That is always the issue with alarms. You have a fine line to walk. Too many alarms and people become complacent and learn to ignore alarms. Too few alarms and you don't draw the attention that is needed.
That's enough to anchor "alert == I might find a problem" in the user's mind.
Instead, the failsafe has the effect of merely invalidating the current test, and making the appliance unable to run a test correctly until either power cycled or the appliance's developer executes a secret series of commands that are not shared with us.
So of course an operator of the appliance found a way to feed in a false "I'm here!" with a loop, to trick the appliance into never going into failsafe…
That's for ~6.8% of all tests being false-positive, ~93.2% being true-negative, and ~3 tests that should have triggered failsafe did not.
I don't if you meant it as a counterpoint for what I said, but it really isn't.
The problem is that given any positive at all, the chance it points to a problem is still virtually zero.
If it was 6.8% of all tests as false positives and 2% true positives, probably people wouldn't have silenced the alarm.
If it goes off 8 times a day and 2 of them are true positives, then people have recent memories of having to fix problems pointed by the alarm.
The reduction I am arguing against is: "Historically, extra information and diagnostics that have an error margin results in worse outcomes because we misapply it; therefore don't build these systems."
And the nurses who want decent pay and can do travel nurse, do travel nurse
the headline says we're talking about death: does that mean 1 life was saved for every 156 patients?
>In addition, they had 2 false alarms for each true alarm and ... and possibly increased risk from said interventions
but wouldn't this study have captured any deaths from those interventions, so the 1 out of 156 life-savings was net?
this study was measuring deaths and what you are suggesting would be outside this study, but it could be measured also.
Many researchers go to relative risk because it shows better results!
It came to roughly the same conclusion as the gp comment when provided with the study PDF.
https://chatgpt.com/share/66eb09e3-7a74-8008-afa8-3b60161d24...
(Though obviously this approach still requires you to go and look at the PDF yourself to make sure it isn't making anything up)
Could is doing a lot of work in letting you interpret what it's saying however you like.
Happy to talk about it.
Are you in the Healthcare industry?
It was bs, as usual.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S277265332...
In this case, the absolute risk when measuring for death in the GIM pre-intervention and GIM post-intervention are 0.0215 (2.15%) and 0.0146 (1.46%) with an absolute risk reduction of 0.0069 (.69%).
While the relative risk is 26% across the pre- and post-intervention, the absolute risk reduction is only 0.69% with a NNT (number needed to treat) of 1/156. Which means that 1 patient in 156 was helped by this intervention.
In addition, they had 2 false alarms for each true alarm and could suggest that interventions were performed in patients who did not require it — more tests, medications and possibly increased risk from said interventions.
This shows that the CHARTwatch ML/AI is not helping at all that much clinically.