News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by rappatic on Saturday September 28, 2024 @08:43PM (#41683929)
Off-topic as far as the article above goes, but do you think it's more likely for global(-ish?) war to erupt because of Europe/Middle East compared to Taiwan? A lot of the discussion around global war pre-2022 was for the late 2020s when China attempts to invade Taiwan. I personally doubt the major global powers will allow the conflicts in Israel and Ukraine to escalate to Western countries actually engaging in combat (but they do seem to want to personally defend Taiwan).
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by _heimdall on Saturday September 28, 2024 @11:12PM (#41684574)
I have been expecting that, if another world war were to kick off, theaters of war would exist both in Europe/Africa/East Asia as well as the Pacific.

A big risk for Taiwan, at least in my amateur view, is China feeling emboldened both by seeing an anemic response to other major conflicts and a West that is already distracted by said major conflicts.

I grew up with the story that Hong Kong was just as off limits to China as Taiwan was. No one came to Hong Kong's defence though, even the British who should be on the hook for that situation just sat by in silence while the Chinese took complete control of HK and installed their own puppet government to manage the transition.

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by whimsicalism on Sunday September 29, 2024 @12:50AM (#41685000)
> I grew up with the story that Hong Kong was just as off limits to China as Taiwan was

Not sure when you grew up but that has been obviously false for at least 40 years

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by PHGamer on Sunday September 29, 2024 @01:14AM (#41685097)
the brits gave up hong kong in the 90s. as soon as that happened no one was expecting them to back the case. however, i suppose the brits were optimistic so they didnt have to have regret about losing a colony.

i think taiwan might get some defense but only cause shit is made there and the west cant pretend the chinese wont flex their power

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by youngtaff on Sunday September 29, 2024 @01:04PM (#41688681)
With the New Territories due to be handed back at the end of their 99yr lease, Britain decided it wasn’t viable to keep the rest of Hong Kong
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by csomar on Saturday September 28, 2024 @11:02PM (#41684527)
War is momentum based. If the US gets dragged in a war with Iran and is also supplying Ukraine with weapons, China might perceive this particular moment as an advantage to start their Taiwan campaign. From there, more countries will see the chaos as an advantage to settle their border disputes. And there you have it, a global world war.
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by benterix on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @06:36AM (#41706644)
> From there, more countries will see the chaos as an advantage to settle their border disputes.

I doubt it. Look at what a "border dispute" did to Russia - they became a global pariah. And modern countries cannot really function in a vacuum, even most stupid/populist leaders know it. Local wars in Africa and the Middle East will continue, that's for sure, but they don't have the potential to become global, at least not now.

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by sudjdkdn on Saturday September 28, 2024 @08:52PM (#41683968)
The most likely reason for war is to move the competition with China onto a military footing rather than an economic one. The US would win the first, and that result would help the second. If you’re seeing western powers gear up for war, it might be to secure their economic future rather than a just intervention
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by FpUser on Saturday September 28, 2024 @09:29PM (#41684120)
So they would start a war and kill people for economy's sake? In this case what make them any different from any other war criminals?
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by knodi on Saturday September 28, 2024 @09:42PM (#41684178)
Ya just don’t buy EU or UK would start ww3. There are much smarter and better economics and influence strategies to play out that are much less bloody to its own population.
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by h18483djdj on Sunday September 29, 2024 @07:19AM (#41686568)
It may not make WW status and they might not be directly involved in fighting it
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by h18483djdj on Sunday September 29, 2024 @07:17AM (#41686561)
I think that’s the point. I’m old enough to remember Bush and Blair wanting UN support for Iraq but ditched the idea when they wouldn’t get it. And young enough that my parent’s generation have never seen a war and so don’t remember why the UN was created in the first place. We live in dangerous times with very poor leaders and politics
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by benterix on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @06:37AM (#41706648)
Yeah Bush seemed surprised nobody wants to join his war. "You forgot Poland!"
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by groby_b on Saturday September 28, 2024 @08:58PM (#41683994)
Some major global powers (i.e. China) have a vested interest in that escalation. Having the US tied down in two other conflicts means significantly less resources.

Which means Middle East and Ukraine are already part of a global-ish war. Proxy wars, so far, but in service of a larger goal. (No, I don't think China necessarily instigated, but they're sure supporting ongoing conflict)

As part of that, I'd also assume that the US nudged the UK to maybe consider their supply chain in case the US can't cover Europe's ass. (They can't, not if they expect a Taiwan conflict)

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by cue_the_strings on Saturday September 28, 2024 @09:22PM (#41684092)
I'm under the impression that time is actually working for China and that they don't really require a war; they'll catch up economically soon enough (5-10y) that a war doesn't benefit them at all, and only the US would benefit from one right now, while they still have a chance of nipping their primacy in the bud.
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by SllX on Sunday September 29, 2024 @12:51AM (#41685001)
If Nationalism weren’t a factor, there is essentially zero reason for the PRC to ever invade Taiwan.

Nationalism is a factor and the PRC is a totalitarian dictatorship. They’re going to go after what they consider their “rogue province” sooner or later, and whether it benefits them economically or not is a footnote.

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by cue_the_strings on Sunday September 29, 2024 @01:26PM (#41688839)
Them being a totalitarian dictatorship doesn't necessarily mean they're stupid. I doubt they would risk their economy just because of Taiwan. They may go after it at some point in the future when the odds are in their favor (because they're obviously not right now), but I doubt it'll be soon.
Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by groby_b on Sunday September 29, 2024 @03:54PM (#41689919)
> Them being a totalitarian dictatorship doesn't necessarily mean they're stupid.

No, but it does mean that they are significantly more prone to irrational decisions. And Xi's not exactly ultra-rational to start with.

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by SllX on Sunday September 29, 2024 @04:15PM (#41690078)
This, and to reinforce this: two things tend to happen with dictatorships: they either face a succession crisis at some point which brings it to its knees, or the existing guy becomes less rational in his old age after a few decades of being surrounded by bootlickers.

The PRC has actually managed to successfully stave off a few leadership crisis’s already, but one of the ways they did so was by moving away from a dictatorship of one and establishing term limits and a model that encourages leadership to think about the next generation and ready a successor. Xi Jinping just re-established a dictatorship of one with an unlimited term length and will presumably serve as the PRC’s strongman dictator for the rest of his natural life creating new opportunities for a succession crisis or for himself to just fall prone to old age. He wasn’t shy about killing off anyone that could have challenged him during his initial election to Premier and associated offices, we have no reason to think he’ll be any different than any other tinpot dictator in history and kill off anyone that looks like they might be gathering too much influence under his rule or looking just a little too eager to be his successor.

Re:Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes by groby_b on Sunday September 29, 2024 @03:51PM (#41689904)
I think we're currently starting to see behind the facade of Chinese economy news. It's not all rosy.

But also: For China, Taiwan is only to a very limited extent about the economy. It is about ideology. For the US, a war now would be a bad idea - only slightly better than it would be a little later. There's an increasing gap in naval abilities (that'll - so the Pentagon thinks officially - close in the 2030s)

That means that we're currently in an unstable time. War is possible, but not a given. Meanwhile, if war happens, the US can't fight on three fronts. And so both Ukraine and the mideast conflicts strengthen China's hand if it comes to war, and weaken the US's. Similarly, an independent EU with at least some manufacturing capability lessens US constraints.

At the moment, things are all about shaping the odds.