News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by karaterobot on Sunday July 07, 2024 @02:44PM (#40899555)
> Succinctly; socialism within, anarchy without.

Great essay. I feel like I read this 20 years ago, which is the last time I read the Culture novels. My impression at the time, which remains true on reread now, is that the idea that a post-singularity, post-scarcity society would organize itself along something like socialist lines makes no sense to me, and isn't well-supported (by my recollection) in the novels I read. This is a universe where, if you want, you can just fuck off and have your own planet. It's a place where everything is taken care of for you, not through the thoughtful allocation of resources for mutual benefit, but because it's trivially easy for a machine to just give you everything you ask for. There is no need to even think about who owns what, because everyone can usually have what they want, go where they want, do what they want. I see the anarchy, I don't see the socialism.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by huppeldepup on Sunday July 07, 2024 @04:11PM (#40900115)
We have recently developed a system that eliminates scarcity for all digital media. The results is not an ideological re-alignment but a crowbar that locks down the rules of scarcity.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by VagabundoP on Sunday July 07, 2024 @04:18PM (#40900158)
Now fast forward that by 10k years and what does it look like when time has worn down all those legal issues. The digital society is only two generations old at most.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Ekaros on Sunday July 07, 2024 @04:24PM (#40900194)
At the same time we have not yet eliminated scarcity in other areas. Thus some still need digital scarcity to solve their physical scarcity. If physical scarcity in general was solved issue there would be no need to lock down digital media.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by huppeldepup on Monday July 08, 2024 @02:29PM (#40907967)
My gut tells me that elimination of scarcity is going to be a piecewise proces, whereby each step is countered with a lock-in of scarcity rules.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by snapplebobapple on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:42AM (#40912845)
My gut tells me the probability we make it to post scarcity without a calamity (probably human manufactured) that ruins our ability to progress to post scarcity is pretty close to zero.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Ekaros on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:35PM (#40899875)
Haven't gone too deep to Culture. But it does the whole post-scarcity thing much better than Start Trek does. When anyone can basically do anything they want well, apart from getting space ships... And it is all provided for by essence robots if I have understood right. Whole thing does coherently make sense with advanced enough technology. Where as in many other universes it just does not.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by notahacker on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:09PM (#40899710)
It's socialist in the sense that the Minds could just fuck off and have their own corner of the galaxy, but instead devote processor cycles and physical presence to ensuring helpless little oxygen-breathers have everything they need
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by matthewdgreen on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:25PM (#40899813)
In one of the books Banks explains that the Minds were created with a bias to be helpful to humans, and that whenever they did try to create a “neutral” Mind that didn’t specifically care about this, the first thing it would do is fuck right off (to another plane of existence.)
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by gpderetta on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:02PM (#40900817)
In fact in-universe the Culture is considered deviant as a whole by similarly advanced civilizations because, instead of focusing on collectively ascending as a civilization as it is proper, they meddle in the affairs of other civilizations.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by squigz on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:14PM (#40902308)
It's funny to call Subliming "fucking right off." Not inaccurate, but doesn't really have the same ring to it :P
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by abelsson on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:09PM (#40899711)
Economic systems of the 1800s doesn't really make sense in a space based, post scarcity society - economics is after all, the allocation of scarce resources. But I would argue that the ultimate aim of the socialism as envisioned by Marx wasn't government control over the means of production (the "dictatorship of the proletariat") but rather "full communism" where the eventual aim was to make resource allocation unnecessary, which in a way, does hint at a post scarcity society. So I can see the connection to the original Marx. Less so with the so-far practical implementations of socialism.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Bluestein on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:16PM (#40899755)
> where the eventual aim was to make resource allocation unnecessary,

... unnecessary through what? How? I think those are important details ...

PS. Honestly asking. Interested in how you further interpret Marx ...

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by abelsson on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:35PM (#40899871)
Unnecessary though productivity outpacing demand as far as I've understood it.

In Marxism what they call "full communism" is envisioned to be the "final state of humanity" where productivity is described to be higher than the sum of needs and wants - everybody can help themselves to anything from the warehouses. Obviously very utopian, and I'm not sure there ever was any detailed analysis on how a society a would actually function in "full communism" - but I don't think the economics of The Culture would be that far off if you would describe it to someone of those views. Early Marxists were much a bit more practical, more focused on critiquing the practices of their contemporary societies than envisioning the details of their utopia.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Bluestein on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:39PM (#40899902)
> but I don't think the economics of The Culture would be that far off if you would describe it to someone of those views

Seems right up their alley ...

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by s1artibartfast on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:35PM (#40902400)
I think there is a fundamental psychological and social engineering element to Marxism that many socialists gloss over. The end state is one of voluntary labor, contribution and exchange.

human desire can outstrip any gains of productive capacity, and includes factors which can not simply be produced. Marx didn't envision everyone owning palaces and yachts post scarcity. He imagined people having enough to get by with moderate comfort for an 1800's standard of living.

Similarly, in the 1930s, Keynes imagined that humans would live lives of leisure as productivity doubled every 20 years. However, the human hunger for material comforts is bottomless.

I think the truly radical part of Marxist end state communism is the idea that people will outgrow desire for "more" if more is an option.

Without this, there will always be squabbling over who gets what. It is this human drive that draws socialism down into totalitarianism.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by lazide on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:04AM (#40902737)
That also neuters any desire for progress, no?

Like world peace, it’s a cure that would require changes making it worse than the disease.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by s1artibartfast on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:33AM (#40902852)
I dont really see the connection. I dont think that it is necessarily opposed to change, just some level competition and acquisition.

Do you think the drive for progress is or relief from suffering is not an end in of itself?

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by lazide on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:20AM (#40903288)
Because fundamentally, to want more is to want change and an improvement for yourself. Sometimes this is something society thinks is good and appropriate, sometimes not.

In any large group, the way to condition people to not pursue ‘more’ is to punish those who attain ‘more’. Or attempt to do so.

Also known as ‘the nail that sticks out gets hammered down’.

Sometimes this is done via ‘hard’ power, like the police, asset seizures, re-education camps, etc. Other times it is done via ‘soft’ power, like shaming, exile, bullying, false accusations, etc.

And that includes ‘being’ more, or ‘getting’ more.

And to make this work, there of course has to be a group of people who have power over the group to enforce this.

Those people always end up having tools at their disposal which makes them ‘more equal than others’ and hence defacto exempt from ‘not allowed to be more’. So folks who are the type that want more always end up gravitating there.

And since it’s impossible to pull everyone in the population up to the level of the highest member (economically), the easier option inevitably gets chosen - which is mashing everyone (except those with exemptions) down to the lowest level attainable across the entire population. Which is usually quite low.

How else do you think it would work?

This really clearly played out in the USSR, and actively plays out in the Chinese Communist party today, albeit with a lot of leeway given to greed.

There is itself no way to interact with and be present in the world that provides any guarantee of relief of suffering. Existence guarantees a risk of it.

And if someone is hungry, or bored, or in a disadvantaged position, of course they naturally will want more.

And due to the nature of how humans work, hierarchies form and in every venue someone always has ‘more’ and someone always has ‘less’. It could be freedom. It could be beauty. It could be health. It could be money. It could be physical strength. It could be fame.

Also sometimes because they just see the potential for things to be better.

Improving oneself and one’s situation involves desiring to be and have more (fundamentally).

Your assumption that somehow ‘removing the drive to have more’ will somehow remove suffering, is reminiscent of thinking World Peace would make everyone actually happy.

Because the only way to plausibly have world peace would require a massive authoritarian dictatorship covering every square inch of the planet, unaccountable to anyone, with a monopoly on force, that also regularly projects power so everyone ‘gets along’. Which would, of course, eventually also have to use violence to enforce its goals.

But what would ‘getting along’ even mean, when there are major conflicting differences on where a border is, or who gets access to what resources, etc? Or even people with fundamentally conflicted ideas of what ‘true’ is or not?

If there isn’t enough water, or food to go around, who decides who starves or dies of thirst if no one is allowed to fight about it? And if you were one of those picked to starve or die of thirst, what would it take for you to not try to fight it using any means you could find?

For instance, what would it take for Trump and Biden to be ‘at peace’? Or Zelensky and Putin?

So any such force, to ensure peace, would have to either micromanage the world’s population so much it would be a dystopia, or pick and choose ‘the truth’ and murder enough people that no one would have anyone to disagree with anymore, or decide that ‘peace’ just meant something like ‘no one actively nuking anyone’ - in which case the war moves to using a different set of tools.

Either way, the wheel turns.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Bluestein on Monday July 08, 2024 @04:07AM (#40903500)
> plays out in the Chinese Communist party today, albeit with a lot of leeway given to greed.

This is what first came to mind.-

PS. I am inclined to believe - unfortunately - that even if "peace" were to be achieved, men would fight over ... increasingly ideological and vague things, finding any excuse (ie. "Which side of the egg is the "bottom" side ...)

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by lazide on Monday July 08, 2024 @04:13AM (#40903527)
Ah good old ‘first world problems’ as it were.

I’m quite sure you’re right.

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by Bluestein on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:13PM (#40899733)
In a way ownership itself becomes obsolete.-

Not by polítical of sociological design, but through mere irrelevance, obsolescence.-

Interesting ...

Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by ein0p on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:24PM (#40899799)
Not merely socialism, communism. I suspect this is why there isn’t a TV series for it yet.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by arethuza on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:34PM (#40899866)
I found the meme "Fully Automated Luxury Gay Space Communism" recently and thought it was hilarious (pretty sure Banks would have liked it as well) it does rather capture quite a lot about the spirit of the Culture.
Re:A Few Notes on the Culture by Iain M Banks by lucubratory on Monday July 08, 2024 @06:08AM (#40904092)
>It's a place where everything is taken care of for you, not through the thoughtful allocation of resources for mutual benefit, but because it's trivially easy for a machine to just give you everything you ask for.

It's trivially easy for the wealth of Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk to provide for the needs of tens of thousands of people without any appreciable dent in their own wealth, but it doesn't happen because of the political structure of our society. The Culture could easily be a society of near-infinite potential wealth which enforced scarcity the way legal & economic systems in our world enforce scarcity beyond what is naturally present now - from John Deere increasing the costs of agriculture to extract profit to the enforcement of intellectual property laws. Our society has more than enough wealth and industry to provide a home for every person, but we choose to organise our economy in a way that requires homelessness instead - I'm not making a moral judgement, just pointing out that that is in fact a decision our society makes and not just a natural fact of the universe.

The Culture is politically organised to provide for the needs of its citizens, using the labour of those able to provide what is necessary. "From each according to their ability, to each according to their needs" is communism, it's not just a state of things that falls out of a coconut tree once you have enough production.