Yes, “ at “ was still in use. ISTR typing ‘@‘ but this was a long time ago (I didn’t get to the AI lab until ‘78 by when EMACS was well entrenched).
This was pre TCP, pre RFC 733, pre DNS etc. I don’t remember if mail already had its own transport or if mail was still a special mode of the FTP protocol. I think that was still being argued over.
Here is a very early map of the routers.
https://groups.google.com/g/net.general/c/u1dxxNcTIX0/m/mHMW...
unfortunately 'show original message' is grayed out, so i can't actually see the map
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incompatible_Timesharing_Syste...>
Of course, especially given its relative simplicity, at some point non-UNIX systems started to implement it (I think I maybe used some DOS package at some point).
_some poking around in Wikipedia_
Indeed, FTP is from 1971 and UUCP is from 1979. And the SMTP page describes that it all started as a mode in FTP.
https://github.com/larsbrinkhoff/mldev
>MLDEV
>The "ML Device" protocol is a remote file system invented for the PDP-10 MIT Incompatible Timesharing System. It may have been the very first transparent networking filesystem.
>Build: Install libfuse-dev, then type make.
>Usage: Create a mount point directory, and then mount an ITS file system like this:
>sudo ./mount.mldev <hostname> <mountpoint>
What are some early network file systems?
https://retrocomputing.stackexchange.com/questions/13709/wha...
>I know it's always hard to define an exact first, so I'll just ask about early network file systems. To be more specific, I'm wondering about file systems that transparently present directories and files as if they were local. I don't consider FTP or similar mechanisms to be candidates.
>For some time it has been my suspicion that the ITS "MLDEV" facility was very early ("the first"), but I never had any facts to back it up. I do have a file timestamped November 1972 that gives us an upper bound for the introduction of the facility. On the MIT-AI PDP-10, it provided an ML device (hence the name) which worked much like the local DSK device except the data was accessed through MIT's ARPANET IMP. MIT-ML of course had an AI device.
>Present evidence is that ITS had a very early networked file system no later than 1972.
>ITS has had a facility called the "ML Device", or MLDEV, for a long time. The name probably comes from a time when the users of the older more established computer called AI wanted access to files on the computer called ML. The "device" part is because ITS files are named by four parts: device, directory, and two file names. To access ML files from AI, the device name is ML. Conversely, from ML the AI device is used.
>To date this facility, we can check timestamps from backup tapes. The earliest file called MLDEV is from July 1975. However, if we examine the source code for an earlier ITS version we see that it has built in ML and AI devices that when accessed starts a program called SYS; ATSIGN OTHER. Disassembling this file we can see that it indeed is accepting file operations and sends information across ARPANET. The earliest file with that name has a timestamp from November 1972.
>We know from RFC documents 342, 344, and 366 that AI and ML were first put on the ARPANET in May-June 1972. So MLDEV could not have been in use before 1972.
List of Chaos application protocols:
https://gunkies.org/wiki/List_of_Chaos_application_protocols
Among the many hackerish features of ITS was allowing a user space process to act like a device, not just for a filesystem but as a TTY, which allowed a lot more kinds of terminals to be supported than would fit in the monitor (kernel in today’s parlance).
All in the early 70s.
But even without CRTSTY, ITS gave everyone the ability to reattach to their processes after they got disconnected, and even pass processes like Lisp interpreters and Zork games around from user to user to share like a joint, by detatching and reattaching them to different TTYs!
https://github.com/PDP-10/its/blob/master/doc/_info_/its.pri...
>VIII.B. CRTSTY
>For display terminals which are not handled directly by the system there exists a program called CRTSTY. This provides the software support to permit these terminals to take advantage of their display characteristics. Among the terminals supported by CRTSTY are: ADM3's, Concept 100's, Hazeltine 1500's, Perkins Elmer FOX's, Datamedias, Control Data Corporation 713's, and a host of others. You should try :INFO CRTSTY and :INFO TERMS to see if your terminal is included. If it isn't, the maintainers of CRTSTY are usually willing to help you add it. In the CRTSTY section of INFO the information you must provide to have a new terminal supported is listed. You can communicate with the maintainers of CRTSTY by sending mail to BUG-CRTSTY.
https://github.com/PDP-10/its/blob/master/doc/humor/jargon.6...
>SUPDUP v. To communicate with another ARPAnet host using the SUPDUP program, which is a SUPer-DUPer TELNET talking a special display protocol used mostly in talking to ITS sites. Sometimes abbreviated to SD.
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc734/
>NWG/RFC# 734 MRC 07-OCT-77 08:46 41953 SUPDUP Display Protocol Page 1 Network Working Group Mark Crispin Request for Comments 734 SU-AI NIC 41953 7 October 1977
>SUPDUP Protocol
>This document describes the SUPDUP protocol, a highly efficient display telnet protocol. It originally started as a private protocol between the ITS systems at MIT to allow a user at any one of these systems to use one of the others as a display. At the current writing, SUPDUP user programs also exist for Data Disc and Datamedia displays at SU-AI and for Datamedias at SRI-KL. The author is not aware of any SUPDUP servers other than at the four MIT ITS sites.
>The advantage of the SUPDUP protocol over an individual terminal's protocol is that SUPDUP defines a "virtual" or "software" display terminal that implements relevant cursor motion operations. The protocol is not built on any particular display terminal but rather on the set of functions common to all display terminals; hence it is completely device- independent. In addition, the protocol also provides for terminals which cannot handle certain operations, such as line or character insert/delete. In fact, it is more than this. It provides for terminals which are missing any set of features, all the way down to model 33 Teletypes.
>The advantage over the TELNET protocol is that SUPDUP takes advantage of the full capabilities of display terminals, although it also has the ability to run printing terminals.
https://its.victor.se/wiki/_media/ai_wp_235.pdf
>The SUPDUP protocol [Crispin 77] is a highly efficient display telnet protocol. The advantage over the TELNET protocol is that SUPDUP takes advantage of the full capabilities of display terminals, although it also has the ability to run printing terminals. When you use the SUPDUP protocol, you do not need to tell the remote host which you are connecting to what type of terminal you have or what the terminal's capabilities are. The host you are SUPDUPing from handles the actual display support for your terminal.
>Additionally, SUPDUP defines a network graphics protpcol [Stallman 78] which makes it easy for network hosts to draw pictures along in addition to text.
SUPDUP Graphics Extension:
https://github.com/PDP-10/its/blob/master/doc/sysdoc/grphcs....
You didn't need CRTSTY to implement the SUPDUP protocol, but CRTSTY translated SUPDUP to standard terminal escape sequences, and provided buffering and optimization. Lisp machines and Knight TVs had their own SUPDUP terminal programs, and I made one for my Apple ][ in Forth.
SUPDUP had a line saving extension that RMS hacked into ITS Emacs, so it can stash lines on the screen in local memory before overpainting them, then almost instantly pop them back on the screen later, so you can scroll back and forth through text really fast at 300 baud (plus Devon McCullough made ZipMod with Huffman encoding to make it even faster on top of that):
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15539983
I wrote a terminal emulator for the Apple ][ + Videx 80 column card in FORTH and reverse polish notation 6502 code, that supported SUPDUP including the line saving protocol that RMS hacked into ITS and EMACS (%TDSAV %TDRES), so Emacs could stash lines on the screen in a memory buffer (on the Apple's bank switched RAM card) and restore them later to paint the screen quickly when scrolling back and forth. (That was great at 300 baud!)
This is just the part of it that interprets SUPDUP codes -- layered on top of the rest of the terminal emulator that emulated H19 (VT52 + character/line insert/delete):
http://www.donhopkins.com/home/archive/forth/supdup.f
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37973838
At 300 baud over a congested ARPA connection, we had a lot of time to think about how to optimize terminal emulation while waiting for the screen to repaint...
When James Gosling later implemented his Unix version of Emacs, he created a super-hot screen update algorithm that automatically took into account the capabilities of terminals and the length of their escape codes and padding required (some slow terminals needed padding when performing line/character insert/delete operations, otherwise they would miss characters. It used dynamic programming to figure out the optimal way of updating the screen, which was really great at low baud rates like 300 or 1200 baud.
Read the paper and display.c code I linked to in the above linked comment, and see the wikipedia page on dynamic programming:
>James Gosling's Emacs screen redisplay algorithm also used similar "dynamic programming techniques" to compute the minimal cost path through a cost matrix of string edit operations (the costs depended i.e. on the number of characters to draw, length of the escape codes to insert/delete lines/characters, padding for slow terminals, etc).
[...]
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37974319
The comments in this old PDP-10 SUPDUP code [5] are hilarious!
SUPDUP on ITS was so smart and opinionated, it had its own ideas about who was a loser and who was a winner, how to figure it out by checking INQUIR entries and relationships, and who it should never or always hassle about net-hopping (hopping through a PDP-10 over the net just to use it as a glorified terminal emulator).
It never hassled gumby or cstacy (because they were free to do whatever they wanted to, like flushing whiny annoying over-entitled alcoholic science fiction writers [1] [2] [3] [4]), but always hassled rms (because it was usually an imposter logging in as rms with password rms just to net hop through the system.)
[...]
;;; these people aren't hassled
wintab: irp x,,[gumby,alan,cstacy,cent,devon,dph,oaf,mly,jtw,jnc,klotz,cbf,sra,ed,swa,map,jbvb]
sixbit/x/
termin
winlen==.-wintab
;;; These people are always hassled
lostab: irp x,,[tk,hewitt,rms]
sixbit/x/
termin
loslen==.-lostab
[...]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37974319
[1] http://www.stormtiger.org/bob/humor/pournell/story.html
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15206151
[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37723853
[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37780515
[5] https://github.com/PDP-10/its/blob/master/src/sysnet/supdup....
I was able to unplug the USB-serial adapter from the embedded device's USB port. Then plug in a different USB-serial adapter (different chip requiring a different driver). It would obtain the same /dev/ttyUSB<n> device, and you would be back in your session intact. If you were in the middle of a vi edit, you could just Ctrl-L to refresh the screen and keep going.
I begin to understand where Plan 9 got that "other" kind of inspiration.
Speaking of intercept characters, did you know Will Crowther, one of the authors of Adventure, wrote the "Users Guide to the Terminal IMP"? You're in a maze of twisty little IMPs!
https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA014398.pdf
Don Woods, the other author of Adventure, is a great PostScript programmer! I worked with him at Sun on NeWS, but earlier he was DON@AI, so occasionally he'd get weird email intended for me.
Here's his Spider card game for NeWS, entirely written in PostScript:
https://www.donhopkins.com/home/archive/NeWS/news-tape/fun/s...
Maybe you could convert it to run in a laser printer, but it would sure use a lot of paper!
I don’t remember either. Could be an artifact of all the file translation over the years, or even early cruddy OCR.
None of the folks in that list would have been using TIPs — ^R mode was added after KTVs were deployed.
Looking at https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc733 @ was already used behind the scenes in its current meaning, we're probably seeing a nicely human readable version of the emails sent.
Note I did not have the time to read the whole RFC and the above may be wrong.
Two more curiosities:
- The sender’s address uses two at-signs, like NAME@@DOMAIN.
- There are typos where “at” is misspelled “ay”. Glad we don’t have to deal with that.
Ah yes, you'd see those coming out of the ARPANET site run by Arthur Fonzarelli. He also used to moderate rec.motorcycles.
In addition to what gumby wrote, CSAIL still maintains a `finger` server.
We suggest that the text of network mail, whether transmitted over the FTP telnet connection (via the MAIL command) or over a separate data connection (with the MLFL command), be governed by the syntax below:
Example:
From: White at SRI-ARC
Date: 24 JUL 1973 1527-PDT
Subject: Multi-Site Journal Meeting Announcement
NIC: 17996
At 10 AM Wednesday 25-JULY there will be a meeting
to discuss a Multi-Site Journal in the context of
the Utility. Y'all be here.
https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc561RFC 733 (Standard for the Format of ARPA Network Text Messages, 1977) has examples of addresses in both formats and this note: Whenever a message might be transmitted or migrate to a host on another network, full hierarchical addresses must be specified. These are indicated as a series of words, separated by at-sign or "at" indications.
Interesting. I thought Ameria preferred the "M-D-Y" order?
Americans colloquially prefer m/d/yy (slashes) rather than dashes, anyway.
"In 02024, Danny Hillis answered frequently asked questions about The Clock."
I don't know how it's future proof, but that's what I've heard.
But hey, everybody has their small idiosyncratic pet peeves: I've ran twice into the same person here on HN who just can't stand term "x64" because it's "unofficial", but somehow refuses to use e.g. "EM64T" for it as well.
When it comes to this, the gods of Y100,000 will simply wish it with an act of will, and it will come about.
"Home was a couple of thousand light years away, which distance they traveled instantaneously, by an application of will. " -Joe Haldeman, "The Groombridge Effect"
: dev3; cat longnow.c
#include <stdio.h>
int
main()
{
long then = 0;
long long now = 0;
long long long time = 0;
printf("then was %ld, now is %lld, time is %llld\n", then, now, time);
return 0;
}
: dev3; gcc longnow.c
longnow.c: In function ‘main’:
longnow.c:8:13: error: ‘long long long’ is too long for GCC
8 | long long long time = 0;
| ^~~~hn is intended for things like explaining the history of email and demonstrating unexpected uses for the units program https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36988917, not for harassing strangers because you don't like how they format their comments, or (checking your comment history) flaming elon musk to promote the culture war and posting nonsensical disinformation about ebpf
I realize this was before DNS was invented, so I am not surprised by the lack of TLD.