News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by snapcaster on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:10AM (#41924163)
Have been following Boeing, watching docs etc. Does anyone have any examples of a company this financialized and hollowed out making a comeback? I'm kind of skeptical it's even possible
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by vasco on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:20AM (#41924252)
It'll be a jobs program and a "compliance as a service" government contract middle man as other late stage big almost-state companies turn out.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by renegade-otter on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:18AM (#41924219)
Let's talk when GE becomes GE again?
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by adventured on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:37AM (#41924419)
Just one piece of GE (GE Aerospace) is worth $200 billion now. The stock has tripled in eight months, with the company tracking to $5-6 billion in operating income and looking very healthy. GE Vernova (energy) is worth another $75 billion and is back in the black after years of losses. It's all probably going to be a lot healthier split up. That might be the case for Boeing as well. It's often the best way to restart failed old conglomerates (no Steve Jobs scenario is going to save Boeing).
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by renegade-otter on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:51AM (#41924553)
I actually didn't know that. It's been a zombie stock for years, so I just stopped checking.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by adventured on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:57AM (#41924611)
Funny enough maybe GE Aerospace should buy the commercial plane division of Boeing. Take the business, engineers, IP and plants, ditch the management.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:04AM (#41925170)
Are we sure the rot hasn't trickled down to the engineering level yet? We know that once upon a time Boeing had great engineers and had an engineering culture but decades of MBA next-quarter management stands between that old company and the current Boeing. While I'm sure many good engineers still go to work for Boeing, what percentage of all the engineers and engineering managers at the company are top quality? Seems like over the decades that attrition, a failing reputation, and a focus on the wrong things would impact the quality of talent the company hired.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by junaru on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:21AM (#41924263)
Wont it just get bought out by the gov/taxpayer because it's a strategic asset etc. ?
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by bell-cot on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:23AM (#41924274)
Maybe add "this large" and "this specializing in long-lead-time, cutting-edge technology" to your conditions.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by mdorazio on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:25AM (#41924297)
Apple was at junk bond status and very close to bankruptcy in 1996 before Steve Jobs came back and turned the whole company around.

Most other success stories involve first going bankrupt (ex. GM, Delta).

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by grobbyy on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:34AM (#41924925)
Didn't think of that.

I think a bankruptcy restructuring would do a world of good for Boeing, the sooner the better. The longer it keeps in this state, the further behind it gets.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by ensignavenger on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:32AM (#41924363)
A move which was partly financed by Microsoft. I don't know that Airbus would finance such a move by Boeing (but perhaps the US Gov will?) or who will "come back" to save the company.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:37AM (#41924426)
Worth noting that Jobs made Apple come around due to the success of pivoting into a completely new and relatively untapped market at the time, the iPod-iTunes combo, which revolutionized the music industry enabling consumers to easily buy and own singles digitally and record studios to sell digitally for the first time, that's where the real genius was that nobody else on the market saw when Napster got shut down.

Had Jobs kept Apple only in the computer business trying to sell colorful expensive iMacs as alternative to cheap gray PCs, they would have long been bankrupt and their carcass devoured by Dell or Lenovo by now.

Boeing doesn't have any other new untapped markets they can enter and dominate. Come to think of it, neither does Apple now. They tried with the Vision Pro VR helmet thingy but that was a massive flop compared to the iPod and iPhone, coupled with the the shut down of their rumored secretive EV program, so they're left keep trying to milk that 30% AppStore fee as long as they can get away with.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by philistine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:11AM (#41925227)
The company was six months to running out of cash when Steve Jobs came back in 1998. The iPod came out in late 2001.

What Steve Jobs did that saved the company was put the hatchet to everything that didn't have an inkling of making cold hard cash. He killed the Newton, destroyed the convoluted product line, and most importantly put the whole company under one P&L statement. That's what saved Apple.

That he then was able to quickly herald a return to portable devices with the iPod is what allowed Apple to become the behemoth it is today. It's useless to pretend to know exactly what would have happened had Apple not made iPod.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:56AM (#41925702)
>That's what saved Apple.

You're forgetting a 150 mil from Microsoft.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by philistine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @11:51AM (#41926296)
That 150 millions was essential, but not for what you think. The money was useful, but Apple cut enough jobs and projets that it did not need it. But Microsoft also committed to continuing to release Office for Mac at the same time.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by fernandopj on Friday October 25, 2024 @10:08AM (#41945465)
The iMac line was already a success even before the iPod. Apple was already becoming a great product company because it was already showing it understood the market better than PC companies.

> In the quarter the iMac shipped, Macintosh computer sales grew year-on-year for the first time since late 1995, and saw the Mac grow its worldwide market share from 3 to 5 percent. Apple went from losing $878 million in 1997 to making $414 million in 1998, its first profit in three years.

SourcE: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMac_G3

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by snowwrestler on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:13AM (#41925243)
The iPod accelerated Apple’s growth but it did not save the company. Apple was already turned around and profitable again before they introduced the iPod.

People want what Boeing sells: airplanes. They just need to make better products, like Apple did.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by grobbyy on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:41AM (#41924977)
Boeing has a lot of untapped markets. It's one of the few companies which can do things which require scale and regulatory changes in aviation.

Technology is where autonomous flying cars, for example, are mostly constrained by regulatory and major capital.

Less ambitious would be things like sleeper planes for long haul red-eyes.

General aviation is a smaller industry, but also ripe for distribution by someone with capital and regulatory connections. It's stuck in 1970-era technology.

I can name dozen of other things Boeing could pull off, if lead by someone like Jobs -- someone with both vision and the ability to execute.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by rob74 on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:14AM (#41925246)
If you want flying cars, please invent a silent, energy-efficient and safe levitation technology first, then we can talk...
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by grobbyy on Friday November 01, 2024 @03:52PM (#42020857)
Silent is hard, but safe and efficient is virtually any modern jetliner. The interesting problem is safe, easy, low-maintenance and cheap.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:46AM (#41925028)
>Technology is where autonomous flying cars, for example

This just sounds like fantasy wishful thinking like Elon's Hyperloop or FSD Model 3 Robotaxis that have been constantly around the corner in the next 6 months for the past 6 years.

>are mostly constrained by regulatory and major capital.

Ah yeah, those pesky regulations about *checks notes*… not killing people. Just like that millionaire "innovator" that got himself and others killed with his carbon fiber submarine who thought he could innovate his way around regulations and engineering process build around decades of accidents and deaths at sea.

Maybe stuff like this shouldn't be left to the move-fast-and-break-things crowd.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by grobbyy on Friday November 01, 2024 @03:51PM (#42020839)
Your notes are quite wrong. Most regulations are not about not killing people with checks notes state-of-the-art-1970-technology.

This is even more true in zoning. There are much better ways to build homes possible, but not when a regulation is phrased in terms of distance between wooden stuffs, rather than safety and durability.

Economies of scale continue to mean that entrenched technologies get used.

Pilot licensing is especially onerous, where control systems allow flight to be a lot simpler, and a lot of very hard-to-fly technologies (like autogyros) can't be brought to mass scale not due to technology but simply due to regulation.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by adventured on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:53AM (#41924575)
Apple isn't left trying to "milk" the app store fee. That's a small fraction of their business. They're doing $300 billion in sales (and $100 billion in profit) in just iPhones, it's the most lucrative single product for a private company in world history (Aramco's oil business and Google Search are the only things that match up). The app store is a moat for the iPhone, not their primary financial success. They could make that app store fee 0% and they'd still generate over $100 billion in op income per year. Then they'd get sued by regulators for anti-trust for not charging a fee, claiming they undercut the competition using the iPhone business profits.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by philistine on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:19AM (#41925281)
Services are roughly a third of the revenue at Apple. Most of the services revenue are taxes on third-party developers, and the payola Google pays Apple for the privilege of Google Search being the default, and to prevent Apple from getting in the search market.

It's where all the revenue growth is at Apple right now. All their hardware businesses are enormous and safe, but basically stagnant. That the majority of revenue is from hardware doesn't mean the future of the company doesn't lie in its ability to extract ever more blood from a stone.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:15AM (#41924745)
>They're doing $300 billion in sales (and $100 billion in profit) in just iPhones, it's the most lucrative single product for a private company in world history

Yeah, but that slice of the market is in decline for them.

"According to Stocklytics.com, iPhone revenue dropped $2.7 billion year-over-year, totaling $85.2 billion in H1 2024."

Makes sense since everyone and their dog already has an iPhone and keeps them for longer than ever meaning selling more iPhones now is more challenging compared to monetizing all the stuff people buy and do on them.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by qup on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:03AM (#41925160)
It moved less than 1%, is that what it says?
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by jajko on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:28AM (#41924317)
One option is for government to step in, cut away the military support branch into a separate company and manage that. Leave the remaining stuff out in the open and either support financially to turn around (like banks in 2008 who then paid back with interest), or let it die due to market forces.

Wondering what consequences all that mean for FAA and its international recognition.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by grobbyy on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @09:45AM (#41925024)
That would be a very, very bad outcome for the free world.

We lost commercial ship yards, and or navy is on a long, slow march to obsolescence. That's messy decades it -- we have a huge lead -- but it's the path we're on.

I don't know the solution here.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by immibis on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @10:10AM (#41925215)
I don't see a problem with the military rotting away.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by InDubioProRubio on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:34AM (#41924383)
You can grow "external" daughter companies that have working "old" practices and get subsizdized by the dying parent, while keeping the MBA infection out as long as possible.
Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by potato3732842 on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @08:46AM (#41924511)
Does it need to be under the same name?

A lot of the "important names" in industrial manufacturing that wound up getting bought by the various industrial conglomerates of the mid 20th century wound up getting sold off when the conglomerates fell apart.

For example IH's agricultural equipment (now a part of CaseIH), construction equipment (now owned by Komatsu) and truck lines (owned by VAG) all more or less continued development and production despite being through a couple owners at this point.

I personally hope it gets split up and Ford winds up buying the passenger airline stuff so we can get a revival of the trimotor nameplate because I like it when reality is funny that way.

Re:Boeing CEO says the company must fundamentally change as ... by class3shock on Wednesday October 23, 2024 @12:28PM (#41926637)
Electric Boat (US navy submarine maker) is trying. They were down to under 5k employees in the 90s (IIRC) after the end of the cold war and significant cuts to defense spending. Now they are probably over 20k and trying to increase production of one type of submarine, add a modified type to the same line, and build a new line for a new type. Not going perfectly but having billions shoved in your pockets sure helps recovery.