Also consider last time US had disarmed people, we did the same thing as Germans did (to the Indians). I'm glad our Jews and Indians are armed to the teeth.
Seems disarming people often turns a rare but continual event into an even worse once a century genocide event.
They weren't "disarmed" you absolute knob. "They" had guns and weapons and fought back against the nazis and lost. It turns out a bunch of civilians with small arms does not actually pose a meaningful threat to a state level military.
What makes this comment so obnoxious, aside from getting all the facts incorrect, is it helps promote this awful notion that you can be immune to state oppression if you just buy a gun. Shockingly, it does not work that way on real life. If you want the state to not oppress people you have to actually put in work to prevent it from happening, because if a state level military is coming to kill you it doesn't really matter how many guns you have in your closet or how cool your black temu tactical gear is. Artillery from 2km away will just kill you.
(Also as far as I know, when the vast majority of native americans died, they had plenty of guns.)
You need to get close to them to check their identity, their Covid passes, or whatever. You need to get close to confiscate contraband. You need to get close to prevent them from organizing and assembling, and so on.
Of course with nuclear bombs and F-16s you can blow everything to bits, but that's not how governments typically oppress people. You generally don't want to exterminate your tax base, you just want them to have the "right" opinions and beliefs.
In the end deploying the artillery in Grozny and elsewhere during the first Chechen war was a pyrrhic victory that ended in years of Chechen independence.
Then there's the alternative as my compatriots saw in the YPG -- small arms bought them enough time to ally with the USA.
I've fought in a non-state militia that held off a nation state, in a civil war. About half the people I met died, but yet, the rest remain. So you're wrong.
>They" had guns and weapons and fought back against the nazis and lost. It turns out a bunch of civilians with small arms does not actually pose a meaningful threat to a state level military.
... Those in the Warsaw ghetto did with smuggled arms, and held out for several days, meanwhile their disarmed brethren did not last nearly as long.
>"They" had guns and weapons and fought back against the nazis and lost
Jews were virtually disarmed in Germany before the genocide started. In conquered states,they occasionally held off longer with smuggled arms. (In some cases like Malka Zdrojewicz, fighting even seems to have possibly save her life as officers admired her courage and sent her to a non-genocide destination.)
Specially given what happened to Native Americans.
I get your point, all disputes are to be settled at gun point in front of the closest coffee shop.
The western world is wild.
Firearm related deaths per 100,000[1]:
Germany: 0.065
US: 4.054 (62.4x higher)
Firearm ownership per 100 people[2]:
Germany: 19.6
US: 120.5 (6.15x higher)
If those stats are to be believed there's approximately 10x firearm deaths per gun in the US compared to Germany.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm...
[2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_civilian...
Then you have safe gun storage, which is mandatory in Germany and is subject to routine inspections.
It is also mandatory to have an ownership license for any type of gun. You will be automatically denied this e.g. if you are formerly convicted of a serious crime, have mental health issues, or a history with drug use or violence. And you need to provide a reason for owning a gun, where "self defence" does not count.
If you can prohibit people from owning guns made for killing lots of other people, and prohibit people who obviously should not own guns from getting them, you've made substantial progress.
Videos of unlicensed Germans doing this are online.
For example I know a guy that has more than 400 firearms. For him it is a business, not a passion, he does not even carry one, but he is giving a wrong impression of gun ownership.
I share your curiosity and have dug into the issue quite a bit, but obviously it's difficult since it's a bit of a taboo topic.