As such, compared to the alternative (bad actors having even more time to leverage and amplify the information asymmetry), a timely public disclosure is preferable, even with some unfortunate and unavoidable fallout. Typically security researchers are reasonable and want to do the right thing with regard to responsible disclosure.
On average, the "bigger party" inherently has more resources to respond compared to the reporter. This remains true even in open source software.
> the vast majority of security vulnerabilities in software are not actively exploited
However I’d say your explanation that it’s
> because no one knows about them
is not necessarily the reason why.
If the vendor or developer isn’t fixing things, going public is the correct option. (I agree some lead time / attempt at coordinated disclosure is preferable here.)
Then I think we are in agreement overall. I took your initial comment to mean that as soon as you discover a vulnerability, you should make it public. If we agree that the process should always be to disclose it to the project, wait some amount of time, and only then make it public - then I think we are actually on the exact same page.
Now, for the specific amount of time: ideally, you'd wait until the project has a patch available, if they are collaborating and prioritizing things appropriately. However, if they are dragging their feet and/or not even acknowledging that a fix is needed, then I also agree that you should set a fixed time as a last ditch attempt to get them to fix it (say, "2 weeks from today"), and then make it public as a 0-day.
Wouldn’t a “good criminal” just exploit it forever without getting caught? Your timeline has no ceiling.
However, if you don't know that it is being actively exploited, then the right course of action is to disclose it secretly to the creators, and work with them to coordinate on a timely patch before any public disclosure. Exactly how timely will depend on yours and their judgement of many factors. Even if the team is showing very bad judgement from your point of view, and acting dismissively; even if you have a history with them of doing this - you still owe it to the users of the code to at least try, and to at least give some unilateral but reasonable timeline in which you will disclose.
Even if you don't want to do this free work, the alternative is not to publicly disclose: it's to do nothing. In general, the users are still safer with an unknown vulnerability than they are with a known one that the developers aren't fixing. You don't have any responsibility to waste your own time to try to work with disagreeable people, but you also don't have the right to put users at risk just because you found an issue.
It’s unethical to users who are at risk to withhold critical information.
If McDonalds had an e-coli outbreak and a keen doctor picked up on it you wouldn't withhold that information from the public while McD developed a nice pr-strategy and quietly waited for the storm to pass, would you?
Why is security, which seriously is a public safety issue, any different?
The point of a disclosure window is to allow a fix before _all_ bad actors get access to the vulnerability.
Medicine and biosafety are PvE. Cybersecurity is PvP.
Initially I had said 90 days from the initial report, but it seemed like they were expanding the work to fill that time. I asked a number of times for them to make a security advisory and got no answer. Some discussions on the repo showed they were considering this as a theoretical issue. Now it's CVE-2024-51774, which got assigned within 48 hours of disclosing.
That's hilarious. It's all theoretical until it's getting exploited in the wild...
Maybe immediate disclosure would cause a few users to change their behavior, but no one is tracking security disclosures on all the software they use and changing their behavior based on them.
The caveat here is in case you have evidence of active exploitation, then immediate disclosure makes sense.
The real problem came later when the next generation of developers saw this HTTPClient class and thought, "Hey, what a nifty little helper!", and soon they were using it to talk to pretty much everything, including financial systems. I was shocked when I discovered it. An inconsequential temporary workaround had turned into a huge security hole.
Edit (just noticed this was the author): I'm curious what torrent client do you prefer? I like Deluge but mostly go to it because it's familiar.
See a full list: https://doc.qt.io/qt-6/index.html
Much more likely is that someone knew they had implemented this temporary solution while they implemented OpenSSL in a project which previously never had SSL support - a major change with a lot of work involved - and every programmer knows that there is nothing more permanent than a temporary solution. Especially in this case. I can understand how such code would make it into the repo(I think you do too), and it's very easy for us to say we would then have immediately amended it in the next version to properly verify certs.
Having been in contact with the maintainers, I have to say I was disappointed in how seriously they took the issue. I don't want to say any more than that.
Source: author of the article