News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by veggieroll on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:28AM (#42127470)
Almost everything listed in this article is a downstream effect or side issue. Yes journalism is expensive and hard work, but that's not why people aren't reading/watching. People aren't reading because they don't trust mainstream news to deliver true facts. Journalists have consistently lost that trust over time and need to reckon with why that is.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by righthand on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:43AM (#42127594)
Politicians lie even more and people have had no problem believing and supporting that lately.

It’s not like journalists are collectively agreeing to lie to the public.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by xoxxala on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:48AM (#42127652)
Public trust in politicians and the government is near all-time lows:

https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/06/24/public-trust...

People are supporting politicians because there is literally nothing else to do but not vote. Also, personally, I expect a politician to lie while holding a journalist to a higher standard. We need proper journalism to hold the government accountable.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by righthand on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:15PM (#42127943)
We do have that but there is strong bias towards not trusting journalism. Everything in the US is capital based and no one wants to pay for journalism. So journalism relies on ad-tactics to get eyeballs looking at their stuff.

This in turn causes low trust because if one type of article is manipulative then the other types must be right?

If people weren’t so anti-capitalism then the journalism would have incentive to be less manipulative across the board.

Furthermore the politicians want manipulative journalism, there is no incentive on either side to do the right thing. If there was we wouldn’t have the political candidates we do today.

Instead we invest in the weakness because be uneducated means you don’t actually have to understand just vote emotionally.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by quickslowdown on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @06:56PM (#42131582)
> If people weren’t so anti-capitalism then the journalism would have incentive to be less manipulative across the board

I'm struggling to put into words the thoughts this sentence triggered. We're on HN, not reddit, so I'm going to assume good faith.

What reasons over the past 30-50 years have capitalists given the population to root for them? When your business model is to fuck over everyone in your path in a race to the bottom for the gain of a select few at the top, why would anyone expect anything else from the people capitalism stomps all over?

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by righthand on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @07:13PM (#42131715)
Because regardless of how hard you get stomped, the system is still capitalism. There’s no need to take revenge on journalism which could work well.

The average American maintains finances by putting their money in a bank where it rots with inflation, of course they get stomped by capitalism.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by some_random on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:03PM (#42127811)
"Politicians" and "Journalists" aren't specific enough to discuss this problem, people haven't been suddenly believing politicians in general they've latched onto specific politicians in specific political parties and believe them. Similarly, you can have people who say they think journalists are all liars but believe specific journalists or specific news outlets. It's like how congresspeople are re-elected pretty consistently despite the national approval of congress as a whole being in the dirt, people like what _their_ guy is up to but not what everyone else is doing.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by marcuskane2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:00PM (#42127765)
Supporting sure, but I don't know about believing.

The most fascinating part of Trump's success is that his supporters know he's lying, exaggerating and making stuff up on the spot and are ok with it. They believe he supports the things they support in a general sense and they believe all politicians lie and cheat, so they don't care even about his most egregious stuff.

I think there's a Dunning-Kruger effect, where people think they're being savvy about a corrupt system. The belief is that the whole edifice of American institutions is really just a facade on top of a corrupt system controlled by elites, and that Trump is being honest in a sense by exposing the corruption, but that his own obvious corruption is just a requirement to succeed in the way the game is played.

And of course Trump makes great use of this. The more he can get people to believe that the other side are liars and crooks, the more they'll tolerate his corruption and lies.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by righthand on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:18PM (#42127978)
Oh it’s definitely a one way street. I realized all the talk coming out of the Trump camp isn’t really about the other side but about themselves. A common repeated phrase is “the other side doesn’t listen to me” which really means “I don’t listen to the other side”.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by xnx on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:37AM (#42127555)
> People aren't reading because they don't trust mainstream news to deliver true facts

People of all stripes seem quite happy to trust news as long as it delivers facts that already fit their worldview

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by kbutler on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:53AM (#42127700)
Not really.

"""Americans continue to register record-low trust in the mass media, with 31% expressing a “great deal” or “fair amount” of confidence in the media to report the news “fully, accurately and fairly,” similar to last year’s 32%. Americans’ trust in the media -- such as newspapers, television and radio -- first fell to 32% in 2016 and did so again last year."""

https://news.gallup.com/poll/651977/americans-trust-media-re...

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by cloudsec9 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @02:16PM (#42128963)
Such studies sometimes ask about the outlets; for some reason conservatives feel Fox news isn't the MSM, while CNN and MSNBC are. Asked about their "non-MSM" outlet, suddenly it is VERY trustworthy.

And these stats hold for liberals as well; they feel their outlet isn't the "MSM", but that Fox is and is untrustworthy.

Since the job of news is now to sell ads and not tell the truth, a lot of "supporters" only hear what their side wants them to hear, and not the facts.

The real problem of course is that each party has different policies; but if we as citizens don't agree on the facts and problems facing us, then there is no way to evaluate the strength of the policies against the problems.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by wakawaka28 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:00PM (#42132019)
Even the "facts" are politicized. Government statistics are falsified or manipulated at the source. Then the media picks and chooses what to report so as to favor the view they want to push. Honest media outlets hold government accountable. I think the best thing for the average person to do is listen to a variety of sources, and compare the news to their own and their friends' experiences. If you're up for research then you can do that along with seeking out true journalists.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by underseacables on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:47PM (#42128257)
Have they been conditioned to be this way over time?
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by wakawaka28 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @07:54PM (#42131966)
Some people might, sure. But studies have shown that a majority of people don't trust the news anymore, across the spectrum of views. If you pay attention and remember what you hear, it does not take long to find examples of the news confidently communicating false reports.

Bias in news has always been a problem, and I think you just have to listen to a variety of sources with different biases to find out the truth.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by travisporter on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:33AM (#42127514)
How does one define mainstream news?
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by ElevenLathe on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:36AM (#42127533)
Stuff your grandma has heard of.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by GauntletWizard on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:41AM (#42127584)
Does it matter? In the modern sellout world, by the time something can be considered "Mainstream", it's already well on the way to abandoning the principles that made it successful in the first place and replacing them with "Cost Effective" practices and monetization, what used to be called Selling Out and is now termed "Enshitiffication".

It does not matter whether you're talking about the broadcast and cable television media (ABC, NBC, CBS, Fox), the new wave media of online-first reporting (All the properties of Conde Nast and Ziff Davis, incl. Wired, Vice, Cracked, Buzzfeed, etc.), or even the third-generation blogosphere (Substack, Medium). There's no trust because success is inversely correlated with trustworthiness.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by forgetfreeman on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:07PM (#42127864)
Folks specifically don't trust journalism because they willfully switched to low quality news sources that intentionally spread hyperbole, propaganda, and opinion pieces in lieu of actual journalism. The market has spoken. Folks like this shit.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by readthenotes1 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @11:58AM (#42127753)
Indeed.

A litmus test for recent journalism is the hunter Biden laptop story.

And the reason is that most journalists nowadays believe that presenting other views is harmful[1]

Most boomers and their children grew up in an unusual period in news when broad and balanced coverage was expected, and even somewhat required in the TV news. "Yellow journalism" is back, though, and we haven't quite adjusted (compare abc news coverage of Biden's plagiarism and lying in the 1980s to their coverage of his mental decline during his presidency)

[1]https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/07/13/u-s-journ...

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by lapcat on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:37PM (#42128168)
> A litmus test for recent journalism is the hunter Biden laptop story.

It's really not. Stories about the families of politicians are better suited for tabloids. They're a distraction at best.

And let's be honest: only a total ignoramus would vote or change their vote based on Hunter Biden. There are a million better reasons.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by underseacables on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:49PM (#42128279)
Tabloids? Not when 51 intelligence professionals sign a letter, claiming the laptop to be false when in fact it was not. I think the laptop story is a classic example of why people distrust a journalists. You had many media outlets, backed by government officials, essentially covering up for Hunter Biden and lying to the public. The laptop exists. It's contents exist. But for years all we heard was that this was a false flag operation from Russia.

That was a lie

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by lapcat on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @01:03PM (#42128407)
> Not when 51 intelligence professionals sign a letter, claiming the laptop to be false when in fact it was not.

No, that's not what they said. Here's what they said: "We want to emphasize that we do not know if the emails, provided to the New York Post by President Trump’s personal attorney Rudy Giuliani, are genuine or not and that we do not have evidence of Russian involvement -- just that our experience makes us deeply suspicious that the Russian government played a significant role in this case." https://www.politico.com/f/?id=00000175-4393-d7aa-af77-579f9...

> The laptop exists. It's contents exist.

So what?

Several Republican-led Congressional committees found no wrongdoing by Joe Biden in the matter. So yes, it's nothing but a tabloid story.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by paleotrope on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @06:03PM (#42131200)
The cynicism in the 51s statement is what's wrong. And the media taking the expected cynical take. The 51 can say we didn't say it was fake we simply strongly implied it. And the media reported the implied lie. The media is either ignorant or more likely complicit.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by lapcat on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @06:14PM (#42131273)
> And the media reported the implied lie.

The media reports a million lies verbatim, because politicians lie.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by paleotrope on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:42PM (#42132617)
These 51 intelligence professionals were not supposed to be politicians, they are supposed to be "experts" in the field.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by readthenotes1 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:39PM (#42132262)
The laptop has emails communications showing that Hunter Biden was claiming that Joe Biden was involved in his business deals, contrary to what Joe Biden was saying.

That was known to any journalists who chose not to report on it

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by defrost on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:10PM (#42132446)
It was reported on at the time.

At the time there were two clear and obvious issues; the provenance was sketchy (material may easily have been added or deleted), and the source (Hunter) was a drug addict.

The "Yeah, my dad's totally on board with this" suffered from both, it may have been fake material added to discredit Biden (hindsight suggests not) OR (just as damning) it's the utterance of a crackhead bignoting an endeavour for credability.

What followed was one partisan media wing endlessly blowing up nothing of substance into a fabricated conspiracy, the other arm either ignoring the nothing of substance or lamely addressing why it was nothing.

You yourself acknowledge this in the framing you used: "showing that Hunter Biden was claiming that .."

The two problematic italics were precisely why knowledgable and honest journalists chose to not endlessly report on it.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by readthenotes1 on Friday November 15, 2024 @01:47PM (#42149683)
Journalists would have worked in your italicized parts, not busy the story
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by defrost on Friday November 15, 2024 @05:22PM (#42151904)
Yeah, they did work the italicized parts at the time .. with a sketchy evidence chain chasing back to the emails of a drug addict that was pretty much it for the day for journalists .. the new day saw plenty more stories with actual meat on the bone.

That's an example of a story not going anywhere, it's commonplace.

What is less common is partisan hacks circling back like a dog to its own vomit and spending months of news cycles pumping up a cardboard outline as a real live bit of news.

Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by underseacables on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @12:46PM (#42128253)
Do you think there is an opportunity for a news publication that reports "just the facts" and holds that as their mantra? No opinions, just facts.
Re:Journalism's fight for survival in a postliterate democracy by xethos on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:10PM (#42132094)
Of course not. The government reports that lots of articles are based on are free. LibGen (which anyone this service would target likely knows of) holds most of the other reports of objective facts. If people were interested in reading the reports, they wouldn't need the paper, and if they need help interpreting the source, that's just a way for readers to scream about bias.

Anything real-time can't be reported on either, because choosing what to report on is a form of bias - even reporting on the latest mass shooting is "Giving coverage to someone that shouldn't be glorified", or "Only showing negatives for the second amendment". There is no way to please people without admitting bias, and then detractors will use tgat to tear down your "unbiased, facts-only" source.