Re:South Korean president declares emergency martial law
by echoangle on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:46AM
(#42307392)
> Martial law is the imposition of punishments without due process
That might be something that happens under martial law but not every occurrence of this is martial law by definition.
> In no world can one argue that being under the equivalent of house arrest is not a punishment.
Watch me do it: Punishment implies intent to make you reconsider your behavior due to perceived misbehavior. If I lock a dog in a kennel to protect him from a larger dog and forget to let him out for 5 hours afterwards, I wasn’t punishing him at any point.
Unless the government did the „house arrest“ to make you suffer (instead of preventing spread of disease, for example), it’s not punishment.
That might be something that happens under martial law but not every occurrence of this is martial law by definition.
> In no world can one argue that being under the equivalent of house arrest is not a punishment.
Watch me do it: Punishment implies intent to make you reconsider your behavior due to perceived misbehavior. If I lock a dog in a kennel to protect him from a larger dog and forget to let him out for 5 hours afterwards, I wasn’t punishing him at any point. Unless the government did the „house arrest“ to make you suffer (instead of preventing spread of disease, for example), it’s not punishment.