It will have consequences far beyond the immediate lawsuit too.
The very concept has basically been iced for a generation and the net is only getting more locked down not less.
Is that legal? Technically yes, in my country. Is it ethical? Debatable, depending on who you’re asking. But for me personally, I have found it to be getting substantially easier to find high quality copies of copyrighted anything in the past 3-5 years compared to 10-15 years ago, so I don’t necessarily agree with the blanket statement that “the net is only getting more locked down.”
[1] I like to use the library as much as possible, if for nothing else than to increase usage numbers to marginally positively decrease the likelihood of finding cuts.
This is basically LibGen / Anna’s Archive. A bit clunky around the download process (maybe things get better if you get a paid subscription though!), but overall it works pretty well.
Not at all. You visit libgen, search for your book, find it (usually available) click one of the two available links for it, click to download, have it download. Done.
It couldn't be easier.
> a jealous amicus brief that the Authors’ Guild settlement would not grant him access to publishing orphan works too
that's not a fair overview of the amicus brief, there are good points there about the process of notifying orphan works rights holders and about the risk of a monopolistic position. I do agree with you on this part though
> the existence of one orphan works clearinghouse would have encouraged Congress to grant more libraries access instead of doing nothing
Edit: I also agree with you that the way the IA subsequently created its e-library was not ideal.
What I meant by “jealous” is that the Internet Archive’s interest was not to improve author notification or to protect foreign authors; it was to provide a competing service under similar or better terms than Google was able to negotiate without spending the time and money that Google did litigating. Kahle wanted what was in Google’s settlement.
And what I meant by “Kahle was wrong” is not that every argument that his lawyers thought up was false; I think the agreement was later amended to fix some issues. My point is that Kahle’s theory of change was wrong. He thought that when the settlement was rejected, then Google would push Congress to create an orphan works law which the Internet Archive could use to publish old books too. As he wrote in his op-ed, “We need to focus on legislation to address works that are caught in copyright limbo. … We are very close to having universal access to all knowledge. Let's not stumble now.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/0... As it turns out, the rejection of the class action settlement did not cause Congress to create an orphan works law. In retrospect, we would have been more likely to get an orphan works law if Google had been allowed to set up a proof of the concept, making the monopoly on orphan works temporary.
https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2016/09/09/libraries-20... https://www.ala.org/news/2019/12/new-ala-report-gen-z-millen...
Sounds legit
For me, I became concerned when they fibbed about why the Internet Archive Credit Union was liquidated. IA alleged it was shut down due to onerous regulations, but the government said IA actually never lived up to their goal of allowing local, low-income folk to sign-up for their service. https://ncua.gov/newsroom/press-release/2016/internet-archiv...
Guess where the first backup copy of the Internet Archive is located.
That ranges from the personal book collection numbering from one to many thousands in private hands, private institutional libraries (the Mechanics Institute in San Francisco is one that comes to mind, many private universities and grammar schools have their own, as do numerous corporations, some of which are catalogued by Worldcat).
Preservation of Western culture, notably the Greek and Roman canons, as well as much literature and knowledge of the Jewish, Byzantine, and Islamic worlds, occurred through religious institutions. Though in some regards those were the governments of the time. Indian, Chinese, and other further East Asian collections were preserved through multiple means.
Book digitisation at US academic institutions (the University of Michigan being a major contributor to both Google Books and HathiTrust) has had its own exctremely combative relationship with commercial publishers, as has the US Library of Congress, which issues US copyright in the first place.
Avoid slurs, it's an HN guideline: <https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html>.
I've used it to track down when wording on a site (for someday relevant to my job) changed, for example.
Maybe. I think that is a pretty optimistic view of congress and our political process. I would argue that having a powerful, rich company with a monopoly to lose would have made passing such a law less likely, not more.
I do think we would have been better off with a Google monopoly on unpublished unclaimed books than with the lack of access we have today.
The article says:
> You’d get in a lot of trouble, they said, but all you’d have to do, more or less, is write a single database query. You’d flip some access control bits from off to on. It might take a few minutes for the command to propagate.
If it's so easy, I'm suprised nobody has done it and accepted the consequences. It seems one of the largest single positive impacts any person could make on the world. Once it's released, it'll never go back in the box. A modern Pandora.
And I agree, someone should do that, because keeping books locked up that the rightsholders can’t be bothered to even attempt to make money from is asinine. Too bad our government doesn’t agree with me, so we’ll just have to wait for it to accidentally walk out the door.
The class as I understand it was the copyright holders of every book in a library, and if approved by the court they can all be legally said to have agreed to the settlement’s terms if they didn’t opt out. Now as with anything legal the whole thing depends on someone’s interpretation of whether it’s ok, but this was a plausible reading of Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
One could file a class action suit on behalf of everyone who ordered a strawberry shake at a McDonald’s in 2023, without ever knowing who or exactly how many they are, and if a judge certified it as a class action and McDonalds cut a deal with those representing the class, the terms would bind them all (except those who explicitly excluded themselves).
For instance, they can spend a lot of effort digitizing an archive they got from a business active from 1890 to 1970 - and then put it all in a single collection, which the public won't get access to until 2070. There's no reason to think the business handled sensitive personal information, but it's too much work to check, so they assume it did. They could classify individual documents according to whether they were actually from before 1920, but that's too much work too.
All of the actual librarians and archivists I know hate this situation - it’s not a job you take if you don’t want people to access things – but that tends to translate into requests for copyright exemptions.
A really big one is orphan works where they have things like digitized music which can’t even be linked to a known copyright holder because it’s unclear who owns it after decades of contract shuffles and acquisitions, where you could potentially solve the problem by changing copyright law to require periodic payments to maintain protected status so someone at, say, Sony would have to cut a check every year to say that they still want to protect some obscure old blues track from 1952 which they don’t even offer for sale any more. I especially liked the proposals linking that to availability for mainstream sale: say that there’s no charge for anything which is normally available on iTunes, Play, Amazon, etc. but you need to pay a fee for works which aren’t available.
I was at Google on a team adjacent to Dan Clancy when he was most excited about the Authors’ Guild negotiations to publish orphan works and create a portal to pay copyright holders who signed up, and I recall that one opponent that he was frustrated at was Brewster Kahle of the Internet Archive, who filed a jealous amicus brief complaining that the Authors’ Guild settlement would not grant him access to publishing orphan works too. In my opinion Kahle was wrong; the existence of one orphan works clearinghouse would have encouraged Congress to grant more libraries access instead of doing nothing which is what actually happened in the 15 year since then.
Since then, of course, Brewster Kahle launched an e-library without legal authorization anyway which will probably be the death of the current organization that runs the Internet Archive. Tragic all around.