News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by InDubioProRubio on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:31AM (#42114686)
Its also a cultural thing. I dont think a entrepreneurial libertarian texan going into a conflict is going to accept whatever the state decrees. Buy your own gear, improvize on the spot, ignore the brass on top, producing results.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by gambiting on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:57AM (#42114830)
Why would such a person be anywhere near the front line?
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by stainablesteel on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:55AM (#42115126)
because their family has been doing it for generations and they keep winning
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by chipdart on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:08AM (#42115193)
> (...) and they keep winning

That's the textbook definition of survivorship bias. It's like a lottery winner boasting about his winning strategy that everyone else is just not able to learn.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bumby on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:37AM (#42115794)
I read the OP differently. I think there can be many angles to a person's identity makeup and they don't always cohere perfectly. A person can have their identity in "entrepreneurial libertarian" while also having it as "someone who comes from a family valuing military service". Humans aren't always perfectly rational when it comes to their different values/tribal identities.

There are a lot of people who join the military while simultaneously "hate authority" for example.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by chipdart on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:34AM (#42117006)
My answer was not touching on the topic of identity. I'm referring to the relationship between cause ad effect.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bumby on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:56PM (#42117881)
That is still downstream of the question of “why would someone make such a [seemingly contradictory] decision.” The person you replied to is misunderstanding the OP, which they later clarified.

My point is understanding outcome causality doesn’t necessarily have to even enter the decision.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bluGill on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:48AM (#42115858)
At what point do we conclude the lottery isn't as random as they claim if one person keeps winning. Statistically someone will win, there are good odds someone will win twice, but the odds of anyone winning 3 times is almost zero.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by chipdart on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:52AM (#42115881)
> At what point do we conclude the lottery isn't as random as they claim if one person keeps winning.

The whole thing about survivorship bias is that you make a critical failure in analysis when confusing partial observations of post-facto results with causality.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bluGill on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:35AM (#42117016)
The point of statistics (one of many) is to figure out how many observations we need. If someone wins the lottery 10 times with their system I will assume that they have a good system (if they have a lot of losses as well it means the system isn't perfect, but it still works), but if you only win once and never enter again I assume it is survivorship basis. Of course by winning the lottery I mean win a large jackpot - most have smaller prizes that you have high odds of winning many times if you play often enough.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by manwe150 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:45PM (#42117782)
Only if you only play 3 times though (in your previous example). Statistics also are about figuring out what sort of outliers must exist for a process to be fair (true random). For something like a mega lottery with terrible odds, then winning twice is already very unlikely. But for something easy like a coin flip, every N trials should have a run of about sqrt N heads or wins in a row if it is unbiased. For something unlikely like lotto, it is closer to looking at the birthday paradox: the probability of one person winning twice is low; but the probability that there exists a person who won twice is high, at random.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by chipdart on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @02:24AM (#42123666)
> The point of statistics (one of many) is to figure out how many observations we need.

No, you're missing the whole point. Think about the problem about survivorship bias. Imagine you are at a M&Ms factory. You decide you want to assess what's the color distribution of M&Ms by sampling the colors that come out of the production line. You somehow make the mistake of sampling the production line for the peanut core M&Ms right out of the pipe that produces yellow M&Ms. You sample away and after hours you present your findings: 99.9% of yellow M&Ms have a peanut core. Based on your findings, you proceed to boldly claim that having a yellow core is a critical factor in producing yellow M&Ms. You even go as far as to rationalize it, and claim that yellow represents peanuts, and if anyone wants to create yellw-colored candy they need to start by adding peanut to the mix.

I then alert you to the fact that you made a critical failure in analysis when confusing partial observations of post-facto results with causality. Your answer:

> The point of statistics (one of many) is to figure out how many observations we need. If someone wins the lottery 10 times with their system I will assume that they have a good system (if they have a lot of losses as well it means the system isn't perfect, but it still works), but if you only win once and never enter again I assume it is survivorship basis.

You're sampling M&Ms out of the freakin' peanut M&M production line. If you fix your mistake, you'll get all kinds of M&Ms. You do not fix your mistake with higher sampling. Your mistake is that you're unwittingly filtering out an important subset of the problem domain, and proceeded to do a faulty analysis on the subset you picked.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by HPsquared on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @04:49AM (#42124540)
There must be a name for "wrongly assuming everything is random and variables are independent". Like the opposite of the gambler's fallacy.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by gambiting on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:27AM (#42115296)
No I mean more like....

1) why would someone who calls themselves libertarian even join any kind of formalized armed force

2) even if they did, how would the command not realize that clearly such a person is unfit for duty and at best should be confined to some work far away from actual combat

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by ajuc on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:15AM (#42114932)
It works the exact opposite way.

People from totalitarian shitholes improvise a lot more than people from functioning democracies (because they have to improvise to survive daily life). And they trust their state and follow the rules a lot less (and for a good reason - their state exploits and lies to them to a degree you can't imagine living in a free country).

USA wouldn't send its army to Mexico with 12 hours of fuel telling the soldiers it's exercises. After selling half the fuel and ammo on black market and providing them with faulty non-spec tires so that significant percentage of their vehicles just broke the first week it actually had to drive somewhere.

Russian army did all of the above, on a massive scale. Nobody in Russia was surprised except maybe putin. IMHO he was more surprised that Ukraine was organized than that his own army wasn't.

Think for a while how you'd adapt to living in such a society. One of the first things is that you pretend to do what they tell you and then completely ignore it and do whatever you can to survive. And then to adapt to that - the army has units that shoot at you from behind if you don't want to be a "meat wave" in the next frontal attack.

Army won't provide you shoes your size? Steal. Army won't provide you drones or anti-drone measures? Cope cages and loot Mavics from malls. Etc. In totalitarian countries (and I've lived in one so I'd know) everybody had to learn DIY cause you couldn't trust the economy/country to provide you with the things you need.

Oligarchy and libertarianism is the same system, just looking from POV of rulers vs ruled. When society doesn't work people have to be libertarians. When everybody's a libertarian - oligarchs rule and society doesn't work.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:35AM (#42115351)
You nailed it.

Lack of social solidarity and communal trust has got to be a kiss of death in wartime. Especially when fighting against an opponent who has it in spades. (US in Vietnam, Russia in early days of the war in Ukraine, etc.).

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by whatshisface on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:00AM (#42115943)
That is all true, except there's another reason people learn to DIY. That is when they have a basically functional government and economy but live in a rural area. The US libertarian ethos stems from a cultural memory of pioneers and farmers that couldn't be served by a centralized state.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by cafard on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:19AM (#42116131)
Ok, but who acquired the land for them?
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by whatshisface on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:32AM (#42116271)
In most cases, the settlers traveled into tribal territory and started fending off attacks themselves. They didn't have to attack first because they were establishing permanent settlements in the territory of nomads.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by asacrowflies on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:53AM (#42117204)
This is basically entirely false ... They would only move into settle AFTER the government clears the land of most natives and signed "treaties" with others. Along with mass relocation and government programs to incentivize the settlers like encouraging the military to kill all Buffalo on site or actively salt spring water sources in favour of European deep wells.etc.etc.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by vel0city on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:23PM (#42117530)
This isn't really clarifying the question of "who acquired the land for them", just acknowledging they (sometimes? often?) had to defend for themselves out there. In the end those settlers purchased deeds to those lands often for very cheap from the US federal government and expected for the federal government to support their Westward movement (which often did happen as well).

They acquired the land from the government and expected some amount of protection provided by the federal government as well.

And even then a ton of that settlement happened after many wars and what not with Native American tribes and groups in those territories.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by whatshisface on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:36PM (#42117685)
Without getting into the (worthwhile) details of US expansion, it's important to note that the security provided by the continental and federal governments did not stop raids, and on a scale of services provided relative to dysfunctional present day governments was truly hands-off. There is running water in Aleppo.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bumby on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:46AM (#42116431)
>And they trust their state and follow the rules a lot less

It was my understanding that the opposite was true in Ukraine early in the conflict. Russia suffered high casualties because they still relied on a central command structure and field leaders were reluctant to make decisions without the express validation of their superiors. This led to them being sitting ducks as they waited for confirmation, and resulted in many high level soldiers being killed because they had to travel to the front lines to communicate orders for any effect.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by ajuc on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:14PM (#42117390)
The centralised structure, the lack of trust and selfishness, and the improvisation and ignoring the rules are all connected.

The less people care about rules - the harsher you have to be to enforce them.

The high level officers had to go to the front lines not because foot soldiers were helpless without them. They had to go there because without them the soldiers would ignore the orders to go forward, hide in relatively safer place, start looting and lie in the reports they executed the orders perfectly killing thousands of enemies :)

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bumby on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:43PM (#42120036)
>the soldiers would ignore the orders

Doesn't that undermine the OP's claim that people in more totalitarian regimes have higher trust in the state and hierarchy?

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by sznio on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @04:31AM (#42124434)
>And they trust their state [...] a lot less
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by kstrauser on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:02AM (#42115969)
You’ve never been through boot camp, huh. Such a person would have an unbelievably unpleasant time until:

- The military sent them home,

- They cracked and sent themselves home, or

- They got over themselves and learned how to be part of the larger whole.

Making it through with those edge opinions intact is not an option.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by Tanoc on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:39PM (#42117716)
That wasn't really true during World War II. Some of the most celebrated veterans of that war were anti-authority as hell, doing things like stealing parts of fellow aircrews' planes to rebuild their own, ignoring formation to get better torpedo angles, and running ahead of everyone else in a tank. In Korea that attitude still survived, but only in the air, and by the end of the Vietnam war it had basically been stamped out. The U.S. military since about 1972 is way less lenient than before then, especially as the equipment's gotten more expensive.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by rascul on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:29PM (#42121147)
> stealing parts of fellow aircrews' planes to rebuild their own

US Army still does that today to some extent (not with planes anymore though). It's not stealing, they're just getting their stuff back.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by marcuskane2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:50AM (#42126525)
You should listen to interviews with special operations folks. Navy Seals, Green Berets, Delta Force, etc.

There is a strong culture of do what's needed to accomplish the mission. Even a "if you're not cheating, you're not trying" to many challenges.

HN has a curiously strong hatred of libertarians (although also professing to dislike authoritarians?) so it's not surprising the comment got downvoted though.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by pc86 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:05AM (#42115996)
You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.