News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by pxoe on Saturday October 26, 2024 @04:57AM (#41953551)
Mastodon is not decentralized, it's federated. It doesn't solve some of the problems that come with centralization, it just creates more entities that will have the same problems (being at will of a server). And funnily, it doesn't even solve data portability entirely (you can't actually move your posts). Mastodon's "decentralization" is even worse than a "theoretical promise" of one, cause it's a just marketing promise when it literally just does not work that way in some aspects. You're still "centralized" to whatever server you signed up on, still with caveats that an actual centralized service would have. It's better, but it's truly not all it's made out to be. Definitely not to the point where such sneer and kind of just, speculatively making shit up, wouldn't look just ironic.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by davexunit on Saturday October 26, 2024 @08:16AM (#41954285)
Federation is a form of decentralization. It has its issues but it doesn't mean it isn't decentralized. Moving towards distributed, peer-to-peer applications is the path forward.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by toofy on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:25AM (#41953657)
> it just creates more entities that will have the same problems (being at will of a server).

this isn’t a “problem” that needs to be solved. you’re not “at the will of the server” in a federated environment, its the actual literal opposite. if i don’t like the server operators or if i don’t like the servers it federates with, that’s totally ok. i start my own and federate with who i like.

this is a good thing, not a “problem.” the ability to freely move and the freedom to associate is incredibly important. and for some weird reason people keep pretending like these things aren’t important if it’s online. its ridiculous.

if i don’t want to spend my play time around eric, i should absolutely be able to move and play somewhere else without eric. that’s actual freedom. if you try to keep me in one place or force me to play with eric, you’re trapping me.

no, the ability to pick and choose how, why, where, and with who i spend my free time is important, its not a “problem”. that’s agency, and i wish people would quit arguing against agency and calling it a problem.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by lukan on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:11AM (#41953817)
"if i don’t like the servers it federates with, that’s totally ok. i start my own and federate with who i like."

So everytime you move, can you take your existing network and posts and messages with you, or do you have to start from scratch every time?

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by ttepasse on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:43AM (#41953949)
You can take your existing network with you, Mastodon has Accounts redirects and follower migrations. Your own content not yet. While Mastodon-the-software has an export function, there is no import as yet. But that is a solvable problem.

https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/moving/

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by echoangle on Saturday October 26, 2024 @07:40AM (#41954139)
Does the migration also work if the server I’m migrating from actively wants to prevent me from taking over my stuff? If they ban me from their server because they don’t like me, they aren’t going to set up a redirect for me, right? Is this a real thing that happens?
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by toofy on Saturday October 26, 2024 @09:07AM (#41954513)
im not the person you responded to, but i think this worry is mostly just overblown. i dont think most people have this concern. i think some do, but not most.

if its something you're super worried about, you could always do what ive seen some folks do and just like docs, photos, etc..., make a backup. just create a mirror federated account with same follows etc...

its not really something i personally have a need for. to me, the worst that happens is i lose some conversations i had with some friends. i cant remember the last time i looked back at some random tweet i made 3 years ago or whatever...

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by hoidofyolen on Saturday October 26, 2024 @12:52PM (#41955959)
the issue is that this is a little myopic when thinking about identity. Your instance server in ActivityPub holds your identity, so when you change servers by mirroring or whatever method, you're giving up your old identity and taking on a copy. That identity part is crucial because if you want to, for example, do OAuth with ActivityPub, your old server technically owns an identity of yours that's just as valid as your new one. It's better on atproto because your identity is always your own (with the caveat that it's currently managed by Bluesky's https://plc.directory, but like they've said, they're working to move this outside the company). ActivityPub will never give you true account portability unless they do something like atproto and allow identity portability. Atproto allows this already. You can move your PDS (where your data is hosted, and the thing that controls access to OAuth) to a new one whenever you want.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by toofy on Saturday October 26, 2024 @09:25AM (#41954603)
well my comment was specifically pointing out that giving someone agency is the opposite of “a problem.” i was pointing out that having options to spend your freetime how and where you like is the literal opposite of forcing you to “the will of a server” or whatever their statement was.

to your comment, the ability to keep posts and such is going to vary by which system you’re using, for example:

- twitter, absolutely not. they want to force you to spend your free time around whoever they say. and they absolutely want to make it difficult for you to have freedom to leave or the freedom to associate. in the before times there were sites you could use to move your contacts and follow the same people on Mastodon. elon hated the idea of people having freedom so he shut that down shortly after he took power. for this reason i recommend people start manually building their contacts on other sites now so the move will be easier once you’re ready.

- threads, im not familiar enough with it yet to say for sure. i have a couple of accounts there but honestly, ill never use them, its zuckerberg… facebook… no thanks. been burned too many times by these people.

- Mastodon, almost entirely yes. you can backup and download both your posts and your contacts. i dont worry too much about it, but if it’s something you’re super worried about just do like we all do with photos, docs, etc… keep a backup. i know some people keep a backup federated account mirroring follows, etc… for worst case scenarios. i occasionally download my follows and posts, but im not really too worried about it.

- bluesky, yep. i love blue sky but for different reasons from Mastodon, i use them both all day long. just for different reasons. blue sky doesn’t at all have the same quality of community as Mastodon or even hn. it’s nice, but its not community focused. its more like twitter before eternal september took over. at the end of the day tho, i don’t have a lot of hope for it, the VC people will definitely figure out a way to ruin it.

but to bring it back to my original comment: the important part is that we have the agency to utilize freedom of movement and association. it should creep you out when someone tries to convince you that having agency is a problem. having freedom to jump from place to place, server to server, community to community is a good thing and its crazy when these people keep attempting to convince us that jumping around is "a problem".

when someone tries to force you to spend your playtime somewhere you don’t want to be, or when they try to convince you “no, you should want to be around eric especially when he’s a dickbag.” that should make your hair stand up with red flags. and that’s what these people have been trying to convince us for years—“noooo, why would you want to spend your free time somewhere else having fun? dont go enjoy yourself! you want to be here! no one here likes each other and everyone is screaming at each other! thats what you really want to do with your freetime!”

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by pxoe on Saturday October 26, 2024 @10:56AM (#41955126)
"backing up" and data takeouts are not data portability, cause with mastodon you can't actually move posts between servers. so it's like, literally what's the point if you cannot actually move your content and it's gonna be a flush and start new again, which in that regard is no different than moving from one proprietary platform to another
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by toofy on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:01PM (#41957700)
sure, i can see why some might worry about this but like i said in a different comment, for me, most social media, ability to go back and reference years old random conversations just isn’t of any kind of critical “identity”. more important to me is just having a reference of who i’m mutual friends with.

other than some family pictures on insta, i can’t remember the last time i’ve gone back and looked at old conversations. i can imagine why some people might need that, but for Mastodon i mostly use it for chatting with friends or light ephemeral type stuffs.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by pxoe on Saturday October 26, 2024 @07:09PM (#41958394)
for artists, content creators, their posts are literally their body of work. this is why people don't move away from twitter, for example - while the audience is important, having posts there is also just as important if not more, cause these posts are the thing that brought in the audience in the first place, and may continuously bring in the audience thru people browsing profiles and sharing/reposting.

besides whatever the content of posts might be, not treating it like 'a part of your identity' when it is literally a reflection of it, i don't know, seems a little dismissive of yourself, but if that's your prerogative, sure. it's super not the same for everybody. for some people, their stuff is either more important to them personally regardless of what it is, or it holds more value with the amount of work put into it, or both.

it's a little bit obtuse to look at platforms filled with posts, and then go and think that those posts are of no value, when it is literally the point and the core of those platforms, don't you think. like, you don't have to imagine. just look at those places that are filled with art and artists, content and creators.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by rtpg on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:01AM (#41953563)
"Being at will of a server" is always a problem, but with federation you can choose which server you are at the will of. You still need trust, but that trust can be chosen by you based off of your needs (and that trust can be placed in yourself). You're on a different part of the trust gradient.

Meanwhile there's a certain quality of service that can be obtained with "mere" federation that is much tougher for many decentralized strategies. The actual topology matters, but federation is a pretty decent model IMO! There's a reason that e-mail has been so useful as a system for so long!

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by lifthrasiir on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:09AM (#41953594)
And the federation also made the spam email problem a lot worse ;-)

Anyhow, federation should be seen as a part of specific strategy for decentralization; federation itself is not decentralization and cannot achieve it without more bits---like topological consideration. Many federated protocols tend to push those bits into the horizon and fail at scale when that horizon eventually approaches, while ATProto is at least explicitly constructed with eventual decentralization in the mind and seems to be fine for now. Mastodon will need to prove much more than ATProto in order to show that it's capable for eventual decentralization in contrast.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by davexunit on Saturday October 26, 2024 @07:59AM (#41954210)
Saying the fediverse is not decentralized is a wild take.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by lifthrasiir on Saturday October 26, 2024 @08:29AM (#41954352)
My assumption is that the fediverse is seek to replicate what was already possible in the centralized manner---a large-scale social network in this case. Mastodon is of course decentralized by nature, but but it is not yet a decentralized social network under my assumption because it doesn't fully demonstrate a large-scale social network right now. To be clear, neither does ATProto/BlueSky right now! But scaling a social network is shown to be hard even without decentralization and it seems more likely that Mastodon would hit the scaling issue earlier than ATProto. That's what I meant by "capable for eventual decentralization".

One particularly visible weakness of Mastodon is that there is no working and efficient mechanism to operate on the entire network. Searching and algorithmic feed [1] would be major features affected by this weakness. I know some consider this to be intentional, but if that's true then Mastodon can't be really said to replicate a social network at all. It is yet another matter whether such features are warranted or not, but if we believe that something like a worldwide social network should exist, then we don't yet have a clear answer that a social network without such features would be technically or socially scalable to that extent, so not being able to fully replicate an existing social network is important enough to consider.

[1] This includes trivial feeds like all posts from my followers, because in my knowledge a large number of follows is not really scalable in Mastodon.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by llm_trw on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:25AM (#41953868)
We've gone from digital totalitarianism to digital feudalism.

This does not seem like an improvement.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by Terr_ on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:32AM (#41953909)
Perhaps manorialism rather than feudalism, which implies certain bidirectional duties.

It may not be a huge improvement when identities and posts can't be migrated, but it's still an incremental one.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by rtpg on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:56AM (#41953993)
While I don't really know about posts being migrated, identities at least can be migrated in the common circumstance of someone simply wanting to change providers and the old host being willing to hold onto the "moved" record for long enough
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by rtpg on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:55AM (#41953989)
I don't think that is correct? You can spin up your own instance and do stuff on it. The fact that some people want to share their resources isn't feudalism.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by zimpenfish on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:30AM (#41953677)
> (you can't actually move your posts)

You can export and import, I believe, for some instances but generically re-posting them to a new instance with the old date isn't currently feasible[0], correct.

You also need to re-federate them to get the "links" correct (and probably de-federate the old) which causes confusing results if your client doesn't handle backdated posts correctly (and most of the ones I was using in 2023 didn't.)

There's probably a solution[1][2] but I think it's something the ActivityPub people just haven't given much thought to just yet.

[0] No date field in https://docs.joinmastodon.org/methods/statuses/#create

[1] When I was importing a 10 year Twitter history to my Akkoma instance, I just tweaked the code to a) allow backdating posts, b) allow certain accounts to backdate posts and c) not federate backdated posts from those accounts. Doesn't really solve the full problem but worked for me.

[2] Obviously there's other problems such as people creating fake history, etc., if you're allowed to post backdated statuses.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by simgt on Saturday October 26, 2024 @06:43AM (#41953948)
> [2] Obviously there's other problems such as people creating fake history, etc., if you're allowed to post backdated statuses.

I don't think it's a problem really, but I may be mistaken about what the goal of these platforms is. I can also create a fake history on a blog or news site and backdate posts. But in the odd case where it matters, say for a copyright dispute or something, it'd be very hard to pretend that the history is legit and very easy to find clues that it is not.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by zimpenfish on Saturday October 26, 2024 @07:07AM (#41954032)
> I can also create a fake history on a blog or news site

Without the implied "authority" of something like Mastodon[0] or Twitter[1], or Facebook, etc. though. You can (currently) point to a post on a $BIGNETWORK and say "I posted that then" and be credibly believed. If you allow backdated (or timestamp-edited) posts, that goes out of the window, surely.

[0] Ok, not if you're running your own instance, obviously.

[1] Who resisted adding editing for years for similar reasons.

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by a2128 on Saturday October 26, 2024 @08:33AM (#41954369)
A federated network is a decentralized network. You're probably thinking of distributed networks, which federation is not.