digit profit margins.

In the US healthcare chain, the ranking of profit margins goes (and this is public info from public financials):

Pharmaceutical companies

Healthcare software companies (based on other software company margins)

Healthcare providers (doctor groups)

Hospitals (HCA, tenet, etc)

Managed care organizations and retail pharmacies at the very bottom.

The big one I don’t know is legal, which I assume slots between hospitals and healthcare providers, but could be higher. Those millions and tens of millions of dollar judgments don’t come from thin air.

Go ahead and get rid of MCOs, and at best you will reduce costs by 5%. That’s an objective fact. They are just allocating the very limited resources among more and more demand.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by psadauskas on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:00PM (#42319439)
I think you left out several layers. At least one of which in the news lately is the PBM, which sit between hospitals/providers and pharmaceutical companies, and are able to exert monopoly power on that market. They have agreements with hospitals that hospitals are only allowed to purchase through them, and then their suppliers are permitted to purchase exclusive access. This results in things like the saline shortage last year, and pushing small local pharmacies out of business. The PBMs also have incredible profit margins, upwards of 80%.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_2yTvHoGs4

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:05PM (#42319476)
Not true. PBMs are just departments of MCOs, so they are included in the profit margins of MCOs (at the bottom).

>The PBMs also have incredible profit margins, upwards of 80%.

I would love to see a single SEC filing showing this, mostly because there exist no standalone PBM.

Also, YouTube is not a source for financial information. 10-Ks, for example, would be.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by phil21 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @02:25PM (#42321036)
> Go ahead and get rid of MCOs, and at best you will reduce costs by 5%. That’s an objective fact.

That doesn't make any sense. Profit margin is meaningless if you are spending billions on a bunch of useless administrative staff pushing paperwork for no reason.

Obviously some of that is necessary, but certainly not nearly all of it. I don't care about a company making 5% on top of a $150k/yr admin salary. I care about the $150k/yr salary which is the true cost added to the system.

Having watched from afar my friends in healthcare who actually provide bedside care vs. the administrative bloat - it's going much like education. Tons of admin staff added that don't ever touch patients that seemingly just get in the way of the folks doing the actual work.

Margin is a meaningless number if you can just pump your expenses to increase the total dollar amount.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @02:32PM (#42321115)
> Margin is a meaningless number if you can just pump your expenses to increase the total dollar amount.

That doesn’t make any sense. If one MCO were to pump their expenses, there are 4 to 6 others waiting to take their customers with lower premiums.

Currently, medical loss ratios are around 85% to 90%, which means MCO administrative costs are 8% or maybe 10%, at most.

However, getting rid of the MCO doesn’t mean those costs go away. Government employees will have to do the prior authorizations rather than MCO employees. So I split the difference, and you end up with a net savings of 5%. Make it 10% if you want to be super optimistic and think the government will streamline paperwork for healthcare providers.

The other 90% of healthcare costs are still there.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by snakeyjake on Friday December 06, 2024 @11:19AM (#42341132)
>there are 4 to 6 others waiting to take their customers with lower premiums

Why do people believe this?

Healthcare isn't widgets and factories in an ECON-101 class.

The chances of anything short of an extremely large and well-funded consortium of investment bankers and private equity firms starting a new MCO is exactly and precisely 0.0%.

And those groups have the same incentives to maximize the payouts to all parties involved that the incumbents do.

Of course, they would never do that because increased competition would threaten their already-extensive investments in the sector.

The problem isn't regulation, or regulatory capture, or any other buzzword a podcast full of morons bandies about.

The problem is that you need at least $10 billion just to open the doors.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 07, 2024 @07:16AM (#42349277)
> Why do people believe this?

Because there are.

UNH/Elevance/CVS/Cigna/Humana/Centene/Molina are just the biggest publicly listed ones. They might not all offer plans in all states on the exchange, but there’s a decent amount of competition for employer subsidized plans.

The low single digit profit margin proves the competition exists such that the sellers don’t have pricing power to earn a higher profit margin.

Re:UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot in midtown Manhattan by S_Bear on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @04:49PM (#42322406)
My insurance denied me a MRI and physical therapy because having 2 working arms was a luxury. Had to pay out of pocket to be able to lift my arm above my head. Private insurance can go shove it.