News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Palomides on Thursday November 28, 2024 @08:48PM (#42270104)
the majority of the pollution probably comes from semi trucks rather than passenger cars, due to the huge weight and number of wheels
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by snibsnib on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:16PM (#42270221)
Where i live, 80% of all vehicles are passenger vehicles. I'm not sure that the extra wheels on semis would make up for that difference, especially with the slow increase in size of passenger vehicles.
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Retric on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:46PM (#42270349)
Something like 98% of ware from road vehicles is caused by semi’s vs 2% from cars and trucks.

20% * 18 = 3.6 vs 80% * 4 = 3.2, so barring some 3rd category semi’s would have more tires. They also have a lot more weight on each of those tires.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Aurornis on Thursday November 28, 2024 @10:09PM (#42270459)
Road wear is proportional to weight.

Semi tires are hard, long-lasting compounds relative to soft consumer tires with deep treads and soft rubber.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by rootusrootus on Thursday November 28, 2024 @10:19PM (#42270514)
> Road wear is proportional to weight

No, it scales at the fourth power of the axle weight.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Retric on Friday November 29, 2024 @05:07AM (#42272725)
Hard long lasting compounds don’t actually make up for fully loaded semi’s weight. They are much larger tires and with consistent heavy loads may only last 25k miles (or 100k with light loads).

So more and much larger tires and fairly similar lifespan = they liked make up a significant majority of tire pollution.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by emmelaich on Thursday November 28, 2024 @10:01PM (#42270423)
Agree, the damage to the road (and the tyres, presumably) is proportional to weight^4.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law

> The fourth power law (also known as the fourth power rule) states that the stress on the road caused by a motor vehicle increases in proportion to the fourth power of its axle load

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by rapjr9 on Thursday November 28, 2024 @11:17PM (#42270750)
A little off topic, but what are the roads releasing into the environment as they wear down? Asphalt is often somewhat radioactive since it's made from oil? Is there benzene in there? What is the scale of asphalt nanoparticles compared to tire nanoparticles?
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by missinglugnut on Thursday November 28, 2024 @11:04PM (#42270693)
I hate that the 4th power law is called a law. It's not a law of nature, it's a lazy curve fit.

Think about this...if car does 'x' damage to the road, 2 cars does 2x damage. 2 cars welded together side by side (axle to axle so the axle count stays the same) would also do 2x damage, but the 4th power law says it does 16x damage.

If it's wrong by a factor of 8 in the simplest thought experiment it's not a law. You can obviously make a heavy load act like many small ones, or concentrate a light load so it does a lot of damage.

Constant * X^4 just coincidentally went through the data in a single 1950s dataset...and for some reason we're calling it a law 70 years later, when it's really just a loose trend that we could easily break with a little engineering. And we probably have broken it...tires, roads, and vehicles have changed a fair bit in 7 decades.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by vel0city on Thursday November 28, 2024 @11:49PM (#42270909)
If you're welding the two cars together connecting the axles you're still having 8 contact patches instead of 4, so the axle load is the same as 2 separate vehicles they're just moving in tandem.

You'd need to stack the two cars on top of each other to increase the axle load. In which case I'd say it's not obvious how much more the road wear would be without looking at data.

I'm not saying the 4th power law is absolute truth, I truly don't know what the wear patterns would look like on a modern surface. But your example isn't proving it wrong at all.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by icehawk on Thursday November 28, 2024 @11:47PM (#42270896)
> Think about this...if car does 'x' damage to the road, 2 cars does 2x damage. 2 cars welded together side by side (axle to axle so the axle count stays the same) would also do 2x damage, but the 4th power law says it does 16x damage.

Are you removing the two inner wheels from the axle? Those would also support weight

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by hackernewds on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:15PM (#42270213)
there are 200000x the number of private cars. are you sure?
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Spooky23 on Thursday November 28, 2024 @11:58PM (#42270952)
A fully loaded tractor trailer has 5 axles and weighs 80,000 lbs, it does 9000-10000x more damage than a passenger car.

This is why states operate weigh stations — overweight trucks cause significant damage.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Palomides on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:23PM (#42270257)
it's widely accepted that trucks cause the majority of road wear, considering the tire is the softer part in contact there, it seems pretty plausible

I don't have a citation to point to, though!

edit: there are roughly 100x registered passenger cars in the US as semis

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by SideQuark on Thursday November 28, 2024 @10:05PM (#42270436)
Well, given a semi only averages 8x the miles of a car per year, your initial claim is wrong.

https://afdc.energy.gov/data/10309

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by vigna on Friday November 29, 2024 @05:44AM (#42272892)
Hi SideQuark. I'm writing you here as there's no contact email on your profile--I wanted to ask you if you ever tried a SAT solver on RomuTrio to find cycles (or you can give me some hints). I'm referring to this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22457101.

You can write me at [email protected]. Thanks for any info!

BTW, thanks for explaining that you cannot prove things about a single permutation using random permutations--it's so obvious that it is very difficult to explain, and the same absurd argument pops over and over.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by Aurornis on Thursday November 28, 2024 @10:10PM (#42270465)
Road wear depends on weight.

Semi truck tires have hard, slow-wearing compounds.

Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by qwerty_clicks on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:22PM (#42270252)
Semi’s drive 12+ hours a day most days of the year. Passenger cars just go to work and they store and back.
Re:Car tires shed a quarter of all microplastics in the envi... by bsder on Thursday November 28, 2024 @09:40PM (#42270324)
Your estimate isn't even close--you're off by about 4 orders of magnitude.

Fact: In California, the number of trucks is about 300K vs cars at 14M (about 40x).

Fact: California AADT on roads for trucks ranges from a couple of percent up to almost 50%. Very few roads have less than 10% AADT from trucks.

Fact: Damage to roads goes as fourth power of axle load.

Speculation: Given that tires are the primary means to transmit that damage to the roadway, it wouldn't surprise me if the trucks are responsible for the vast majority of tire particulates.

Reference: https://dot.ca.gov/-/media/dot-media/programs/traffic-operat...