News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by diogenes_atx on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @09:49PM (#41653717)
Many of the contributors to this thread are under the wrong impression that the police found the victim's laptop and other items in Marcellus Williams' car. This is not true. According to Wikipedia, the murder occurred in August 1998, but it was not until May 1999 that the victim's family "announced a $10,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction in the case. In response, two individuals, Henry Cole and Lara Asaro, named Marcellus Scott Williams as the culprit."

The wikipedia article continues: "Lara Asaro, the girlfriend of Williams at the time of the crime, gave testimony that Williams had confessed to her... This is after she discovered evidence from the crime scene in Williams' car."

This is an important clarification: The police did not find the victim's property in Williams' car. Rather, Williams' ex-girlfriend, who was incentivized by reward money, claimed, more than 8 months after the crime, that she saw the victim's property in his car.

This is one of the the main reasons that the Innocence Project correctly argues that there is no reliable evidence linking Marcellus Williams to the murder.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Felicia_Gayle

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by MikeAmelung on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:08PM (#41653816)
"The next day, the police searched the Buick LeSabre and found the Post-Dispatch ruler and calculator belonging to Gayle. The police also recovered the laptop computer from Glenn Roberts. The laptop was identified as the one stolen from Gayle's residence."

https://law.justia.com/cases/missouri/supreme-court/2003/sc-...

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by diogenes_atx on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:22PM (#41653890)
The full quote from the article in justia.com states the following: "In November of 1999, University City police approached Asaro to speak with her about the murder. Asaro told the police that Williams admitted to her that he had killed Gayle. The next day, the police searched the Buick LeSabre and found the Post-Dispatch ruler and calculator belonging to Gayle. The police also recovered the laptop computer from Glenn Roberts. The laptop was identified as the one stolen from Gayle's residence."

The only thing linking the laptop to Williams was the testimony of a witness. Even if the witness is telling the truth, he has no way of knowing how Williams obtained the laptop.

By any reasonable standard, all this is extremely flimsy evidence: More than a year after the murder, the police found a "Post-Dispatch ruler and calculator" in the suspect's car that belonged to the victim? And someone testified that Williams had the victim's laptop. And it is on the basis of this pitifully weak evidence that you would justify the execution of Williams, the suspect? Even though, as the Innocence Project correctly observes, there is no direct physical evidence linking Williams to the crime scene, and the DNA recovered from the crime scene does not match Williams?

https://law.justia.com/cases/missouri/supreme-court/2003/sc-...

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by MikeAmelung on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:05PM (#41654133)
I was just helping everyone understand that your important clarification, was in fact, wrong.

Since I wasn't on the jury, I can't say whether or not I would have been ok with the death penalty in this case, although the murder was particularly heinous.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by analog31 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:12AM (#41654480)
As I understand it, you have to be OK with the death penalty, to be on a capital jury.
[dead]
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by encoderer on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:02AM (#41656920)
false.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by partitioned on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:55AM (#41657852)
you mean, true?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by norir on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:46PM (#41661152)
This in and of itself very likely creates a bias against the defendant. For me, there is overwhelming evidence that many innocent people have been executed. To support the death penalty, you seem likely to either not believe in systemic injustice (which means you are also probably more likely to believe flimsy testimony) or accept that innocent lives are a tolerable tradeoff to ensure that some people are executed for their crimes. Both groups seem more likely to convict to me than a random sample.

Personally, I also feel that it is morally wrong to give jurors life and death decision making power. The jurors themselves can be deeply harmed by this if they later learn that they convicted a defendant on the basis of false evidence.

I think the bigger problem though is that the death penalty is too abstract. There are many people who believe that certain crimes are worthy of execution. I don't personally agree, but I accept other's beliefs on that point. But even if I grant the righteousness of execution in certain cases, it seems nearly impossible to implement justly and without heavy costs to society. This includes the costs to the people who must carry out the execution as well as the exceedingly high financial costs relative to other forms of punishment.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by analog31 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:15PM (#41664584)
Indeed, it starts with the judge deciding (without trial or jury) whether capital charges can be brought. Then a capital jury is chosen.

In practical terms, it also requires an incompetent lawyer. Ruth Bader Ginsberg said "No well defended person receives the death penalty." I read that in an article about the one isolated case where she was wrong.

I also suspect that the death penalty corrupts the societies that use it.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by diogenes_atx on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:16PM (#41654195)
Ah, yes, you have corrected a significant error. In my original post, I said the police did not find the victim's laptop or other property in Williams' car. Instead, I should have added: "More than a year after the murder, the police, in response to a tip from Williams' ex-girlfriend (who was incentivized with reward money), searched his car and found a 'ruler and calculator.' "
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by lolinder on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:37PM (#41654303)
If the ruler and calculator in fact belonged to the victim that is an important clarification of your "the police did not find the victim's property in Williams' car", and your reaction is unnecessarily dismissive. Just acknowledge the error and move on, no need for sarcastic defensiveness.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by diogenes_atx on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:52PM (#41654375)
Even if the police were able to establish that the ruler and calculator belonged to the victim, it is merely circumstantial evidence. It does not prove Williams was the killer.

Here is a quick summary of the main issues: (1) There is no reliable evidence that Williams is guilty of the crime; (2) The DNA evidence from the crime scene does not match Williams; (3) Numerous legal experts, including St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney Wesley Bell, argued convincingly that Williams' death sentence should have been commuted to life in prison, at a minimum; (4) A Republican governor ignored the facts and legal opinions and simply murdered Williams.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by lolinder on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:56PM (#41654396)
> Even if the police were able to establish that the ruler and calculator belonged to the victim, it is merely circumstantial evidence. It does not prove Williams was the killer.

I agree. You were still wrong in ways that do matter. Acknowledging it gracefully makes your case stronger, not weaker.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by qingcharles on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:32AM (#41654578)
What percentage of trials rely on circumstantial evidence? It has to be a high percentage.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by xapata on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:12AM (#41654741)
Isn't the jury responsible for determining what's reliable evidence?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by komali2 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:18AM (#41654778)
Kind of, They can also be instructed to ignore certain evidence, or certain evidence can be barred from being shown to them.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by ekidd on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:48AM (#41656422)
Juries absolutely do make errors, including ones which result in innocent people being put to death.

In a number of cases, the Innocence Project has certainly managed to find hard DNA evidence that linked the actual murderer to the crime, resulting in saving people from death row. One of my friends worked on some of these cases. As former law enforcement, he was very much aware of the various ways the system can fail. Police officers commit perjury on the stand, "expert" witnesses use pseudoscience with zero factual evidence (there are processes to prevent this which have gotten slightly better), and there are shockingly terrible public defenders.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by mrgoldenbrown on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:16AM (#41658677)
The jury didn't get to see everything. It certainly didn't get to see the results of dna testing that happened after the trial.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by iphoneisbetter on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:10AM (#41657403)
> Even if the police were able to establish that the ruler and calculator belonged to the victim, it is merely circumstantial evidence. It does not prove Williams was the killer.

It would appear the jury disagreed with you. Cue the liberal bitching about how American justice is broke, blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Same shit, different day, different website.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by amiga386 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:01AM (#41657910)
It doesn't matter how heinous the murder was if you have the wrong suspect.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_DrsVhzbLzU

> Priti Patel: this is about having deterrents...

> Ian Hislop: It's not a deterrent killing the wrong people!

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by graemep on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:25PM (#41660304)
its not a deterrent for multiple other reasons too:

1. most murderers do not expect to get caught if they are acting at all rationally, and do not care if they do not, and, 2. unless you execute a high proportion of people committing a particular crime any one criminal knows they are unlikely to be executed.

I think the Tutu quote at the end of the video.

Most of the rest of the work world has abolished capital punishment, and most of the rest uses it very sparingly. The big exceptions are China and the Middle East. Good company to keep?

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by reginald78 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:49PM (#41661178)
This is the second time in as many days I've seen some one use the argument that the severity of the crime meant the standards for conviction should somehow be less stringent. Sadly, I don't get the impression is an uncommon way of thinking.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by UncleMeat on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:15PM (#41662802)
Horribly, you regularly see this in supreme court cases. Some case has the conservatives denying a significant right to a criminal suspect and the decision will start with a lurid depiction of the crime they were convicted of through the denial of some right.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by BobaFloutist on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:49PM (#41663204)
Sometimes the crime in case isn't actually that bad, so they have to dig for a lurid description of a different crime entirely.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by kbos87 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:54PM (#41665512)
This line of thinking peeks through all the time from otherwise intelligent people. Merely mentioning how heinous a crime was when we're talking about the guilt or innocence of a suspect should immediately kill your credibility. Too bad the criminal justice system doesn't care about that.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by dialup_sounds on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:35AM (#41658237)
In your prior comment you say that Asaro was incentivized by a reward offered in May 1999, but that doesn't agree with waiting for the police to approach her in November.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by mrgoldenbrown on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:26AM (#41658785)
The "approach" by the police was essentially an offer to either testify and get the reward money and have police drop some charges against her, or not testify and face the charges herself.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by wpm on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:16PM (#41653859)
Circumstantial. There are a 1000 different ways he could have obtained those items without committing a murder. Prove that having them is proof positive he killed someone.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tptacek on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:33PM (#41653962)
I don't think we should have capital punishment at all, anywhere, and certainly this is a textbook example of why, but circumstantial evidence is real evidence, admissible in court cases.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by droopyEyelids on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:37PM (#41653982)
This is true, but circumstantial evidence is seldom enough to have the DA bring a case to trial because it is weak evidence.

At least, thats my impression im not a lawyer.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tptacek on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:41PM (#41654006)
My understanding is that the opposite is closer to the truth: most cases are made on circumstantial evidence. Jury instructions apparently tell jurors not to weight it any differently than direct evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by sitkack on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:22AM (#41654806)
What does that mean? That they makeup spurious causal chains and believe that is reality?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tptacek on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:17AM (#41655087)
Just search [missouri model jury instructions circumstantial evidence]. Jury instructions are written in plain English.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by mahmoudimus on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:14PM (#41663467)
This is indeed true. Most cases are made on circumstantial evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tiahura on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:46PM (#41654034)
Actually the instructions tell the jury that how much weight to give to any evidence is up to them.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by aidenn0 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:30PM (#41661004)
Multiple witnesses seeing a suspect run out of a store holding a smoking gun shortly after the store clerk was shot is both circumstantial evidence and plenty for a DA to bring to trial.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by tptacek on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:31PM (#41661013)
I don't think? this is even a real debate. One can want it to be otherwise, but criminal law does not disfavor circumstantial evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by harshreality on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:39PM (#41654322)
I don't think there are 1000 different ways to get both a ruler and a laptop that belonged to the same murder victim.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by atoav on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:25AM (#41654817)
[1] Ruler is in the folded laptop, laptop gets stolen, laptop is sold, ruler inside, buyer is told he can keep the cool ruler.

[2] Murderer specifically tries to pin the murder on someone else. Someone else being prosecuted is a good way to live free after, gifts his laptop and a ruler to the suspect or leaves them somewhere where they are discovered and taken.

Is that unlikely? Is it more unlikely than a murderer keeping the laptop and ruler from a victim, tying him to the murder?

For me this alone would be absolutely insufficient evidence, to sentence someone to death. The ease with which some here would do this shocks me.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by awb on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:36AM (#41655547)
Fair, but the Innocence Project did not argue that the defendant received inadequate representation. So presumably the defense would have had to offer an explanation during the trial and the jury was apparently unconvinced.

Juries can get things wrong, but we’re also just getting the cliff notes of the trial rather than the whole story.

Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by smsm42 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:14PM (#41665634)
Did they ask Williams how the laptop got there? If yes, what did he say? If not, why not?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by trainfromkansas on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:38AM (#41654600)
"Circumstantial" evidence is often stronger than "direct" evidence. e.g. DNA is almost always "circumstantial", yet more modernly maligned eye witness evidence is "direct".
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by Bnjoroge on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:18PM (#41654204)
not the same thing at all lmao
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ... by satiric on Friday September 27, 2024 @02:53PM (#41674261)
"Lara Asaro... gave testimony that Williams had confessed to her" I know very little about this kind of thing, but isn't this hearsay?