Zero countries in the West enacted anything resembling martial law. The only freedoms abridged were those of movement and assembly, and even then the penalty was being shut down or ticketed, rarely jail, never summary execution.
Everyone else knew the difference between masks and literal martial law.
[1] https://www.factcheck.org/2020/03/martial-law-isnt-imminent/
I'd agree with this characterisation.
> I'd agree with this characterisation.
I consider it an occupation of the capital. If re-establishing public order by forcing lawbreakers to leave is martial law, then so be it. It needed to happen.
There have been successful long-running protests in Ottawa in the past, including encampments outside the national legislature, without any hard response. Sticking dozens or hundreds of trucks belching diesel fuels and blaring horns in the central part of the national capital for a month, and preventing police from keeping order, goes beyond any normal protest.
This is independent of the claim that it didn't happen ("Zero countries in the West enacted anything resembling martial law"). We're just talking about whether martial law was imposed, not whether it was unjustified.
Rather than "freedom of movement and assembly", I'd argue that what we lost was "freedom of due process". Everyone was jailed, just in their own homes.
Your freedom of movement is always restricted around e.g. U.S. military installations. That isn't a contradition, it's an abridgement.
> what we lost was "freedom of due process". Everyone was jailed, just in their own homes
Not what jail means. Not what due process means. Plenty of people broke the restrictions, some might have gotten ticketed. For those who faced jail time, they had access to courts. That is due process. You don't get any of that under martial law.
There was no curfew, particularly no curfew enforced by the military with threat of violence... ah, except during actual riots in a few cities.
Businesses were forced to close alongside many non-essential government services.
Nobody was jailed, not even in their own homes.
Enforcement was through ordinary civil means, not by actual soldiers pointing guns at you, unaccountable to civilian law.
This isn't "close" to martial law.
No other freedoms were abridged. The consequence for breaking the rule were mostly fines. And those fines were subject to judicial review, which eventually found them unconstitutional [1].
Under martial law you don't get a court. You don't get a fine or to complain about it online. You get sent to jail or worse; someone checking IDs is going over the top.
https://www.foxnews.com/world/australia-debuts-new-orwellian...
Yes, that's dystopic. Yes, making people do that for 14 days after traveling anywhere in the country is martial law in all but name only.
Yes, imposing fines instead of jailing people for exercising civil rights is still martial law.
Yes, people who resisted were arrested: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-54007824
Stop gaslighting us. We know exactly what happened, and don't like it, and it's a large reason the american election went as it did.
That was a single state government (South Australia), a state with only around 7% of Australia’s population. And it only applied to people in post-travel quarantine. It would be like if a US state government (e.g. Florida, which is roughly the same percentage of the US population as South Australia is of Australia’s) introduced some controversial policy and then non-Americans were presenting it as “the US makes you…”, as if it were some nation-wide policy
It's not. If we broaden to this definition, America has been under martial law since passports, border control and driver's licenses.
> imposing fines instead of jailing people for exercising civil rights is still martial law
No, it isn't. If we broaden to this definition, America has been under martial law since its founding.
> people who resisted were arrested
Sure. And charged. Due process. Not martial law.
> We know exactly what happened, and don't like it, and it's a large reason the american election went as it did.
One, we didn't experience any of what you listed in America. Two, the election went the way it did because of the economy. Three, election! Not a thing under martial law!
You can credibly say the Covid restrictions were authoritarian, dystopic and even unconstitutional. You cannot say they resembled martial law. A hit and run is a terrible crime, that doesn't mean it's a war crime, and someone arguing it isn't a war crime isn't saying it's okay.
It's arguing a rubber duck from a battleship. Emergency powers != martial law. Martial law in America would mean suspending the Constitution.
Calling anything that happened in America during lockdown martial law is the equivalent of Karen calling bad service at a restaurant an assault on her rights. It's misunderstanding a term but wanting to use it because it's edgy.
Just the various takes i've read in newspapers about why people are fed up and desire change.
> Martial law in America would mean suspending the Constitution.
> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;
The SC has ruled that 'Congress' means the government writ large, including state governments.
https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-04-26/pastor...
https://www.npr.org/2021/02/06/964822479/supreme-court-rules...
Oops... guess that one was suspended! If you have to appeal to SCOTUS to un-suspend it, it's safe to say that it was suspended.
They made less money. I'm looking forward to the next two years: I and everyone in my friend circle are going to make a lot of money. Even if we do nothing.
> if you have to appeal to SCOTUS to un-suspend it, it's safe to say that it was suspended
You're using a judiciary striking down an unconstitutional law as an example of martial law? Maybe start with the Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martial_law.
Here's a hint: if you can appeal to any court, you're not under martial law.
Who said no rights were suspended? You're arguing with yourself [1].
The wrong statement made at the head was that we had martial law in the West during Covid. We did not. Not even close. If civilian courts can overrule anything, you're not under martial law.
(Also, every state is constantly passing laws that are struck down, if this is your standard for martial law then everyone is always under martial law and the term is meaningless.)
> Martial law in America would mean suspending the Constitution.
I pointed out that constitutional rights were suspended. Thus, by your logic, martial law was declared.
Then, after making the simple claim above you continually change the goal posts. First, martial law is suspension of the constitution. Then, it's suspension of the constitution and the inability to appeal to courts.
Pick one. If it's simply suspending the constitution... then we saw that. But you've changed the goal posts, not me.
Category error. Breakfast means eating food. That doesn't make every meal breakfast.
> constitutional rights were suspended. Thus, by your logic, martial law was declared.
Suspending the Constitution and having Constitutional rights suspended (or more accurately, violated) are very, very different. America under martial law would not have to respect courts, states, or any legislature. You'd have a commander in chief and his generals and everything else exists at their pleasure.
Note that one could suspend the Constitution without martial law. A Constitutional Convention could suspend the Constitution, for instance.
> you've changed the goal posts, not me.
Read the Wikipedia article. Or just look up the word "martial."
No it's not.
> being under the equivalent of house arrest is not a punishment
Where were you? I was in New York City and travelled to Tennesse and California and London and Frankfurt in 2020. I went running every other day.
Buddy, you've been all over the place from SCOTUS to Cape Byron.
I know plenty of Australians. With the amount of noise you guys were making online you'd think you'd know you had the freedom of speech.
That might be something that happens under martial law but not every occurrence of this is martial law by definition.
> In no world can one argue that being under the equivalent of house arrest is not a punishment.
Watch me do it: Punishment implies intent to make you reconsider your behavior due to perceived misbehavior. If I lock a dog in a kennel to protect him from a larger dog and forget to let him out for 5 hours afterwards, I wasn’t punishing him at any point. Unless the government did the „house arrest“ to make you suffer (instead of preventing spread of disease, for example), it’s not punishment.
making people isolate after international travel during a global pandemic is not "martial law in all but name". this is an absolutely unhinged thing to think. please get some fresh air and get off Youtube and Rumble.
I don't watch youtube and don't know what rumble is. For those of us not terminally online, just witnessing reality is shocking enough.
You're describing a suspension of habeus corpus, not martial law. (And even then, not accurately. Curfews have customarily been enacted for short periods of time without being considered a violation of due process.)
15 days to slow the spread was widely supported.
Then it turned into two years (three years?) and people saw right through it.
You're still debating the merits of the policy. That's orthogonal to whether it was martial law.
The practical and political differences between a state of emergency and martial law is massive. Not to mention, the lockdowns were driven by a global health crisis, not a political struggle. They're not even close to similar.
Is that really as true as it used to be since COVID? A number of governments enacted quite astonishingly repressive measures with remarkably little complaint from the people. Using the army instead of the police to do the enforcement seems like a relatively small step.
It probably wouldn't fly in the same way but if a sufficiently serious threat were to occur again and especially if the people did refuse to comply with lock down instructions then it seems quite plausible that some western governments would resort to force.