A humorous book on the topic of the fact that rural life is mostly just a lot of work, see "Against The Country".
I still cherish sports, music, and dance, but the difference in childhood environment is immediately recognizable in adults.
These being?
I grew up in a lot of different places but the impression I get from my own experiences is that the valuable life lessons of being alone in the woods can be acquired part-time. You don't have to relocate there. And since living totally alone in the middle of nowhere, rather than in a small town surrounded by fields, farms, and forests, is a lifestyle that only recently became possible, I doubt the value of extended isolation. Throughout human history people have gathered into settlements of at least the size of a village. Living alone is totally new.
But regardless, rural != isolated. Children still go to school. This guy lives 10 miles (aka 10 minutes) from a "town", and that town is indeed where people get together.
That's the thing about actual rural living. There are no stoplight (which takes 2 to 4 minutes to cycle) which slows down miles-driven. There are no traffic jams. Everyone is typically doing 60mph. 1 mile per minute. 10 miles is 10 minutes.
I know people that take buses to "do city things", and it takes them > 1 hour to get anywhere. I know others that walk (20+ minutes) or drive (20+ minutes to get a mile away, or to get a few city blocks due to traffic).
"Having houses apart" doesn't mean isolated from other humans. At all. Heck someone with a "few hundred acres" is often within a mile of another house. As a kid, I used to bicycle 10+ miles to see friends in the summer (when there was no school), and why not? And in the winter, you see your friends daily at school.
You're not "living alone" because you're on a 200 acre parcel of land.
A person would need millions of acres to even feel as if they're living alone.
10 minutes for the grown-ups, who can drive whenever they feel like it.
For the 14 year old who can't drive, and whose parents can't drop everything to play chauffeur? That's 40 minutes each way on a bicycle - along single-lane roads with drivers doing 60mph.
Sounds like a recipe for your kid to spend all day behind a screen, to me.
Source: Direct, firsthand experience. The social isolation and countless screen hours did turn me into a great programmer though, so I've got that going for me.
Some 14 years olds drive a paddock-basher (unlicensed car) on not-public farm roads.
Source: Did all of that at 14 well deep in the country ( a good 1,000 km away from anything close to a city )
I didn't have a farmers license, but I was definitely driving our little S10 up to the supermarket for groceries or gas at 14. Never had a issue. I wasn't a menace on the road until I was officially licensed ;)
Teens take risks and there's a known "acturial hump" for increased risk of death in young adult years.
Did this change in the winter? Nope. I still often rode my bicycle to school. On days where there was too much snow I'd have to leave earlier to deal with the hike. Sometimes a friend might notice me and pick me up.
I was definitely the weirdo in school (not a out transgender kid in the 1990's no way), but I still had friends. I wasn't isolated in any way.
Source: Direct, firsthand experience. Guess what. In life, your mileage may vary. Just because you experienced something one way doesn't mean everybody else experiences it the same way.
No wonder you spent hours each day outside :)
We also rode facing traffic. That way you could see a car coming although you can hear one coming for miles. The purpose of seeing was two fold, to see what type of car, and to see of they saw you.
Every kid knew to get over further when a car came, and get over further for wider vehicles.
I grew up in a rural area, 3 miles from the grocery store & post office, a 40 minute drive to the "big" town (20k). My parents end up driving to the "big" town a couple times a week. I always thought this was nuts and looked forward to living in a city where that wasn't necessary.
Now I live on the SF peninsula... and everybody regularly drives 40+ minutes to do things. Just to get dinner, go to Ikea, or take the dog for a walk in a nicer park. It's a 10 minute drive to BART or to Caltrain, too. Unless you truly dedicate yourself to hardcore SF living, your average middle-class Bay Area resident is driving just as much as my rural parents did.
Miles became meaningless - nearly everything I go to is within 5 miles. What matters is total travel time since two locations both 2 miles away from me might be 10 minutes or 90 depending on time of day.
I still see the single digit miles on google maps and “go oh that’s close!” a few times a year just out of habit though.