News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by loandbehold on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:08PM (#42186987)
Russia is responsible but not alone. This war could have been prevented by not pushing Ukraine into NATO. It's THE reason for the war.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by holowoodman on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:31PM (#42187202)
Quite the opposite. Ukraine has been prevented from joining NATO by the west, especially Germany and France, for fear of angering Russia. This course of action has led to war. The proper course of action in hindsight would have been to have Ukraine join NATO asap back then.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by spookie on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @02:12AM (#42191453)
Same for Georgia. But here we are.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fsloth on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:50PM (#42187376)
That’s bullshit. I’m sorry, but I’m tired of apologists falling to Russian state lies. Falling over to Russian lies is not independent thinking.

The first rule of kremnology is that Russia always lies without a shame, as lies are usefull and they incur zero cost on the liar.

Russia invaded because they felt Ukraine was showing a bad example of slavic people becoming a democracy.

Also Russia has always had an affinity towards Ukrainian genocide. See Holodomor.

Also there is the narrative of lost colonial honor, Crimea, Catherine the great, and other idiotic pseudo-historical ramblings of a demented autocratic propagnada.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Terr_ on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:15PM (#42188686)
> Also there is the narrative of lost colonial honor,

Useful word: Revanchism [0], for people who want to conquer places they claim they once-owned.

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/revanchist

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by selimthegrim on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @09:43AM (#42194297)
Also irredentism.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by techbrovanguard on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:00PM (#42189788)
> The first rule of kremnology is that Russia always lies without a shame, as lies are usefull and they incur zero cost on the liar.

you’re describing international relations, none of this is specific to russia. people are indoctrinated from birth into nationalist propaganda. when these mouthpieces speak they aren’t lying, but it’s not the truth.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by watwut on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @04:36AM (#42192213)
The amount of lying coming from Russia is the next level tho.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fsloth on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @06:21AM (#42192834)
No, the use of lying in Russian dialogue is quite next level. It’s way beyond what is expected in western international policy.

It’s the ”i know they are lying, they know i know, and yet they lie”. One of the points is not to convince but to confuse.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fatbird on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:18PM (#42187648)
Ukraine wasn't a candidate for NATO membership in 2014 or 2022, and this was agreed to in all major treaties/agreements with Russia. It's still not a candidate, and can't be while it's actively engaged in war.

NATO membership has never had anything to do with it. Note how Finland has joined NATO since 2022, and faces no repercussions from Russia, despite a third of their land-based nuclear missiles within 400 km of the Finnish border.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by loandbehold on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:46PM (#42189314)
ChatGPT disagrees with you:

Was Ukraine candidate for NATO?

Yes, Ukraine has been a candidate for NATO membership. In 2008, during the Bucharest Summit, NATO members agreed that Ukraine would eventually become a member of the alliance. However, no formal invitation was extended at that time. COMMONS LIBRARY

In 2010, under President Viktor Yanukovych, Ukraine adopted a non-aligned status, halting its pursuit of NATO membership. This policy shifted after the 2014 annexation of Crimea by Russia, leading Ukraine to renew its aspirations for NATO integration. In 2019, Ukraine amended its constitution to enshrine the goal of joining NATO. NATO

In September 2022, following Russia's annexation of parts of southeastern Ukraine, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy announced that Ukraine had applied for NATO membership under an accelerated procedure. WIKIPEDIA As of November 2024, Ukraine remains a NATO partner country and has not yet achieved full membership.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fatbird on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:37PM (#42189646)
Nothing ChatGPT said disagrees what I wrote.

Between 2010 and later 2022 (i.e., not in 2014 or in February 2022) Ukraine was officially not pursuing membership, and France, Germany and the US were all unofficially making it clear that NATO membership was not being pursued and would not be offered.

Ukraine applied for NATO membership after Russia's invasion. It cannot therefore be a cause of Russia's invasion. At the time Russia sponsored and supported internal revolt in Crimea and Donbass, it was 2014 and Ukraine was officially and unofficially not in or applying to NATO--so how can that be the cause of Russian intervention then?

Thank you, though, for using ChatGPT to support my contention that NATO membership had nothing to do with Russia's invasion.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fatbird on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:48PM (#42189707)
Also, to clarify one point: No one is a candidate for NATO who is currently engaged in hostilities. While Ukraine was in a state of war against Russian supported forces in Donbass and Crimea, it was ineligible to even apply. It may have put the goal of joining NATO in its constitution, but it was a non-starter until that conflict was resolved.

BTW, Russia has shared borders with multiple NATO countries, starting with Norway in 1949 when NATO was founded, and the Baltics since 2004. A neighbouring country's membership in an alliance is not a casus belli.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by trmaker103 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:11PM (#42190757)
It wasn't about an official candidacy, it was about formalizing neutrality:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2021_Russian_ultimatu...

Inofficially, of course the U.S. wanted Ukraine in NATO and the EU all the time. Merkel opposed NATO membership at some point, but Germany is just a vassal state.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @12:04AM (#42190968)
Ukraine has as much right to a neutral russia, as russia has to a neutral Ukraine. What has russia done to deserve more?

Indeed, russia started this war by refusing to be neutral. Thus, Ukraine will perhaps show neutrality if russia shows neutrality first.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by fatbird on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:57PM (#42190934)
Did you read your own link?

Although Russia has obstinately described NATO expansion as a threat, Putin was actually more concerned about the loss of Russia’s perceived sphere of influence in former Soviet republics which were aligning themselves with the West economically and politically

So it wasn’t about NATO, it was about maintained a decaying sphere of influence.

Boris Bondarev, a Russian diplomat who later resigned in protest of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, recalled that the draft treaties had shocked many Russian diplomats and that he immediately viewed the demands as non-negotiable.

Even the Russian diplomats knew it was posturing while Russia added to the 100,000 troops already staging on the border with Ukraine. Demands made at the point of 100,000 guns pointed at you are not good faith negotiating positions.

What right does Russia have to formalized neutrality, to control Ukraine’s foreign policy? Do you think that, since “Germany is just a vassal state” that Russia deserves one too?

[ETA: formatting]

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Terr_ on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:29PM (#42187167)
Compare: "The serial-killer is responsible but not alone, this second stabbing could have been prevented by not trying to protect yourself from being stabbed again by the same serial-killer!"

That may be true in the most narrow and mechanical sense, but the way it presents blame is very wrong.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by threeseed on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:53PM (#42187404)
So then the resolution to this war is simple:

Russia returns Crimea, Donbass etc and Ukraine promises not to join NATO.

Strange that Putin hasn't proposed such a deal.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by eptcyka on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:43PM (#42187884)
Not joining NATO is just a way of deferring the genocide. A regional power has no chance to stand against a global superpower on its own. If not NATO, then a different coalition.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dralley on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:49PM (#42187937)
I understand what you mean but Russia is not a global superpower. They are not the USSR. Acting and speaking as though they are is part of how we got into this mess, the US and Europe didn't show any real backbone during the decade following the initial 2014 invasion, or during the Syrian crisis before that, or the 2008 invasion of Georgia before that.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by eptcyka on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:35PM (#42188347)
Fair, but even if they are not a global superpower, they are a tier above most of their bordering countries. 2014 was a direct result of Germany being dependent on Russian gas.

I wouldn’t argue that EU and the US did not screw up in 20{08,14} though. We did. Massively. We did underestimate Putins long game - had we known how far he wants to go, and I’d argue most post soviet countries knew, this would’ve been nipped in the bud.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by InDubioProRubio on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @08:35AM (#42193815)
Saudi Arabia with snow instead of sand
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Terr_ on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:18PM (#42188709)
> They are not the USSR.

One strand of BS I've seen is "Ukraine now is a different country than the one we promised never to invade."

If that's really how it works, Russia should be ejected from the United Nations and apologize for fraudulently casting votes in the UN Security Council, because it's a different country than the USSR.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @07:38AM (#42193402)
Acting and speaking as though they are is part of how we got into this mess,

Actually it was Putin's acting and speaking as if he could partially restore the glory of the former Soviet empire (whose collapse he called "the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the century") that got Russia into its current mess in Ukraine.

He does, in any case, consider the current Russian Federation and the Soviet Union to be continuations of "historic Russia". So it's not Western rhetoric. And it isn't the West that is making him invade Ukraine and menace other countries.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dralley on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @05:08PM (#42198615)
I think you misunderstood what I was saying. Of course Putin is an imperialist. But for two decades his grievances were treated as though they had legitimacy, or as though Russia should be given the same level deference and appeasement that the USSR was. Even holding Putin's opinions constant, the US and Europe should have pushed back harder against the aggression rather than pretending it wasn't happening.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @06:49PM (#42199416)
Indeed I did. I thought the referent of "as though they [were]" was "the USSR", rather than "a global superpower".

The second possibility makes much more sense (and is more informative), so I should have assumed that one instead.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by hughesjj on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:05PM (#42188605)
You could always just bootstrap a nuclear program in Ukraine instead.

They gave up their nukes in exchange for protection from Russia and the US. Both countries have failed to keep up their end of the bargain, so it's sensible for Ukraine to get back what they gave up.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by endofreach on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:12PM (#42189069)
Great idea. Uncontrollable wars? Rising extremism all over the world? New generation of politicians who never experienced real diplomacy? Moralism, division, hatred... of course... the only things to save us all: the nukes. Let's just get it over with!
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by InDubioProRubio on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @08:37AM (#42193821)
Gruncle Vlad is that you?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by threeseed on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:34PM (#42190613)
Ukraine had already hinted that this is in the future.

And I wouldn't blame them.

The West promised to protect them and failed.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Terr_ on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @03:56AM (#42191986)
A somewhat more-amusing proposal I've seen: Ukraine declares "war" against a NATO nation (e.g. Poland) and then immediately surrenders. Then it starts negotiations to secede while keeping NATO membership without a gap.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by hackandthink on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @02:02AM (#42191418)
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by InDubioProRubio on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @08:37AM (#42193823)
Another asset
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dralley on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @12:40PM (#42196353)
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by hackandthink on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @06:29PM (#42199251)
"Shut Up About NATO Expansion" is a fun video, well made.

But Mearsheimer's arguments are convincing.

We may find it ridiculous to be afraid of NATO or the USA. Others do not.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @07:52PM (#42199893)
But Mearsheimer's arguments are convincing.

They're not and are in fact easily debunked.

See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42197501

We may find it ridiculous to be afraid of NATO or the USA

Russia isn't "afraid" of either -- it just considers them to be annoyances.

Its regime pretends be "afraid" of both, for the benefit of its internal and external propaganda, and of course to entice its people to sign up for the meat grinder. But that's just its delusion, which we are under no obligation to honor or validate.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dralley on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @06:48PM (#42199411)
It's not convincing. It's a man wrapped up in defending a worldview he's held for 5 decades against real world experiences that directly contradict it.

Putin's actions do not line up with this portrait of him as a hyper-rational long-term strategist acting on the interests of the Russian state. They line up very well with what you would expect from an aging, deeply conspiratorial cold warrior with widely publicized nationalist beliefs [0], a desire to have a legacy that compares against the likes of Peter the Great [1], and the type of delusional thinking that is the near-inevitable result of not having anyone that is willing (due to brownnosing) or able (due to corruption) to tell you hard truths [2].

Even when someone like Tucker Carlson sits down with Putin and practically tees him up to blame the war on US, he goes on ridiculous historical tangents to try to justify why Ukraine isn't real, as opposed to saying anything related to NATO. And that's not a fluke. Russian internal narratives are vastly more focused on nationalism than on anything resembling "NATO made us do this".

You also just have to look at the assassinations carried out on NATO soil - including using chemical and radiological weapons - blowing up Czech ammunition depots, etc. Years and years of unilateral kinetic escalation directly against the west. And then no response whatsoever when Finland and Sweden joined NATO.

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/21/world/europe/putin-ukrain...

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/10/putin-compares...

[2] There's far too many instances of this to even count.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by inopinatus on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @05:05PM (#42198591)
Mearsheimer is entirely captured by Putin’s “Valdai Club” propaganda unit.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valdai_Discussion_Club

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @07:32PM (#42199739)
Captured, no. Never estimate the human potential for naivete self-deception.

What we do know is that they've been in contact, and that he is sincerely grateful to them:

   In John Mearsheimer's 2023 book "How States Think", the foreword acknowledges him receiving a small financial support from Valdai in conjunction with Best Book award for his 2019 book "The Great Delusion".
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by watwut on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @04:34AM (#42192208)
No, Ukraine in NATO would prevent the war. The war happened, because Russia wants territory.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @05:13PM (#42198658)
> Russia is responsible but not alone. This war could have been prevented by not pushing Ukraine into NATO

The war is what caused Ukraine to restart its previously-repudiated attempts to join NATO, so this isn’t just wrong but entirely backwards.