I suppose the thing that people maybe don't agree with is the lack of attribution when llms regurgitate information back at the user. That, and the fact that these services are also overly aggressive when it comes to spidering your site
But unlike search indexing, there is no exchange of value when these LLMs are trained on my content. We all collectively get nothing for our work. It’s theft dressed up as business as usual. I’ll do whatever I reasonably can to avoid feeding the machine and hope some of the ongoing and inevitable legal fights will rein things in a bit.
The people receiving the most value from these models are almost universally not the original content creators. The fact that I can use the model for my own purposes is potentially nice? But I’m not really interested in that and this doesn’t represent what I’d consider a reasonable exchange for using my work. It still drives people away from the source material.
I realize there may be products that may benefit from this. I was just agreeing with the sentiment that I want no part in it.
I realize not all sites fall into this category.
The solution to the problem isn’t AI. The solution is to break Google’s stranglehold on the web by regulating it.
The solution is to get government up to speed by making it contemporary, so it can understand and respond to current issues. Not leaving it up to people who had their time several decades ago and can’t let go.
The only use case I see here would be if it can be poisoned to reject queries about the area and direct readers to the source instead.