News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by SoftTalker on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @12:42AM (#41564185)
As a man I find it far easier to have a friendship with another man because the whole sexual element is entirely absent and it seems much easier to find stuff we have in common to talk about.

Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by dailykoder on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:26AM (#41564432)
>Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

That still sounds so alien and crazy to me. My friendship, when I grew up has always been a good mix of men and women. We never cared about that. No one gave a shit if anyone got naked and changed clothes (or for whatever reason). And a few of them had a relationship with eachother. In the friend group there was never anything sexual. We were/are just friends. It's weird to me that people think it ain't possible

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by moribunda on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:40AM (#41564512)
People don't think it ain't possible. Just that it isn't common and there is a sexual tension in the end. And when you are in a relationship there are insecurities.

Your situation doesn't seem "normal".

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by InsideOutSanta on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @04:01AM (#41565442)
>Your situation doesn't seem "normal".

This perspective is so mind-blowing to me. I'm Western European, and all of my male friends have female friends, all of my female friends have male friends. That's what's normal to me. When I hear people say things like "friendship between men and women always has sexual tension," that's what sounds "not normal" to me.

I guess it has a lot to do with cultural norms and gender roles.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by infecto on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @08:22AM (#41566903)
I'm not sure if this was the intention, but while I believe anyone can be friends, the comment about 'if anyone got naked and changed clothes' doesn't seem entirely typical for most cultures.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by InsideOutSanta on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:43PM (#41570456)
When we go skiing, for example, we all change from jeans into Winter clothes outside the car after parking at the resort. I've seen most of my friends in their undies, regardless of gender. It's not sexual, it's just convenient.

I have no idea how common these types of situations are elsewhere.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by moribunda on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @09:06AM (#41567222)
Commenting on such topics on hn makes me want to have some kind of footer with a/s/l/salary/social class etc.

I'm from central/eastern Europe, and I feel a little bit of WEIRD bias [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychology#WEIRD_bias] in many opinions presented here.

I'm not saying it's wrong. I'm just finding myself more and more blocked when it comes to discussing such topics.

Your friends have friends of different sex - I get it, but for how long we would have to debate here to check if there really is no sexual tension there. Where does relationships come from then in those groups? None of those friends become pairs/partners? There are no ex-lovers who after 10-20 years are coming back together from the "friendship phase". Etc.

On the other hand, I never said that there is only sexual tension. Just that it's hard for me to imagine a world where it's not important.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by standardUser on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @10:34AM (#41567994)
Sexual interest is not wholly absent from my mixed gender friendships. But I wouldn't call it "tension" in most cases. Some are people I have been intimate with before, but now that is in the past. Some are now married with children and I am friends with their spouses (and kids) and would never, ever try to inject sex. Some I am not at all attracted to, and some are not at all attracted to me.

And some I hope to someday fool around with!

It's not simple, but the vast majority of the time it is not a problem either. The real problem comes from jealous partners, and I personally would never date someone who is so jealous that they cause problems with my existing friendships.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by InsideOutSanta on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:59PM (#41570657)
Yeah, I agree with that.

For example, I'm friends with most of my exes. We're all in new relationships. I sometimes go out for dinner with one of them to catch up on life and talk. There is no sexual tension at all, because we are in different relationships, so sex is not something we even think about!

If we were both single and an ex would call me and ask if I'm alone tonight and if she can drop by and watch a movie, then that would be a completely different situation, and there very likely would be sexual tension. But this is highly situational and has more to do with circumstances than with the people involved.

Just because I had sex with a person in the past or might in the future or could in theory does not mean that there is constant sexual tension between us.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by kelipso on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @03:05PM (#41571436)
Yeah this is absolutely not normal among most people, probably the vast majority of people.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by standardUser on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @06:03PM (#41573350)
Not normal to be friends with any exes or people you've had sex with? Maybe not too common in ones 20's, but more likely by their 30's or 40's.

Lot's of friendships start with brief dating/hookup that doesn't lead anywhere romantically. And frequently major relationships leave bonds that persist after the relationship ends. I'd be hard pressed to think of ANYONE I know who does not have at least one friendship like that (I'm early 40s).

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday September 18, 2024 @02:34AM (#41576475)
I'm not sure why you are generalizing like that. It's normal for all the people I know in my personal life.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by InsideOutSanta on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:52PM (#41570573)
Maybe I'm just confused about what you mean by sexual tension. If I'm attracted to somebody, I feel out what they think. If they don't feel the same, then that's that. Same the other way around.

If people agree that they like each other, then there is sexual tension, because they both instigate that sexual tension.

If they aren't attracted to each other, then there's obviously no chance of sexual tension in the first place.

For some people I see on the Internet, sex seems to be an overwhelming factor in their lives, and they see all relationships through that lens, but I've never observed that in real life. Sex and romantic relationships are just one part of people's lives, and most friendships are never perceived through that lens.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by dailykoder on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @02:32AM (#41564855)
That's what I learned over the years. But by I appreciate that me and my friends ain't normal.

Edit because I read your other comment: sure there might have been cheating and other sorts of trouble. But iirc envy never played a role.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by maxbond on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:51AM (#41564591)
If being in a relationship without insecurity is abnormal, then I'm happy to be a snowflake.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by moribunda on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @02:27AM (#41564825)
You're dumbing it down.

But I envy you living in a snowflake world without insecurities, cheating, divorces, etc.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by maxbond on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @02:47AM (#41564961)
I'll acknowledge that I speak from a privileged position, but from up here in my ivory tower, I can see that a lasting relationship is necessarily founded on trust.

Sometimes in life we develop defense mechanisms that are self defeating. I bet a lot of us are familiar with the conundrum of the IT department that always says "no." The environment becomes too constrained for work to be done, so the rest of the business develops shadow IT out of necessity.

Telegraph to your partner that it's unsafe to discuss their friendships with the opposite sex with you, and they will start hiding that information from you.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by wiseowise on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @02:48AM (#41564968)
Not the point they’re making.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by RoyalHenOil on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @12:58AM (#41564286)
In my experience, being in a stable monogamous relationship makes it easier to be friends with the opposite sex because it reinforces that it is strictly platonic.

It works especially well if they are also in relationships and if your partner is also in your social circle. Couples hanging out with other couples is a really strong basis for friendship.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by lazide on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:07AM (#41564335)
The last part is key IMO - there are communities where the activity involves spending solitary time alone with the other party, and that tends to be much harder to do stably with opposite sex partners without some kind of sexual relationship forming, regardless of other relationships.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by golergka on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @12:47AM (#41564218)
> Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

That's not a healthy relationship.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by oguz-ismail on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @12:50AM (#41564239)
That's the healthiest kind of relationship.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by RoyalHenOil on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:12AM (#41564364)
If you or your partner are the sort of person who might cheat, then sure I guess. But I personally wouldn't want to be in a relationship where cheating was on the cards and we had to regulate our social lives to prevent it. I don't think that's healthy.

My husband and I have been in a rock solid relationship for over a decade, and we don't have any issues with opposite-sex friendships. It would be weird if we did because it would mean that we couldn't have any mutual friends and share a social life together as a couple. That seems really unnatural and unhealthy to me.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by maxbond on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:16AM (#41564382)
To add, depending on the context, this could also be a sign of controlling behavior. Policing who your partner is friends with is pretty classic controlling behavior, but insisting your partner not be friends with their preferred gender is also "normal" in certain circles. I don't think that's a healthy norm, but it is important context.

For instance, if someone's partner said they couldn't be friends with men/women, and then tried to create distance between them and their family, then I would advise them to leave that relationship immediately. That would be a dangerous situation.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by brailsafe on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:45AM (#41564549)
Seems to me like such an act wouldn't be such a big deal if it wasn't usually surprising. I don't know what it would mean for it to be "on the cards".

Given the right circumstances, even an evidently unlikely scenario can become more plausible in the mind of the other, and you only ever have your own perspective to rely on in terms of what you think those scenarios or the predicate conditions are.

That doesn't mean it will happen or has happened or should be considered as a real possibility, but imo it does mean that if people could control for it, it wouldn't catch them off gaurd, which necessarily depends on it being unexpected.

And maybe any of those thoughts are indicative of being in a bad place relationship wise, it happens from time to time, it can be talked about, things aren't constant forever

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by sethammons on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @03:55AM (#41565398)
I'm honestly surprised your comment isn't grey. Mind adding something to help others understand what you feel is obvious? I am left to assume why you think it is healthy and the only reason i can come up with is "boys and girls can't be trusted around each other" - and lack of trust and lack of contact doesn't feel like a basis for any kind of relationship.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by jimmaswell on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @10:44AM (#41568104)
I always wonder what these people think us bi people are supposed to do, have no friends and never leave the house?
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by consteval on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @01:58PM (#41570647)
In my experience, these types of people have given approximately zero minutes of thinking time to bi people. Or any other kind of person, for that matter. They know their perspective and that's all, and that's how they intend to keep it forever.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by watwut on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @04:02AM (#41565449)
It really is not. It means there is jealousy, possession and lack of trust going on.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @09:57AM (#41567652)
That your partner isn't allowed to associate with 50% of the people on the planet due to insecurity?
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by standardUser on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @10:18AM (#41567824)
> Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

I would never subject myself to that kind of relationship.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by dangus on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @10:43AM (#41568084)
I can't disagree with this more strongly.

It's very easy to leave the sexual element out of your co-ed relationships.

It's very easy to have things in common with the opposite gender.

Women tend to be extremely willing to talk about their feelings while men bottle them up due to societal expectations and gender norms, so women make great friends for men.

If your significant other can't handle you having friends of the opposite sex they are not being reasonable. (It's not like you have to have sleepovers or something!)

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by jimmaswell on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @11:13AM (#41568496)
Precisely, and following their logic a bi person would have to have no friends at all.
Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by pmg101 on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @05:12PM (#41572793)
I THINK that following their logic a bi person would have to have no bi or gay male friends and no hetero or bi female friends.

If I'm understanding that the root of this so-called "logic" is in the threat of mutual attraction with someone other than the partner.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by jimmaswell on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @11:10AM (#41568456)
> Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

What do you suppose a monogamous bi person would do?

All this normalized controlling jealousy out there is so strange and sad to me as someone in open relationships full of bi people. We're happy for each other if someone has a good time when we're apart, we all hang out together and have a good time, even go to furry cons and get up to shenanigans together.

From what I recall of a lecture I once listened to on human sexual behaviors, the drive to at least have encounters with multiple people is very common and makes evolutionary sense as far as adding diversity to your offspring pool.

I'll go as far as to say the expectation of strict monogamy is a repressive social norm that leads to needless heartache and shame from the effects of cheating, on both parties - of course breaking the boundaries of a relationship is one's own avoidable choice, and the cheater is wrong to do so and bears the blame here, but the fact that it's such a common occurance supports the argument here - the repressed urge was so strong it overrode their care for the relationship. How many relationships would have been saved if sex wasn't seen as such a big deal? In the age of contraception, PreP, vaccines, etc. I don't see the value to society in strict sexual monogamy as a norm.

Re:A lonely man in his 30s found community in an unlikely pl... by klyrs on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @04:26PM (#41572341)
> Also, if you are in a relationship, having friendships with other females will likely be a problem.

If you allow a partner this much control over your life, you'll suffer for it. If you're pre-suffering in hopes of landing a partner who will mistreat you, you're missing out on life (and potential healthy partners who expect you to not be a weirdo in the presence of other women). Turns into a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Take note of the other men talking about their successes in this regard before dismissing the concept out of hand. Or, take it from a lesbian: most of my friends are women. If women were hard-wired to hate their partners' female friends, we wouldn't ever show up to a softball game. It's the culture: seek people whose culture provides a stable and healthy basis for life.