* End customers are really a customer of Yotta, a (silly IMO) fintech where interest was essentially pooled into a sweepstakes prize.
* Yotta was a customer of Synapse - they used Synapse BaaS APIs to open customer accounts (again, these accounts were really just entries in Synapse's ledger, and they underlying funds were supposed to be stored in an FBO account on Evolve).
* Synapse partnered with Evolve, who is the FDIC insured bank.
Synapse went bankrupt, and Yotta customers are finding out they can't access their money. But the bankruptcy court is at a loss as to really what to do. FDIC isn't getting involved, because as far as they can tell, Evolve hasn't failed. Synapse is basically out of the picture at this point as they are bankrupt and there isn't even enough money left to do a real audit, and Yotta is suing Evolve alleging they lost customer funds. But, in the meantime, Yotta customers are SOL.
If you had a direct relationship with an FDIC-insured bank, and they lost your money, there would be a much clearer path for the FDIC to get involved and make you whole (up to $250k).
There is always residual risk between the bank and you with the fintech company. That’s what got Yotta in trouble ,they basically outsourced the heavy lifting of managing ledgers to synapse which you as customer have no control over.
For most people that risk is not worth losing their already modest savings over , that is why banks are regulated and FDIC exists after all.
The difference between them and some bullshit thing like Yotta is you are the customer of record for the account. The bullshit aspect of Wealthfront is they front real services with automated investment services. Yotta was pooling customer funds at some other bullshit fintech who was then putting those funds (or not) into one big account.
Personally, handling cash is an old business and I’m really conservative about who handles mine. Innovation is risk, especially when the money behind it is focused on eliminating accountability. Yotta should have been illegal. Keep accounting boring.
If your bank and you have a disagreement over how much money should be in your account, then FDIC wouldn't be involved?
But, in all cases, there is a clear process to ensure no money goes missing, either through fraud, mistakes or insolvency. Banks require the blessings of their regulators to operate, so they are highly incentivized to ensure all of their accounting is accurate. With fintechs no such regulatory framework exists (at least not yet).
This case is like FDIC be involved because say Robinhood or stripe or Shopify or any other saas app went bankrupt and their customers are mad they lost money
I’m highly skeptical of this claim. Every bank I’ve worked with adheres to their records requirements like it’s life or death (because it kind of is for the bank).
Tell your friend he’s exposing himself to hard prison time if he’s not just making up a story. If his boss tells him that they don’t have budget to retain the logs he should be whistle blowing, not violating federal banking laws to save what is a rounding error in their IT budget.