News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by jameskilton on Saturday August 03, 2024 @04:32PM (#41149044)
Yet ESDF is objectively better because it frees up Q, A, Z, and W to easily be used for other keybinds. The number of people I've seen stretch their pinky down to Left-CTRL for crouch boggles my mind. With ESDF, crouch is A!

Yes, this is a very tiny hill on which to die on, but it's my hill!

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by foresto on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:21PM (#41149348)
> Yet ESDF is objectively better

Subjectively better.

If I were to switch to ESDF, I would have only one key to the right of my index finger in each row, as opposed to two. (I have a split keyboard.) You could argue that I would have two keys to the left of my pinky finger, but I find that reach more difficult.

I would also have a harder time orienting my fingers without looking, because I would no longer have the differently-shaped keys under my pinky to let me know I was in the right place. (The indentation that indicates home position on my F key is subtle, and easy to miss when I'm focused on the action in a game.)

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by admax88qqq on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:18PM (#41149712)
Objectively better on a standard non split keyboard then. Many games assume non split keyboard for default key bindings
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by bigstrat2003 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:51PM (#41149881)
No, still subjectively better. There's no such thing as objectively better when it comes to control schemes. It's all personal preference.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by foresto on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:01PM (#41149925)
What is a "standard" non-split keyboard? What does a game developer's assumptions for default bindings have to do with objectivity?

Also, you have conveniently ignored my last paragraph.

The better mapping is objectively subjective. ;)

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by nailer on Monday August 05, 2024 @01:24AM (#41158374)
It is a keyboard that is not split.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by Talanes on Saturday August 03, 2024 @04:58PM (#41149222)
I have large hands. Left control is the natural resting place of my pinky, while reaching A from an ESDF rest requires I adjust my whole hand to scrunch my fingers closer.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by cwillu on Saturday August 03, 2024 @11:46PM (#41151041)
I've used EADF (not s) for years, and will never go back.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by silon42 on Sunday August 04, 2024 @06:44AM (#41152595)
I touch my palm on the ctrl key, so WASD is more natural.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by pimlottc on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:14PM (#41149307)
ESDF is also more natural to touch-typers as it’s basically the same as the left hand “home position” of ASDF. And it’s easy to locate without looking, since the F key usually has a raised marker on most keyboards.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by throw7 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:31PM (#41149396)
I touch type, but I've always felt WASD more "natural" or comfortable for gaming. I've tried ESDF but can't get used to it... For me I think it really is that the edge of the keyboard helps anchor and give a solid reference for where the hand is and those keys at the edge will be easily hittable by everyone. Also, a lot of times my pinky awkwardly rests inbetween the shift & z.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by orangea on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:42PM (#41149472)
On the other hand, the F key has a bump on it on every keyboard I've recently come into contact with, which could provide an anchor.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by grayrest on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:44PM (#41149485)
As an EDSF gamer (blame Tribes) I agree but I've run into issues with (IIRC) E, Shift, and Space on keyboards that aren't n-key rollover but it's been over a decade since I last owned one. So I think that's the reason for WASD.

FWIW, A is dodge for me and V is crouch.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by corysama on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:46PM (#41149864)
An issue with EDSF that WASD dodged was that some keyboards had groupings that could only register a limited number of key-downs simultaneously. I believe EDSF was in one group. But, WASD spanned two. So, on those keyboards you could get ignored inputs specifically when things were getting frantic.

I've never experienced that myself. Instead, I've been EDSF fo' lyfe because I had so many keybinds in HL1 multiplayer they surrounded those keys on all sides.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by wileydragonfly on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:52PM (#41149892)
Input ghosting. Happens when they don’t use a 1 to 1 switch matrix. Probably some truth to what you’re saying, I could see the column/row inputs being different.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by pdpi on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:45PM (#41149857)
ESDF also has the cute advantage that it has your hand resting in home row position.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by justin66 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:34PM (#41149422)
> objectively better

There actually was a time when computer scientists at Atari studied user interface stuff with game performance in mind. All that ended years before WASD, but it’s worth pointing out that WASD came about as part of a competitive process. It’s not like anyone’s being forced to use something that doesn’t work for them (except on consoles).

> stretch their pinky down to Left-CTRL for crouch boggles my mind. With ESDF, crouch is A!

Because those are the only two conceivable choices…

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by MetaWhirledPeas on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:23PM (#41149736)
> part of a competitive process

Ehhh, sort of. I think people copied it from Thresh (a famous Quake player). It was better than the default, and "good enough" for competition. So a lot of people simply copied it and never thought about it again, especially after games started making it the default.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by justin66 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @10:59PM (#41150873)
I don't believe that competitive players are unwilling to experiment with this stuff to get an edge. On the hand, if someone polled today's competitive gamers to see what they're doing with their keybindings, the results were not published in this article. The author might ascribe more importance to the defaults than is really appropriate.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by rasz on Saturday August 03, 2024 @08:40PM (#41150331)
>computer scientists at Atari studied user interface stuff with game performance in mind

2600 and 5200 controllers say otherwise.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by justin66 on Saturday August 03, 2024 @10:54PM (#41150857)
The point was that there is a way to do "objective" study of Human-Computer Interaction, with game controllers as well as everything else, and then there are random opinions offered as "objective" for no reason other than people not caring about what "objective" means.

But you're right about those controllers being somewhat shit. In fairness to the amazing Atari research labs that were used as part of a perhaps poor comparison, they had nothing to do with the design of those controllers and weren't around long enough to really affect much on the hardware side before their iteration of Atari died. For a couple of years Atari had some amazing researchers, but they would have benefitted from some amazing (or merely competent) senior management as well.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by orangea on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:38PM (#41149454)
You could also just find a way to rebind caps lock, which would accomplish more or less the same thing.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by aquova on Saturday August 03, 2024 @10:09PM (#41150720)
This is exactly what I've done -- Caps Lock is another control. I find I don't use it much for typical keybinds, but very heavily use it in games.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by unshavedyak on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:32PM (#41149410)
Funny, haven't seen esdf mention in ages. I used to use ESDF exclusively. I eventually gave it up though just due to needing to remap it in ever damn game. Plus some wouldn't let me remap, which was even more annoying.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by 0cf8612b2e1e on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:13PM (#41149679)
It is incredible the number of AAA releases which have an abysmal rebinding experience. Like they gave the job to the intern and nobody attempted to try it once. From tutorials which hard code the controls, special modes (driving, UI) which only respect the original, etc.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by maxglute on Sunday August 04, 2024 @03:46AM (#41151798)
Wonder if there's a program that toggles remaps wasd to esdf or whatever template.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by gavmor on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:11PM (#41149289)
First shooter I played at home was Esoteria, with ESDF.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by forrestthewoods on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:18PM (#41150016)
Disagree. If I put my pinky on A for ESDF then I have to rotate my wrist enough such that pressing E is uncomfortable. The natural resting place for my pinky with WASD is on shift, not tab. CTRL is trivial to reach. Tab is more awkward.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by glitchc on Saturday August 03, 2024 @04:45PM (#41149133)
And what a hill at that!
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by nailer on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:14PM (#41149308)
Agreed, but everyone I’ve ever discussed this matter with has called it FEDS vs WADS
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by imp0cat on Saturday August 03, 2024 @04:56PM (#41149207)
So what exactly do you need the QAZW for? With WASD you still have TAB, CAPS, tilde and SHIFT available. Also, crouch is Q, jump is E.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by orangea on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:40PM (#41149458)
I suppose with ESDF you have the two keys Q and W where otherwise only tab would be.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by lupusreal on Saturday August 03, 2024 @05:41PM (#41149463)
Crouching and jumping are usually performed in combination with movement. How do you press Q or E while also using WASD freely?
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by nvy on Saturday August 03, 2024 @06:25PM (#41149746)
For run'n'gun games like Quake, nothing really but for games with more controls like ArmA or Tribes those extra buttons come in handy.

Shield, nade, lean left/right, use item, etc.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by mrob on Saturday August 03, 2024 @07:03PM (#41149932)
Weapon switching is a big part of competitive Quake. Easy-to-reach weapon keybinds give you an advantage.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by nvy on Saturday August 03, 2024 @09:25PM (#41150516)
Sure but aren't they all on the number keys?
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by elabajaba on Sunday August 04, 2024 @02:07AM (#41151426)
Sure, but try hitting 8 without moving your hand from wasd
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by anonCoffee on Sunday August 04, 2024 @08:40AM (#41153150)
Q and E are lean left, lean right!
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by nvy on Saturday August 03, 2024 @04:48PM (#41149147)
The Tribes series showed me the based way of ESDF enlightenment.

WASD is for peasants.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by Terr_ on Saturday August 03, 2024 @09:23PM (#41150504)
> Yet ESDF is objectively better [...] crouch is A!

I think you've forgotten the hardware limitations (rollover/ghosting) that usually made it objectively worse instead, where "A" often wouldn't behave the same as ctrl or shift when multiple keys are being held down.

Being able to strafe while holding crouch is a handicap.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by II2II on Saturday August 03, 2024 @10:47PM (#41150839)
Shift is can be another interesting key to hit. Many non-US keyboards have an extra key between shift and z (or whatever letter takes to place of z in a particular region. Not only are you reaching further to hit the shift key, but the size of the target is not much larger than a normal key.

In countries like Canada, life is even more fun. Most keyboards are of the US variety, yet many laptops come with the multi-lingual variant. Better get used to two keyboard layouts if you're using WASD with shift/control.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Saturday August 03, 2024 @11:57PM (#41151070)
Clearly hasn't learned to use the palm for left ctrl!

/s

I do use the palm though, it is weird, lol

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by silon42 on Sunday August 04, 2024 @06:45AM (#41152599)
me too, just works out well with WASD. It's like an extra finger.
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by xen0 on Sunday August 04, 2024 @04:02AM (#41151865)
And here I am using QWES.

I find it much more ergonomic to have the three fingers on the same row.

And L Ctrl is not a stretch at all. Although for some reason I usually bind L Alt to crouch...

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by fragmede on Sunday August 04, 2024 @01:30PM (#41155059)
Damn, am I the only one that used M1 to go forwards?
Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by tmtvl on Sunday August 04, 2024 @05:45AM (#41152305)
I've been using ESDF (well, .oeu now that I'm using the Dvorak layout, but details) since I was using Azerty keyboards. A (Q on Azerty) for jump, C (J on Dvorak) for crouch, Z (; on Dvorak) for walk, and I've got enough reach for plenty of other keys.

Got started doing that when I played Bungie's Oni, which required editing an INI file to rebind keys.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by animal531 on Sunday August 04, 2024 @06:28AM (#41152513)
My hill is slightly smaller in that I replace D with C, this way I have my thumb on C and I never have to switch keys.

I instead use D as the use key in all games, X for reload, V for crouch etc.

Re:How WASD became the standard PC control scheme by esdf on Sunday August 04, 2024 @08:29AM (#41153112)
I've got to agree with you on this