Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by wpm on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:16PM
(#41653859)
Circumstantial. There are a 1000 different ways he could have obtained those items without committing a murder. Prove that having them is proof positive he killed someone.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by tptacek on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:33PM
(#41653962)
I don't think we should have capital punishment at all, anywhere, and certainly this is a textbook example of why, but circumstantial evidence is real evidence, admissible in court cases.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by droopyEyelids on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:37PM
(#41653982)
This is true, but circumstantial evidence is seldom enough to have the DA bring a case to trial because it is weak evidence.
At least, thats my impression im not a lawyer.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by tptacek on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:41PM
(#41654006)
My understanding is that the opposite is closer to the truth: most cases are made on circumstantial evidence. Jury instructions apparently tell jurors not to weight it any differently than direct evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by sitkack on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:22AM
(#41654806)
What does that mean? That they makeup spurious causal chains and believe that is reality?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by tptacek on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:17AM
(#41655087)
Just search [missouri model jury instructions circumstantial evidence]. Jury instructions are written in plain English.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by mahmoudimus on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:14PM
(#41663467)
This is indeed true. Most cases are made on circumstantial evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by tiahura on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @10:46PM
(#41654034)
Actually the instructions tell the jury that how much weight to give to any evidence is up to them.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by aidenn0 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:30PM
(#41661004)
Multiple witnesses seeing a suspect run out of a store holding a smoking gun shortly after the store clerk was shot is both circumstantial evidence and plenty for a DA to bring to trial.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by tptacek on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:31PM
(#41661013)
I don't think? this is even a real debate. One can want it to be otherwise, but criminal law does not disfavor circumstantial evidence.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by harshreality on Wednesday September 25, 2024 @11:39PM
(#41654322)
I don't think there are 1000 different ways to get both a ruler and a laptop that belonged to the same murder victim.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by atoav on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:25AM
(#41654817)
[1] Ruler is in the folded laptop, laptop gets stolen, laptop is sold, ruler inside, buyer is told he can keep the cool ruler.
[2] Murderer specifically tries to pin the murder on someone else. Someone else being prosecuted is a good way to live free after, gifts his laptop and a ruler to the suspect or leaves them somewhere where they are discovered and taken.
Is that unlikely? Is it more unlikely than a murderer keeping the laptop and ruler from a victim, tying him to the murder?
For me this alone would be absolutely insufficient evidence, to sentence someone to death. The ease with which some here would do this shocks me.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by awb on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:36AM
(#41655547)
Fair, but the Innocence Project did not argue that the defendant received inadequate representation. So presumably the defense would have had to offer an explanation during the trial and the jury was apparently unconvinced.
Juries can get things wrong, but we’re also just getting the cliff notes of the trial rather than the whole story.
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by smsm42 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:14PM
(#41665634)
Did they ask Williams how the laptop got there? If yes, what did he say? If not, why not?
Re:Who Is Marcellus Williams: Execution in Missouri Despite ...
by trainfromkansas on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:38AM
(#41654600)
"Circumstantial" evidence is often stronger than "direct" evidence. e.g. DNA is almost always "circumstantial", yet more modernly maligned eye witness evidence is "direct".