News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:03AM (#42108096)
> why try to bring back a species we already killed off?

To observe and study them, for one. Also, to see if we can (and learn how to and how not).

> same impulse that led to the poodle

What’s wrong with poodles (or domesticated dogs in general)?

(You could have said French bulldog. But you chose a very intelligent, hypoallergenic breed with few health issues compared to other pure breeds.)

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by hunter-gatherer on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:19AM (#42108250)
I'm sure OP just threw out poodle as a reference to all inbred (purebred) dogs. I have actually had this on my mind a lot lately, and I was telling my wife about how the wild dogs I've had experience with in the Middle East and Africa seemed so much stronger and capable than pretty much any dog in the west, probably because there is still some survival-of-the-fittest going on there.

I used to have an AKC golden retriever that died of osteosarcoma at 14, and had a non-functioning pancreas since he was about 2, which meant he had to be supplemented with enzymes his entire life. The eugenics movement in the couple hundred years really has ruined dogs in the western world. There are so few people who breed responsibly that finding them is a huge chore. I'm inferring that what OP meant by "same impulse that led to the poodle" is this impulse that created all these genetic monstrosities. People need to let go of the "pure bred" idea in my opinion.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by RoyalHenOil on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @07:18PM (#42131749)
AKC golden retrievers are very badly inbred (they are 27.3% inbred, according to the raw data from this study: https://cgejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40575...) — two random "unrelated" golden retrievers are more closely related to each other than human siblings are — and they are prone to serious health problems, especially cancer. It is not a breed I would ever recommend due to these issues, especially from AKC lines — which are bred for competition and therefore have a very limited stud pool.

But that doesn't mean all dog breeds are equally inbred and equally prone to health problems.

Poodles are in MUCH better shape than golden retrievers.

Golden retrievers are twice as inbred as poodles. And unlike golden retrievers, poodles have not been bred toward an unhealthy type; they have a slim, primitive body shape and a non-brachycephalic head shape that is associated with good health and long lifespan in dogs.

If I were seeking an example of a pointless, harmful breeding program in dogs, I would not have chosen poodles. There are endless other breeds (pugs, Cavalier King Charles spaniels, etc.) that have been wrecked by thoughtless breeding practices.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by lolinder on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:19AM (#42108240)
I don't have a problem with poodles, but breeding them wasn't a conservation effort. Not everything we do needs to be, but I'm concerned that programs like this one suck air from programs that could actually make progress towards real conservation.

If they framed it as a poodle-breeding effort I would be unconcerned.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by _DeadFred_ on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:21PM (#42108761)
Do you really think bringing in the types that find reviving extinct animals 'sucks the air' from conservation efforts? It gives an interesting visual story that protecting a rodent species in the middle of nowhere can't.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by InDubioProRubio on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:40AM (#42108424)
We can also prep them up with good times economy money in some reservation and then have them poached off when bad times roll around.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by astura on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:54AM (#42108543)
>hypoallergenic breed

There's no such thing - certain breeds being "hypoallergenic" is a straight up lie that was made up by breeders to sell dogs.

https://archive.is/8rUwG

https://www.jacionline.org/article/S0091-67491201380-2/fullt...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by s1artibartfast on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:27PM (#42108802)
I wouldnt be so conclusive. I'm open to the idea that hypoallergenic branding is garbage, but non-shedding certainly is a phenotype, which can have an impact independent of allergens in hair samples.

It is also worth nothing that the cited study showed 4-5 orders of magnitude difference between allergen samples from different animals (0.1 to 1000 ug/g). The results just didn't group well across breeds. IF someone showed me this data at work, I would say they are either failing to isolate causes of variability or have a shitty measurement system.

https://www.jacionline.org/article/S0091-6749(12)00793-2/ful...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by wholinator2 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:43PM (#42120602)
I would bet to differ here. I've got pretty strong allergies to dogs, i couldn't even stay a night at a girlfriends house without medicating myself to sleep, waking up with a crusty throat, red eyes, and a blocked nose for days straight. But i grew up with a dog who would only ever give my nose a slight itch if i rubbed my face on him for a bit.

The difference? Breed. She had an Australian shepherd (i think), large and shredded a ton absolutely all the time. There were drifts of hair on every corner in the house if she didn't vacuum for a week. We had a havanese poodle mix, small guy, barely shed at all. So sure, if you take the absolute most extreme position possible that hypo means completely no allergens whatsoever at all, then it doesn't exist. But in reality i can live with one dog and can't with another, that's the only definition of hypoallergenic that actually matters to people

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by alephnerd on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:09AM (#42108159)
> What’s wrong with poodles

Poodles have similar issues to French Bulldogs because they have a genetic bottleneck as well.

> To observe and study them, for one. Also, to see if we can (and learn how to and how not).

I can understand the reasoning of trying it for the sake of trying (ethical considerations aside), but I'm not sure if an extinct species that is resurrected via some form of cloning would even be a representative sample to observe actual behavior.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:11AM (#42108178)
> Poodles have similar issues to French Bulldogs because they have a genetic bottleneck as well

Source?

I thought small and toy breeds make up most of the problematic breeds. Standard poodles’ hip dysplasia, like retrievers’, is mostly a product of early spaying and neutering leading to deformed hips. It’s environmental, in other words, not genetic.

> not sure if an extinct species that is resurrected via some form of cloning would even be a representative sample to observe actual behavior

It would be a guide into what behavioural factors in modern elephants were evolved versus learned. Obviously not pristinely. But it’s another data point.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by alephnerd on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:21AM (#42108261)
> Source?

https://cgejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40575...

> It would be a guide into what behavioural factors in modern elephants were evolved versus learned. Obviously not pristinely. But it’s another data point.

But couldn't you do the same thing with an RCT?

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:25AM (#42108299)
> couldn't you do the same thing with an RCT?

Maybe, maybe not.

You certainly wouldn’t refine your genetic and artificial gestation techniques that way.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by alephnerd on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:28AM (#42108323)
Fair point.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by fellowmartian on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:14AM (#42108198)
All breeds have breed-specific issues, but saying that Poodles have similar issues to brachycephalic breeds is just silly, those are different orders of magnitude of suffering.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by optionalsquid on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:39PM (#42108893)
> To observe and study them, for one. Also, to see if we can (and learn how to and how not).

The thing is that they are not actually bringing a species back. Rather, they are creating something that superficially resembles an extinct species based on an equally superficial set of selection criteria. Genetically speaking their "quagga" is still going to be much, much closer to the population of zebras from which it was bred, compared to actual quaggas. So whatever we learn from those "quaggas" is unlikely to be transferable to the historical quagga