Children with autism or ADHD might struggle in some ways, but be better off in others.
It seems clear that there is no objective reason they are worse than a neurotypical
person, so if a "cure" to these conditions was developed, you would have some degree of
moral quandary.
Careful, you are most likely talking about someone spending their energy at masking their handicaps. *You only see the handicap you can see*.Someone with high intelligence but severely damaged executive functioning might look like the under performer in your team, but is giving all they have to work and still failing in silence, with their personal life being a giant mess.
Prune it down and it is simply "You can fix something by developing a fix, and if you can't do that you can fix something by redefining what "fixed" means".
I personally think it's excessively reductive, but there are those that say, for example, that you become more attuned to your other senses when you lose your hearing, or even that area of the brain can be repurposed for other tasks. They may say, therefore, that the only reason being deaf is a disability is because the world is designed for non-deaf people. In the same way that you wouldn't consider yourself disabled for being unable to see x-rays or detect magnetic fields.
My father has hearing aids and has had them since he was probably in his mid 60s, I'm just pushing 50....
...but to my point, Apple recently released their 'kinda hearing aid' tech (from what I can tell just a custom EQ and passthrough for the mics in the airpods).. and man it's fucking great. I'm probably not ready yet for 'real hearing aids' and they are so fucking expensive to boot.. but having this 'half measure' has been really useful for me.
> While hearing aids are relatively speaking uncontroversial, the internal portion of a cochlear implant requires surgery, which of course entails risk
I don't know the scope of that risk. Might be fine, but the point is you have to actually find out what it is before doing it.
My cousin with it needs to live in a group home. He’s barely verbal.
This isn't an argument for or against the comment or the OP, but this is not universally seen as objective, and there are more ways to think about this than the medical model where there are "normal" people and that disabilities are deviations from what is "normal". Many disabled people and experts on disability see it as socially constructed, because certain conditions (e.g. being shorter than average), while limiting your physical abilities, are not disabilities because society generally provides for those conditions and extends equal access. If 50% of people were born Deaf, our society would still function, but it would address Deafness with affordances like the ones currently offered to short people.
To put it another way, despite e.g. being gay or short posing various social or physical disadvantages, we shy away from encouraging conversion therapy or height extension surgery by default, instead opting for a more inclusive society. And human beings are complex — a person who has found culture and meaning as a member of the Deaf community may disagree with you that they are "objectively worse off" for not having hearing, despite the obstacles.
This article I think does a good job of explaining the quandary of a parent faced with a "fix" for a condition that is challenging but through which people have developed identity and culture. I am lucky to not currently have to take a stand on the right choice here, but I think the complexity of the issue deserves more respect than to be dismissed out of hand.
Because these things are dangerous and ineffective. You can point to clear negative consequences that come from doing them at a mass scale. Again, I go back to the idea of "different, not worse". Being gay is not the absence of straightness, and being short is not the absence of tallness. But being deaf is the absence of hearing. You just get less.
> This article I think does a good job of explaining the quandary of a parent faced with a "fix" for a condition that is challenging but through which people have developed identity and culture
You could say the same of cancer, but a fix would be very appreciated. Anything that makes people's lives worse will create a community, but I don't think this is an argument against resolving that problem. What's contradictory about this is that these people saying the solution is bad also demand their problem be fixed. They just say that the fix should be implemented at a global scale. Instead of a simple implant that restores hearing, they want the entire world to be made accessible to people without hearing. If this was fully achieved, it would have the same effect as restoring their hearing. There would be no struggle, there would be no community. Being deaf would be just as unusual as being short. Yet I've never heard opposition to making things more accommodating to deaf people. Essentially, their issue isn't with the problem being solved, but that this solution to the problem is too effective.
> Many disabled people and experts on disability see it as socially constructed
They are wrong. Even without society, the disability would exist. The only social construct is the threshold for how badly something needs to affect you before it is considered a disability. While it's true that we can, through science, reduce the degree to which a disability affects a person to the point it falls below that threshold, this is just curing disability. The fact that a disease can be cured doesn't make it a social construct. The only real point to be had here is that the word "disabled" is a social construct, but this is a meaningless statement. All words are social constructs. That's just how words work.
The impairment doesn't go away, but the extent to which is it disabling is a function of the individual's relationship to society. Two people with the same impairment can have different degrees of disability based on accommodation. We can both have bad vision but if I can afford glasses and you can't, only one of us is disabled by it.
This is the social model of disability, it's a well established framework that has had immense practical value in the medical treatment of a huge range of disability, including adhd and hearing loss. It's so so shitty to dismiss it as "they are wrong" when you clearly don't even know the absolute basics of the history and practice of this field.
No it's not. It's a function of the person's relationship to glasses. The same way deaf people are no longer disabled when you restore their hearing. The only difference is that we can all obviously see that depriving children of glasses for the sake of forming a "blind community" is an utterly ridiculous thing to do.
What I'm saying is that there are two different cures for deafness. The first is to engineer a world in which it is not necessary to hear, and the second is to restore the individual's hearing. I am of the belief that there is no substantive difference between these two methods as it relates to the argument being made against cochlear implants. Of the two different cures, that is more effective which is the soul issue people take with it.
> This is the social model of disability, it's a well established framework that has had immense practical value in the medical treatment of a huge range of disability, including adhd and hearing loss.
The conclusion they reach is that a disability can be treated by altering the environment of the person with it. I reach this same conclusion without the need to reference some abstract "society" which causes all these problems.
> It's so so shitty to dismiss it as "they are wrong" when you clearly don't even know the absolute basics of the history and practice of this field.
Well they are wrong. If you find the truth to be shitty, I suggest you bury your head in the sand.
This doesn't make them not disabilities, it just makes them disabilities with societal affordances. Even if we accept what you're saying here, these people are still less able to do things in the world, because much of the world doesn't provide those affordance, so they're restricted to the places that do.
Even in those places, there are still limits to the affordances provided - even people have the idea that in the US, employers can't discriminate against disabled people, they absolutely can if the disability affects their ability to do the job. Warehouse jobs routinely discriminate against those who can't lift 50 pounds as a matter of policy.
> And human beings are complex — a person who has found culture and meaning as a member of the Deaf community may disagree with you that they are "objectively worse off" for not having hearing, despite the obstacles.
I hear the argument, and I don't necessarily disagree that people find meaning from these kinds of communities. Nonetheless, there's a difference in that a hearing person is still able to find community (though obviously not the exact same community) but can also hear, while a deaf person can only do one of those two things.
When I was a kid in school, the phrase "differently abled" was in vogue, and it always seemed sort of ridiculous. It's not like you get other abilities for being deaf or having a missing leg or being paralyzed - you just have fewer. The only example I can think of where the phrase is really appropriate is for people with autism, who often are better than non-autistic people at some tasks as a result of their autism.
Being able to hear is basically a superpower if you are deaf.
That's not even close to the argument being presented.
The fundamental crisis within the deaf community is around the fact that deaf people share a common language. This is very different than most other disabled communities. Language is fundamental to shared culture.
To be clear, I'm not saying that deaf children should not be given cochlear implants, but the issue is much more complex than "being deaf is the same as being able to hear." It's that deaf people historically felt a sense of shared community and culture. The ability to "fix" (a term many of them would not agree with) deaf people leads to a challenging position where a culture is slowly being destroyed.
It's much closer to the choice white American parents who adopt Asian children have around what culture should those children be exposed to and how much. Is it okay to raise an adopted Chinese child exactly the same a white American child? Should the adopting family try to learn Mandarin? Teach the child them about Lunar New Year? Make friends with other Chinese families in the community? There's no absolutely correct answer for any of these questions, but they are issues families in these situations must navigate.
I suspect your immediate response is that being Asian isn't a disability, but I would point out the first point in my comment: deafness, unlike other disabilities, does have it's own distinct culture because of shared language (not shared disability).
This is problematic. Who, but the members of a living culture, can determine any of these questions? My understanding is that most cultures are self-preserving, until they aren't, usually through conquest or other external forms of eradication.
I don't see the problematic aspect of "curing" the child's deafness before they become a member of the Deaf community. It's not removing someone from the Deaf community. Deontologically, it ought to be fine, surely? (I'm looking at this deontologically, because from a utilitarian perspective, we should be asking what is the correct percentage of otherwise non-deaf children we should surgically make Deaf.)
Because you do have such a threshold, and you consider things that fall below that threshold not to be "culture", and therefore not to be worth preserving.
Which leads to: How do you justify this choice of threshold?
Nihilism is perfectly fine as a philosophical argument, but few would support it in practice
I agree that your reductio ad absurdum argument shows that "nothing deserves to continue" is in untenable position. But surely the opposite extreme (namely, "everything deserves to continue") is just as absurd?
So the question remains: Where to draw the line?
(Although, given the child will continue to need a cochlear implant or similar device, they'll still be disabled either way, and nothing is stopping them from learning sign language too.)
Yeah, it is a different language and culture as a result. Not any worse or better, just different.
You have to be a lot more expressive in ASL to get the points across and just more active in general. Also more patient as it takes longer to communicate, but maybe that an 'us' thing.
We like it a lot, and it's a lot of fun really. We;re thinking of tutoring in ASL for the fam, but like, we don;t have the time to even cook dinner, haha.
I'd say give it a try with your kids.
We already use sign language, we already use our entire body to communicate, infact 55%, more than we do speaking and listening.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigma:_Notes_on_the_Managemen...
It shows quite well the tension between normality and the need for a community IIRC
There are plenty of things where this "different, not worse" narrative holds up. Children with autism or ADHD might struggle in some ways, but be better off in others. It seems clear that there is no objective reason they are worse than a neurotypical person, so if a "cure" to these conditions was developed, you would have some degree of moral quandary. But someone without hearing is just objectively worse off than someone with it, the same way someone without legs is worse off than someone with legs.
The last part is what really gets me about this. The child values the hearing aid so highly that they literally hug it as they go to sleep, and this is somehow presented as a "both sides are right" outcome. To me at least, that's a pretty conclusive endorsement that kids should be given these things.