And it's not black or white. There are lots of people who can contribute a little, but cannot contribute their full share. But we've set up the rules in a way that makes it very difficult for them to work and contribute. If you have income, your welfare often gets cut off completely. That's counter-productive. There are lots of people who should be able to get some of their income from work and some from welfare, and that's the way things should be, a gradual change from "all from welfare" to "all from work".
That's a direct subsidy to people assuming that too little subsidy is supplemented with welfare or food stamps. It may also be an indirect second-order subsidy to a company, but it is first and foremost a subsidy to people.
You can "fix" that problem by eliminating welfare, or by ensuring companies pay enough. Since most of us don't want people to starve, either we're stuck with the problem, where we're distorting the market in a way that incentivizes behavior that harms society, or we level the playing field by ensuring companies pay enough.
How is low wages worse than no wages? I don't get it.
If an employee at the end of the month ends up having some kind of disposable income, that's a great result. If an employee at the end of the month ends up not having some kind of disposable income, but still have their needs met, that's an okay result.
But if they put in as many hours as everyone else and their income dips below some logistical threshold their work becomes unsustainable. Either someone else has to pay for their continued living or they sink. Now since companies figured out that government will help people on the verge of sinking, they would gradually lower pay below the threshold, while government makes up the difference from everyone else's pocket. They would do that, they /are/ doing that, so to combat this government imposes a minimum wage.
Not to say, that there aren't jobs that make sense to be below minimum wage, but the big bad actors force government's hand, just like one liar destroys everyone's trust in everyone else.
If system can not reach this level there is lot to do to fix the system. Setting up minimum wages to level where this happens is one of them.
The other guy gets his apartment paid for by the state, he asks for $10/hr
I need to pay for my apartment so I need $20.
The other guy gets the job and the apartment.
Have this play out a million times across the entire economy.
The problem is adverse incentives that make it more profitable to do things that harm society.
There are employees who can provide enough value to be worth hiring at a cost below minimum wage but not above it. A minimum wage is effectively a statement that they don't deserve a place in the market. The notion that everyone is worth at least minimum wage to whoever is paying them comes from ability privilege. Such people are real.
I hired one last weekend to help paint my house. Perfectly lovely guy but slow of thought and slower of motion. There is no little damage in dignity done by choosing to subsidize such people rather than allowing them to exchange their real work for real value.
Are you saying some people don't deserve respect just because they can't support themselves? I think they should be able to work and contribute as well, saying we don't need them just because they can't provide for themselves isn't respectful.
But the damage is being done to society at large. By subsidizing that worker, taxpayer dollars are being used to prop up a business that should not exist instead of being spent on productive things like healthcare, education and infrastructure.
Imagine if I wanted to buy a Porsche, but decided it wasn’t worth the asking price, so I just pay less and make the government pay the rest like I have some right to have one just because. That is exactly what businesses are doing when they pay employees so little they require government assistance to live.
Here on HN it gets downvoted, because I assume the average user is the business owner (or very much aspires to be) who is doing the exploiting.
No every job and not every company should exist. If your job can't provide minimum wage then either your business in not productive enough to deserve place in the market or you are exploiting your employees.