News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by lokimedes on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:04AM (#41943795)
Not long after the initial discovery, we had enough data for everyone at the experiments to simply run a basic invariant-mass calculation and see the mass peak popping up.

Once I could "see" the peak, without having to conduct statistical tests against expected background, it was "real" to me.

In these cynical times, it may be that everything is relative and "post-modern subjective p-hacking", but sufficient data usually ends these discussions. The real trouble is that we have a culture that is addicted to progress theater, and can't wait for the data to get in.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by louthy on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:40AM (#41944282)
> run a basic invariant-mass calculation and see the mass peak popping up.

For the idiots in this post (me), could you please explain what that entails and why it helps confirm the discovery?

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by fnands on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:28AM (#41945071)
Not the original commenter, but also ex-HEP person:

The invariant mass is the rest mass of the particle (i.e. it's "inherent" mass). You can calculate it by taking the final state decay products of the original particle (i.e. the particles that are actually observed by the detector) and summing up their four-vectors (squared).

You can plot the invariant mass calculated from any particular final state, and for a rare particle like the Higgs the majority of the contributions to your plot will be from background processes (i.e. not Higgs decays) that decay into the same final state.

If you have a lot of Higgs decays in your sample you should be able to see a clear peak in the distribution at the invariant mass of the Higgs boson, a clear sign that the Higgs (or something with the same mass) exists.

Often by the time the discovery has reached statistical significance, you might not really be able to see such a clear sign in the mass distribution. I.e. the calculations are telling you it's there but you can't see it that clearly.

I wouldn't really say this helps confirm the discovery in a scientific sense, just that it's reassuring that the signal is so strong that you can see it by eye.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by exmadscientist on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:21AM (#41946138)
> just that it's reassuring that the signal is so strong that you can see it by eye

It's really something when this happens. I worked on a big neutrino experiment searching for theta_13, where our goals were to (a) determine if theta_13 was dead zero or not (being truly zero would have a Seriously Major Effect in theories) and then (b) to measure its value if not.

Our experiment was big, expensive, and finely tuned to search for very, very small values of theta_13. We turned the thing on and... right there there was a dip. Just... there. On the plot. All the data blinding schemes needed to guarantee our best resolution kind of went out the window when anyone looking at the most basic status plot could see the dip immediately!

On the one hand, it was really great to know that everything worked, we'd recorded a major milestone in the field (along with our competition, all of whom were reading out at basically the same time), and the theorists would continue to have nothing to do with their lives because theta_13 was, in fact, nonzero. On the other hand... I wasted how many years of my life dialing this damned detector in for what now? (It wasn't wasted effort, not at all... but you get the feeling.)

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by nick3443 on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:54AM (#41945319)
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by Filligree on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:50AM (#41946426)
Squared four-vectors?

I'm only an amateur, but wouldn't that give different results depending on choice of units? I.e, I usually use C=1.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by dguest on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:11PM (#41946653)
the math is

m^2 c^4 = E^2 - p^2 c^2

where m is mass, E is the total energy in the decay products and p is the 3-vector sum of the momentum.

Those units should work out (they certainly do if you set c = 1).

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by Filligree on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:12PM (#41947281)
Ah, I see. I was assuming you meant the 4-momentum. Though I'm not sure this doesn't come out to the same thing.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by dguest on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:49PM (#41947657)
what I showed is the squared 4 momentum when you use the Minkowski metric [1], assuming "squared" means "self-dot product". The formulation above is just another way to illustrate the Minkowski dot product.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minkowski_space#Minkowski_metr...

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by sixo on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:27PM (#41946817)
you use the same units on both sides of the equation, it's fine, it's like counting "meters squared"
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by WalterBright on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:36PM (#41948227)
What about the loss of mass released as energy inherent to the decay process?
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by cwillu on Friday October 25, 2024 @04:17PM (#41949241)
“Energy” is only released as the energy and momentum of the resulting particles.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by thaumasiotes on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:46AM (#41944320)
> In these cynical times, it may be that everything is relative and "post-modern subjective p-hacking", but sufficient data usually ends these discussions.

I don't think that's right. I think having an application is what ends the discussions.

If you have a group of people who think CD players work by using lasers, and a rival group who think they do something entirely different, and only the first group can actually make working CD players, people will accept that lasers do what group #1 says they do.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by dspillett on Friday October 25, 2024 @08:35AM (#41944639)
> people will accept that lasers do what group #1 says they do

Most people. Some fringe groups will believe it is all a front, and they are only pretending that so-called “lasers” are what make the CD player work when in fact it is alien tech from Area 51 or eldritch magics neither of which the public would be happy about. What else would CDDA stand for, if not Compliant Demon Derived Audio? And “Red Book”. Red. Book. Red is the colour of the fires of hell and book must be referring to the Necronomicon! Wake up sheeple!

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by biofox on Friday October 25, 2024 @08:56AM (#41944805)
Counterpoint: Vaccines work, but far too many people think that COVID vaccines contain Jewish-made GPS tracking devices that act as micro-antennae to allow Bill Gates to sterilise them using 5G.
[dead]
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by seanhunter on Friday October 25, 2024 @10:01AM (#41945390)
This sort of willful devil's advocacy doesn't further discussion and is extremely unhelpful. To take your first example, you know and I know that you can tell whether a CD player works. You put in a CD, you press "play", it plays.

If you have some theory as to why that test is inadequate, it's on you to lay your cards on the table and state it so there's something substantive to discuss. Until then you're just trolling.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by thaumasiotes on Friday October 25, 2024 @10:23AM (#41945582)
Why do you think I presented those questions side by side?
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by oneshtein on Friday October 25, 2024 @10:58AM (#41945885)
It looks more convincing this way, especially when your audience know nothing about antibodies. HN is just not you target audience. IMHO, it will work well in a pub after a drink or two.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by seanhunter on Friday October 25, 2024 @10:54AM (#41945844)
I think the reason you presented those questions side by side is that you are trolling. I won't be responding further.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by romwell on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:51AM (#41946441)
>Why do you think I presented those questions side by side?

Perhaps because cowardice prevented you from stating your point clearly, so instead you resorted to vague implications in the form of a question.

A fine tactic which gives the coward a plausible deniability defense when their bullshit is called out: I didn't say that, you said that.

Coupled with other similar techniques, e.g.:

* You know what I mean

* Questions that have actual answers, but are asked rhetorically to make an implication: How many cats are eaten alive each year by immigrants?

* Both-sidesing/false balance (giving equal weight to contradicting points of view, regardless of what the reality has to say)

* Ambiguous implication that can be taken in many ways, depending on how the asker defines the terms: Do you really think the immigrants are helping the economy?

* Non-sequiturs and non-answers

* False dichotomies

* Etc

...this gives the coward a superpower to start a heated discussion, where the coward never actually says anything directly.

Instead, the opponents exert an enormous effort to debunk each leaf on the tree of possible interpretations of the coward's incomplete thought, effectively doing the thinking for the coward in a futile attempt to nail down what point the coward intended to make.

(There is no such clear point, other than I am right and you are wrong).

By the time it becomes clear that no possible interpretation is supported by reality, the coward silently leaves the discussion, and says the same exact things elsewhere, feeling empowered by having made others frustrated.

That frustration counts as a victory in an argument in coward's view, with the assumption that it comes from inability to counter the coward's (unstated, vague, implied) points.

In reality, it's infuriating to have to be made guessing what the other person wants to say, doubly so when they are the one forcing to play that game, which, miraculously, you always seem to lose, because the outcome is invariably "that's not quite what I'm saying" (and what the coward is saying is never directly stated by the coward).

At the same time, this protects the coward from being riduculed for any of the views they're promulgating in the discussion.

This is why the coward never states the views directly, and instead e.g. "presents questions side by side".

If the coward were to say outright "Unlike CD players, there's actually no clear way to say whether vaccines work or not", the coward would be laughed out of the room, and they know it — which is why the resort to implications and rhetorical questions about coward's motivation.

I hope this fully answers the question asked.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by 12_throw_away on Sunday October 27, 2024 @01:47PM (#41964256)
Well said, this is extremely good.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by romwell on Monday October 28, 2024 @07:17PM (#41977596)
Thank you for this comment!

Sometimes I wonder whether it's worth to write anything of this sort, or am I screaming into the void.

Your comment makes it absolutely worth it.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by qup on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:55AM (#41945325)
They're talking about additional functions (side-effects) of vaccines, really. It's secondary to whether they work or not.

We can't tell whether a CD player has a listening device in it, for instance.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by roywiggins on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:22AM (#41945006)
It's not hard to find people who are germ theory truthers. They have alternative "explanations" for why nobody gets polio or smallpox anymore.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by otabdeveloper4 on Saturday October 26, 2024 @02:07PM (#41956548)
No need for scare quotes. Post hoc fallacies aren't proof of work, and anyways there's doubt if post hoc is even true for polio and smallpox.

Way too many confounding factors here, and nobody will risk and experiment with a control group in this situation.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by bongodongobob on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:23AM (#41945015)
Yes.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by gpderetta on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:33AM (#41945108)
That's a common misunderstanding. The mind controlling COVID vaccines are being spread by chemtrails. The 5G signal is only used by pilots to decide when to start spraying.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by nsxwolf on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:07AM (#41945996)
COVID vaccines may "work" but they're pretty lame compared to something like the varicella vaccine where the disease basically disappears of the face of the earth.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by IX-103 on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:21PM (#41946760)
We'll see if varicella stays gone. It's tricky in that it can embed itself in the host genome and come back later. That means that until the last person exposed to the virus dies, we can't really consider it gone. Good luck convincing people to continue vaccinating for a disease no one has seen in a couple decades. Of course, if varicella was able to infect germ-line cells it would be even worse...

COVID on the other hand doesn't have such a mechanism, and just relies on being really contagious. So if everyone would stay up to date in their boosters and continue masking in public places, we may be able to get rid of it in a couple of years.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by vlovich123 on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:21PM (#41948060)
> So if everyone would stay up to date in their boosters and continue masking in public places, we may be able to get rid of it in a couple of years.

By that logic we'd have gotten rid of the flu. Vaccines for rapidly mutating viruses like flu and COVID can't keep up and remain an epidemic. The only disease we've actually been able to eliminate worldwide due to vaccines is smallpox. We'd have gotten rid of measles too if crazies hadn't decided the MMR vaccine causes autism due to criminally fraudulent research.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by zehaeva on Friday October 25, 2024 @02:48PM (#41948363)
Didn't one strain of the flu become extinct during the pandemic because we masked up and staying away from each other for a year? One would think that if we just kept that up we'd get rid of all the others.

https://www.npr.org/2024/10/18/nx-s1-5155997/influenza-strai...

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by vlovich123 on Friday October 25, 2024 @04:21PM (#41949277)
It's really hard to draw causal links here. It could be any number of factors or required all of them together. In fact, if that had worked, why didn't COVID or other strains die too? And China had much more severe & prolonged lockdowns but that didn't eliminate anything extra for them.

Don't underestimate the impact of stock viral interference - flu & COVID are both respiratory infections and COVID was much more infectious. Some flu strains probably just couldn't remain competitive with the combined set of other flu and COVID strains.

While masking and social distancing have a beneficial impact on limiting the spread of respiratory diseases, there are practical reasons why it doesn't work to eliminate it altogether and ignores the possibility and likelihood of other resevoirs to reintroduce the disease. For example, if North America remains masked & socially isolated by the virus persists in Europe, then as soon as North America opens up you'll get the virus in North America again. And imaging a simultaneous world wide lock down is a laugh - even during COVID governments were not globally coordinated and even within national governments there was mixed local coordination.

Aside from all that, let's say it was purely a result of masking and social distancing. The consequences of that were quite sever & catastrophic, not to mention that no one actually stayed away vs limited their normal contacts & there were plenty of practical reasons it wasn't possible (e.g. getting groceries). Life involves death & risk and it's pretty clear that even before the vaccines became available many people were not OK with the tradeoff COVID entailed (e.g. Florida).

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by MajimasEyepatch on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:25AM (#41946177)
On the other hand, nearly everyone believes in black holes, and there's no practical use for that information. The difference is that "we pointed a telescope at the sky and saw something" is easier for a layman to understand and requires somewhat less trust than "we did a bunch of complex statistical work on data from a machine you couldn't possibly hope to understand."
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by throwawaymaths on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:08PM (#41946618)
There's a lot of (warranted imo) skepticism there too. Im sorry I can't find the citation but there was a Japanese paper out this year that claimed the ml post processing of the EHT data produces a qualitatively similar image given random data.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by hn72774 on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:00PM (#41946532)
> there's no practical use for that information

The information paradox is closer to us than we think!

Joking aside, another perspective on practical use is all of the technology and research advanced that have spun out of black hole research. Multi-messenger astronomy for example. We can point a telescope at the sky where two black holes merged.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by throwawaymaths on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:19PM (#41946736)
Has that been done?! Iirc there is only one multi messenger observation of LIGO results (of which there have been many) which casts doubt on LIGO
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by hn72774 on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:14PM (#41947303)
It is still nascent according to this https://rubinobservatory.org/news/multi-messenger-astro
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Friday October 25, 2024 @01:38PM (#41947548)
I think this is where it's worth differentiating between different types of "believes in" (and why I think modal logics are cool). I can convince myself that a thing seems safe to believe, or I can tangibly believe it, or I can believe it in a way that allows me to confidently manipulate it, or I could even understand it (which you could call a particular flavor of belief). Practical use seems to fit on that spectrum.

I certainly don't believe in black holes in the same manner that I believe in the breakfast I'm eating right now.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by whatshisface on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:32PM (#41946875)
By that line of reasoning, the moon does not exist.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by throwawaymaths on Friday October 25, 2024 @11:43AM (#41946357)
Yeah. The higgs evidence is pretty convincing visually. Not so sure about LIGO. There is an extraordinary claim of noise reduction that requires extraordinary evidence and it's all obfuscated behind adaptive machine learning based filtering, and the statistical analysis on that is unparseable to a non-expert (that is worrisome). The pulsar timing network though is easily believable.

Luckily, there's pretty simple statistics that one can throw at that once the third detector comes online. Hopefully that comes in before we spend too much money on LISA.

It's basically this, from the article, but from astro:

> Particle physics does have situations where the hypothesis are not so data driven and they rely much more heavily on the theoretical edifice of quantum field theory and our simulation of the complicated detectors. In these cases, the statistical models are implicitly defined by simulators is actually a very hot topic that blends classical statistics with modern deep learning. We often say that the simulators don't have a tractable likelihood function. This applies to frequentist hypothesis testing, confidence intervals, and Bayesian inference. Confronting these challenging situations is what motivated simulation-based inference, which is applicable to a host of scientific disciplines.

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by maxnoe on Friday October 25, 2024 @03:30PM (#41948777)
How do you explain the LIGO detection of a neutron neutron star merger that was at the same time observed as GRB by many, many other telescopes?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW170817

Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by throwawaymaths on Friday October 25, 2024 @08:11PM (#41951341)
That's an n of one (I could be wrong but its the only multi messenger GW event we've seen, with how many events are being generated, you'd have expected more). Could be a coincidence. The angular resolution of LIGO is not exactly amazing, and we don't have a real estimate of the distance to the source of the GW? In fact, IIUC the event could be exactly in the opposite direction too.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by polyphaser on Sunday October 27, 2024 @12:19AM (#41959830)
There's no fancy machine learning needed to detect some "bright" LIGO signals (some of the first blackhole-blackhole mergers). Given a set of template signals, a matched filter tries to find the one that best matches the noisy signal your instrument recorded. In order for a MF to work, what you really need is a good understanding of the noise in your instruments observations -- and there're very few people in the world better at that than LIGO folks. LIGO spent almost 20 years in construction and R&D, and almost 30 in planning. When you hear stories about how they can detect trucks miles away, and detect the waves crashing on the coast, it's possible because of scores of PhD students' who spent years characterizing each and every component that affects LIGO's noise levels. All of this to say that it's possible to download their data online and do a quick MF analysis (I did that), and with a little bit of work you get a blindingly bright statistical significance of 20-sigma or so. The actual result quoted in the papers was a bit higher. That's a testament to how well the instrument was built and its behaviour understood.
Re:Yes, we did discover the Higgs by dguest on Friday October 25, 2024 @12:31PM (#41946859)
I think the gigantic bumps that Kyle pointed to "discovered" the higgs.

The statistical interpretation showing a 5 sigma signal was certainly essential, but I suspect it would have taken the collaborations much longer to publish if there wasn't a massive bump staring them in the face.