News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by rockyj on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:32AM (#42181169)
I am an Indian living in Berlin. I always am surprised at the price differences between the countries. A new small SUV in India (e.g. Citroen Basalt) with all bells and whistles is less than 10k Euros (https://www.carwale.com/citroen-cars/basalt/) and here in Germany I cannot get a decent second hand car for less than 20K.

On the other hand, in India any car is probably unusable after 10-15 years, and here in Germany people buy a car for life.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by theshrike79 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:02AM (#42181333)
It's because we don't want to end up like this: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/mumbais-air-qualit...

Most of the extra price goes into emissions reduction.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by tock on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:26AM (#42181491)
India's AQI issues mostly stem from crop burning. AFAIK cars have to comply with BS6 which is pretty similar to Euro 6.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by jklowden on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:20AM (#42181871)
Funny thing: during the pandemic, when no one was driving, New Delhi’s air cleared so much that the Himalayas could be seen for the first time in decades.

If pollution is caused by "crop burning", why is it that the worst pollution is in cities?

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by sangeeth96 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:31AM (#42181938)
There are more factors than people not driving during those times:

> The phenomenon is made possible by a dramatic improvement in air quality in recent weeks, after industries shut down, cars came off the road and airlines canceled flights in response to the coronavirus pandemic.

> Delhi saw up to a 44% reduction in PM10 air pollution levels on the first day of its restrictions, India’s Central Pollution Control Board found. The PM10 standard measures airborne particulates 10 micrometers or smaller in diameter.

https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/himalayas-visible-loc...

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by plastic_bag on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:49AM (#42182048)
> If pollution is caused by "crop burning", why is it that the worst pollution is in cities?

The worst pollution is not in any cities. It's a problem specific to North Indian cities and regions in Pakistan.

No city in South India is even remotely as polluted as the NCR.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by f1shy on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:00AM (#42181736)
I've no idea, but I think they will also cut some corners in safety, like 2 instead of 6 to 8 airbags, ABS, ESP, etc.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by piyushpr134 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:12AM (#42181821)
Nopes. Bharat stage 6 and eu6 norms are exactly same. https://gomechanic.in/blog/bs6-vs-euro6-what-is-the-differen...

Moreover, we are really really mileage conscious so our cars are very fuel efficient, leading to lower emissions.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by publicola1990 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:09AM (#42181373)
And it could even cheaper since like about 40% of price of many cars in India is reportedly taxes and duties.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by devsda on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:48AM (#42182042)
Its actually sometimes more than 40% and that's not even for luxury cars.

Here's[1] an example for a car costing a million INR, taxes are more than 300K. That's not the final landing price. Final price adds up extra road tax component that is anywhere from 13 to 17%(or even more) which is calculated on top of the 1 Million.

In case you missed it, that's tax on tax i.e. double taxation! Some courts have ruled it illegal but majority of state governments act ignorant and just continue the practice.

1. https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/235811-query...

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by rusticpenn on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:40AM (#42181222)
The roads, weather, driving habits etc in India play a role.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by ricardobayes on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:39AM (#42181210)
The Dacia Sandero starts at around 13k in Europe and by all means a pretty good car. I have a friend who bought one new and told me it has been very reliable.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by WeaselNo7 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:45AM (#42181252)
The Dacia Sandero unfortunately gets a 2 star Euro NCAP rating (which is typical for Dacia cars). Not something I personally would feel safe putting my family into!
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by Radim on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:52AM (#42182075)
> Not something I personally would feel safe putting my family into!

From https://www.topgear.com/long-term-car-reviews/dacia/jogger/r...

> The Jogger returned the equivalent of a four-star rating for adult occupant crash protection, and three stars for child occupants. Plenty respectable scores. The Jogger lost marks, however, for its lack of active safety equipment: it doesn’t offer lane-keep assist, pedestrian detection, or seatbelt warnings for the rearmost row. [0]

> The overall NCAP rating is dictated by the lowest score in any individual category, hence that headline one-star result for the Jogger.

Many people actively disable gimmicks like "lane-keep assist", so YMMV on such damning "1 star Euro NCAP rating".

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by 627467 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:40AM (#42181215)
With all the "green" restrictions in place in many european cities - forbidding cars as recent as 2005 to enter them - cars are only for life if you live in the middle of nowhere or have a short life
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by OtherShrezzing on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:10AM (#42181382)
You can usually retrofit a pre-2005 vehicle for a thousand or so euros. Approx the cost of the annual maintenance on a vehicle of that age, and certainly far less than the cost of a new or used car (either financial cost or embodied emissions cost).
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by mdp2021 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:31AM (#42181936)
> You can usually retrofit a pre-2005 vehicle for a thousand or so euros

Not in every Country.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by pjc50 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:28AM (#42182295)
That was nearly twenty years ago, a very high lifetime for a car.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by acchow on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:03AM (#42181340)
> and here in Germany people buy a car for life

The average age of a car in Germany is 10 years so I guess this was sarcasm?

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by rockyj on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:21AM (#42181449)
No sarcasm. In India cars are pretty much unusable after 15 years due to wear and tear, not to mention laws like - https://www.hizuno.com/blog/motor/15-years-old-car-rules-in-... (tldr: cars older than 15 years have to be dumped)

In Germany, people may upgrade from their own will, but even from my window I can see a dozens cars parked which are more than 10 years old. Not to mention a new Merc or VW can probably be stil working well in 20 years (for example see autoscout24 for Mercs from 2014 still selling for 15K).

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by rajaravivarma_r on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:48AM (#42182410)
I have rarely seen a car becoming unusable after 15 years. I have seen taxis with more than 400,000 KM on the odo. Not that they never had issues, but they are pretty much usable if you replace parts.

The 15 year car rule is only applicable for New Delhi NCR Region. You still need to obtain fitness certificate for vehicles every 5 years after the 15th year, but they need not be dumped as long as it passes the evaluation.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by teractiveodular on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:17AM (#42182232)
How does that square with Ambassador taxis still being a thing in some cities? Do they just look ancient?
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by fwip on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:34AM (#42181544)
Sure, but "for life" could reasonably be expected to cover 50 or 60 years, if you buy your first car as a young adult.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by lnsru on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:22AM (#42181458)
People used to buy a car for life. These cars from the past were built differently and made a good name for German cars. Golf 4 is a legend. Now it’s crap made for 150000 miles and then time to buy a new one. All brands the same! Source: buddy from Bosch from ECU department sharing the requirements for modern car. And recent sad personal experience.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by f1shy on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:59AM (#42181729)
The requirements from all auto makers, not only for ECU, but every single part is 10 Years/ 100k km for low end, 15 Years 150k km for high end. I think that is no secret. And that is 100% the experience if you buy a car, there is a point where the maintenance per year is more than the value of the car itself. At that point the car is effectively 0 EUR value.

I hear in USA the Toyotas hold much longer... I'm not sure why, if it is true, and what are the conditions.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by itsoktocry on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:41AM (#42182371)
>but every single part is 10 Years/ 100k km for low end, 15 Years 150k km for high end

Every car I've owned has gone well over 150,000 km without anything but regular maintenance. It's really hard to kill a modern engine.

Yes, things wear out and need to be replaced.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by bobim on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:21AM (#42182258)
The maintenance must be seen as per the service value, not the car value. If it's in good condition then maintain it and drive until pistons goes through the head. Keep this gray energy off the scrapeyard.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by wil421 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:35AM (#42182333)
I’ve take a mid 2000s Corolla and a 4Runner to 250k. The Corolla was still running with a slight radiator leak. The 4Runner had a transmission banging noise I didn’t want to fix.

No salt on my roads and little to no rust on either.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by itsoktocry on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:39AM (#42182359)
>People used to buy a car for life.

When? The 1940s?

We know this isn't true, based on the existence of older cars, today.

I'd put money on a barebones car of today outlasting nearly anything of the past.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by taneq on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:19AM (#42183103)
Agreed. When I was a kid (80s/90s), a 15-year-old car was barely worth keeping running and a 20-year-old car was a rusted-out piece of junk. Today a 15-year-old car can be quite nice and there are plenty of unremarkable 20-year-old cars still getting around just fine.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by johnisgood on Thursday November 28, 2024 @05:29PM (#42268998)
Could it be because "modern cars" are worse in some ways?
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by adrian_b on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:24AM (#42182669)
My father has used a car bought in 1973 for about 35 years, most of which it has been used daily for going to his office, while in vacations it has also been used on many mountain roads of very bad quality.

When he has stopped using the car, that has been more because the driver was worn off, not the car.

Obviously, during all those years the car has been repaired many times, but in almost all cases by himself and only a few times at a car workshop.

Similar lifetimes have been typical for many other things bought during the seventies, like washing machines, TV sets and other such household appliances.

The products designed for short lifetimes have become widespread mostly after 1990 and especially after 2000.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by technothrasher on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:44AM (#42182811)
I can't speak for Germany, but in the US the average age of personal vehicles has been consistently increasing from 5.6 years in 1977 to 12.6 years in 2024.

(Data from Summary of Travel Trends: 1995 Nationwide Personal Transportation Survey, and 2024 IHS Markit Co., Average Age of Light Cars and Trucks in U.S)

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by vanviegen on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:52AM (#42182876)
If over the course of a hundred years, you gradually replace all of the wood that makes up a ship at least once, is it still the same ship?

That was easier to do with 70s cars than with modern cars of course.

I agree that consumer products in most categories have become throwaway crap in recent decades. But quite a few cars, at least in my experience, are still built to last.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by f1shy on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:56AM (#42181711)
>and here in Germany people buy a car for life.

In which Germany are you living? People change car pretty regularly, especially because of the maintenance cost for passing the TÜV. All small cars sold have distribution belt soaked in oil, so you have to change before 10 years, and by that time the cost of changing the belt is more than the car value.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by hengheng on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:09AM (#42182563)
The median car in Germany is 12 years old or so, almost the same as in similar countries. That's a result of cars simply lasting longer than they used to.

First owner is usually a lease customer (company car), second owner will keep it for much longer, third or fourth owner will run the car into the ground, and it'll almost always be crushed in Eastern Europe. Guessing grandparent is seeing a lot of second and third owner cars.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by wil421 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:33AM (#42182318)
For anyone wondering, a distribution belt is the timing chair (or timing belt in this example). GM has a Duramax 3.0 diesel engine with a timing belt instead of a chain and it’s on the back. People were so angry GM put out a warranty for 5 year 100k miles.

I’ve seen tear downs on YouTube and the Duramax people are livid about a belt.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by technothrasher on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:33AM (#42182730)
I think we're getting a little confused here. The Duramax 3.0 diesel has a timing chain, not a belt. The belt people usually bitch about is the oil pump belt.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by dchest on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:21AM (#42185154)
I think the comment referred to wet timing belt https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SASSFjIt5I
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by ponector on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:15AM (#42181845)
With all bells and whistles Citroen Basalt is 15k euro, which is still cheap. But for 15k euro you can get a new Citroen C3 in Germany as well, but with basic configuration.

>>in Germany I cannot get a decent second hand car for less than 20K.

You cannot compare Indian Citroen with German Mercedes.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by Intermernet on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:10AM (#42182187)
Mercedes have a pretty terrible reputation these days. A mechanic friend of mine rates them as one of the most unreliable new cars you can buy.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by adrianN on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:52AM (#42182068)
The average age of cars on the road in Germany is almost certainly lower than 15 years. I believe I remember it was something like eight years.
Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by neoromantique on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:32AM (#42182313)
>here in Germany I cannot get a decent second hand car for less than 20K.

Then you're doing something very wrong. There are literally thousands of cars for sale that are reliable and well maintained for half that.

Hell, these days even a sub 1K eur can get you by in a pinch, if you choose carefully enough.

Re:$8k Suzuki from India Received a 5-Star Crash Test Rating by Hendrikto on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @05:50AM (#42192673)
> here in Germany I cannot get a decent second hand car for less than 20K.

What are you talking about?

I bought my used Opel Corsa with 50k km for 2200€. Driven it for 60k km since, without problem. So it was definitely “decent”.