Coal kills consistently, and mostly where it is used and mined. If you profit from cheap coal energy, you have a higher risk of pulmonary disease. If better filters are installed, your risk is reduced, incentivizing you to trade off risk and reward. If a country builds unmanagebly big hydro dams, a disaster will also affect mostly its own population.
With nuclear energy you have a few catastrophic incidents that render entire areas uninhabitable but also contaminate countries that don't even benefit from it (e.g. Austria got fallout from Chernobyl, having no nuclear power itself). At the same time, by pure luck, many reactors identical to Chernobyl did not blow up and provided the surrounding areas with ridiculously cheap energy.
This is a Black Swan type of risk that completely disconnects risk taking and reward. Even if you are very neglegient, the risk is still very low, allowing you to reap massive benefits. Even worse, countries that don't benefit but may be affected by a disaster may pay you for upgrading your security measures (this has happened in the EU).
I'd rather have technology that is more dangerous but where risk actualization mostly and consistently affects those who are rewarded if everything works out well.
[2] http://nextbigfuture.com/2008/03/deaths-per-twh-for-all-ener... [3] http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Magazines/Bulletin/Bull411/... [4] http://allthingsnuclear.org/post/4704112149/how-many-cancers...
Chernobyl is still the worst nuclear disaster.
Turning to nuclear power means that we will have more waste to deal with - and more risks for the future of human-kind. I have no idea what society will look like in just 200 years, but it feels dangerous to be storing up these issues for them to deal with. (I have the same concerns about rampant fossil fuel use).
Yes in the short term nuclear power can also have a 'boogie man' affect, but that shouldn't take away from the concerns that many, who are wary of nuclear power, have for the future.
There are two types of radioactive material: A, stuff that radiates very little but lasts very long. And B, stuff that radiates very much, but lasts only some months.
If you are concerned about stuff A, like uranium. There's plenty in nature. It is dangerous already because it emits Radon gas. People still live with that. But you really need large quantities for it to be dangerous.
Nuclear power plants need surprisingly small quantities of fuel. And that doesn't turn into large quantities of waste.
"In contrast, the amount of natural uranium required to provide the same amount of energy as 16 kg of fossil fuels, in a standard fission reactor, is 2 grams; and the resulting waste weighs one quarter of a gram."
http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c24/page_16...
The kids in Fukushima disagree, segment from "Children of the Tsunami," BBC, March 1, 2012 ~ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JS0Rf_gWFA
I'm not trying to downplay the plight of those affected, but it's worth separating these concerns when evaluating the true risks involved with any technology that can potentially have great benefits for the bulk of humanity, the rare catastrophe notwithstanding.
The dam wasn't engineered well enough, definitely not up to western standards.
Chernobyl is a similar situation. Anyone can build a dangerous power plant using whatever resource they want.
Safety is something you invest in. The question then becomes how expensive is safe nuclear power vs. safe hydroelectric? The biggest problem with nuclear is that "safe" nuclear power is very expensive compared to the alternatives, but if they can get costs down without sacrificing safety (or the alternatives increase in price), its a good option for us.
For e.g. launching rockets to space can still fail from times to times, despite the effort and care it takes to do it. Crashing planes also occur from times to times, despite our extensive knowledge of the field and all the effort we can put in preventing disasters.
Wouldn't it be sane to assume that nuclear power will also fail from times to times, and you can't do much about it?
Per watthour, nuclear power is the safest form of energy production, by a very large margin[1].
Chernobyl is the worst nuclear disaster in history. The UNSCEAR report states that 62 deaths can reliably be attributed to the disaster. Peer-reviewed estimates of additional deaths in the long-term range from 6,000 to 50,000.
You mightn't have heard of the Banqiao Dam, but you should have. In 1975, Typhoon Nina destroyed 62 dams in Henan Province, China. The biggest of these, the Banqiao Dam, released 700 million cubic metres of water over the course of six hours. The resulting flood destroyed six million buildings, killed 26,000 people and caused a humanitarian disaster that killed another 145,000.
The business of energy is inherently dangerous. We have an instinctive aversion to radioactivity, because it's strange and invisible, but it's just energy. Someone falling into a nuclear reactor seems inherently more horrible than a solar panel installer falling off a rooftop, but a death is a death. The Chernobyl exclusion zone seems innately more frightening than the beaches cordoned off after the Deepwater Horizon disaster, but cancer from crude oil exposure is still cancer.
We've got very good at controlling the risks of nuclear power. We know what the worst case scenario looks like. Radiation exposure isn't nice, but neither is a mine collapse, a gas explosion or climate change. Stories involving radiation are attention-grabbing, but we can't allow that to distract us from the hard data.
[1] http://nextbigfuture.com/2011/10/snapshot-of-deaths-per-tera...